Takeaways from Wisconsin's season-ending loss to BYU, early March Madness exit
The Wisconsin Badgers saw their 2024-25 season come to an unfortunate end with a 91-89 loss to BYU in the second round of the NCAA Tournament.
BYU, far better than its No. 6 seed indicates, controlled the game through its first 38 minutes. The Cougars built a decisive advantage through relentless offense (Wisconsin's season-high in points allowed), efficiency from the free-throw line (15-of-16, 93.8%) and dominance on the offensive glass (13 offensive rebounds).
That last category jumped off the stat sheet as BYU built an 11-point halftime lead -- the Cougars grabbed 26 total rebounds to the Badgers' 14 in the first frame, with nine offensive boards to Wisconsin's 10 on the defensive end. Where Wisconsin had a perceived advantage in physicality and interior scoring, BYU was better. The same can be said at the free-throw line, arguably Wisconsin's No. 1 strength.
BYU played like the better overall team. That was, until the last two minutes of action.
Wisconsin executed a 9-2 run from the 1:47-minute mark in the second half to 1:00. That cut BYU's lead to just two points, 91-89. The Badgers would eventually get a stop on a possession that lasted 47 seconds. However, John Tonje's heroic bid to force overtime fell just short. As the clock finally hit 0:00, the Badgers' season came to an all-too-familiar disappointing end.
Tonje was sensational in the loss. His performance is one of our major postgame takeaways:
Wisconsin's stars showed up
John Tonje finished with 37 points, four rebounds and four assists on 10-of-18 shooting and 14-of-16 from the foul line. He was sensational. The only real second guess is his decision to hold the ball until the final buzzer, as opposed to attempting a three-pointer with time left on the clock, which would have allowed Wisconsin a chance to foul if the shot missed.
John Blackwell also pitched in 21 points, six rebounds and three assists. He was key in the team's resurgent second-half run. Both he and Tonje did their part on the offensive end.
The same can't be said for some of Wisconsin's other regular contributors, which is our next takeaway.
Wisconsin got next to nothing from its bench
Wisconsin's depth was a clear strength throughout the season, led by veterans Kamari McGee and Carter Gilmore, plus newcomers Jack Janicki and Xavier Amos. On Saturday, those four combined for three points on 1-of-9 shooting. The three points came from Gilmore with 1:47 left in regulation.
The Badgers didn't get enough contributions from typically-dependable players. Another made shot or two from the group would have altered the result.
The Badgers' strengths suddenly turned to weaknesses
While Wisconsin had a chance to win late, the game was nearly lost in the first half when the Badgers allowed nine BYU offensive rebounds, leading immediately to 12 second-chance points. The Badgers also missed four of 11 free throws in the frame. Those two areas symbolize a Wisconsin team that was not at its best throughout the game, especially in key areas where it usually wins.
More notably, the Badgers had developed into a strong defensive team over the course of the season (KenPom No. 25). That progress was erased, as BYU dropped 91 points on 49.2% shooting. Yes, the Cougars shot a red-hot 46.2% clip from three. But many of their shots from distance were wide open. BYU got whatever it wanted on offense and Wisconsin did not find a consistent answer.
The end-of-first-half sequence was a killer
There are numerous 'what-ifs' from the season-ending result. By far the biggest is Wisconsin's significant mistake at the end of the first half.
Wisconsin trailed 44-36 with 20 seconds left in the first half. John Tonje dribbled the ball past half court and passed to Steven Crowl in the post, who threw up an inexplicable shot attempt with 13 seconds left on the clock. BYU grabbed the rebound, dribbled the length of the court and drilled a three-pointer at the buzzer. Wisconsin's mental mistake, whether from Tonje or Crowl, led to a five-point swing. That shift was decisive in a game of such small margins.
It's a heartbreaking end to a fantastic season
Much more will be written about the 2024-25 Wisconsin Badgers over the following weeks and months. But most importantly, despite the heartbreaking result and first-weekend exit, this season should be remembered as a success. The team was picked in the preseason to finish 12th in the Big Ten, that after losing its top three players after the 2023-24 season, two to the transfer portal. Wisconsin got a program-best season from unheralded transfer John Tonje, made a run at the Big Ten regular-season title and revolutionized its offensive approach.
Hopefully, years of upcoming success can allow this season to be viewed as a key turning point, as opposed to just another postseason disappointment.
Contact/Follow @TheBadgersWire on X (formerly Twitter) and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Wisconsin Badgers news, notes and opinion
This article originally appeared on Badgers Wire: Wisconsin basketball BYU tournament game takeaways
Topics
-
Social media reacts to Wisconsin's crushing loss to BYU, early NCAA Tournament exit
Wisconsin dropped a heartbreaker to BYU, 91-89, in the second round of the 2025 NCAA Tournament on Saturday night.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Why is JJ Watt boycotting Tator Tots after Wisconsin basketball's loss to BYU in March Madness second round? We explain.
JJ Watt says he's boycotting Tator Tots for the next 48 hours after Wisconsin basketball's loss to BYU in March Madness. Here's its connection to one of the Cougars' star players.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
March Madness upset predictions 2025: Pick these early NCAA Tournament exits
Who will make early exits in 2025 NCAA Tournament bracket? Our best March Madness upset predictions are in.Yahoo Sports - Mar. 17 -
Wisconsin vs. BYU odds, March Madness predictions: 2025 NCAA Tournament picks from proven model
The SportsLine Projection Model has revealed its BYU Cougars vs. Wisconsin Badgers picks for the second round of the 2025 NCAA Tournament on SaturdayCBS Sports - 1d -
BYU vs. Wisconsin Prediction: Odds, Expert Picks, Betting Trends, and Stats for 2025 March Madness Round 2
BYU Cougars vs. Wisconsin Badgers Game PreviewYahoo Sports - 3d -
In March Madness thriller, BYU gets back to Sweet 16 with 91-89 victory over Wisconsin
BYU withstood a ferocious charge from Wisconsin's John Tonje to hold off the Badgers for a 91-89 victory Saturday that sends the program to the Sweet 16 for the first time since 2011 — the days of ...Yahoo Sports - 1d -
John Tonje's record-setting 37 points vs BYU in March Madness game celebrated despite the loss, social media reactions
Wisconsin basketball's John Tonje scored a program NCAA tournament single-game record 37 points vs BYU in a losing effort.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Tip time, TV channel announced for Wisconsin basketball March Madness second round vs. BYU
The No. 3-seed Wisconsin Badgers will continue their 2025 NCAA Tournament on Saturday with a second-round matchup against the No. 6-seed BYU CougarsYahoo Sports - 3d -
John Blackwell, Wisconsin players react to crushing season-ending loss to BYU
Wisconsin's 2024-25 season came to a heartbreaking end with a 91-89 loss to BYU on Saturday night. John Blackwell and others shared their reactions:Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Three takeaways from Tennessee's win against UCLA basketball in March Madness
A look at three takeaways from Tennessee's win against UCLA basketball in the NCAA Tournament second round.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Michigan State basketball's Big Ten tournament run ends with 77-74 loss to Wisconsin
Michigan State basketball's Big Ten tournament came to an end Saturday with a loss to Wisconsin. Next up, the real March Madness.Yahoo Sports - Mar. 15 -
Jimmer Fredette relishes BYU's return to relevance after watching Cougars in March Madness
Among the throng of blue-clad BYU fans who packed Ball Arena to witness the Cougars' narrow escape against Wisconsin was Jimmer Fredette. BYU's last basketball blue-chipper, Fredette sweated it ...Yahoo Sports - 1d -
RECAP: Wisconsin basketball drops heartbreaker to BYU, is eliminated from NCAA Tournament
The Wisconsin Badgers fell 91-89 to the BYU Cougars in an NCAA Tournament round of 32 thriller on Saturday night.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Missouri basketball was once a Final Four-caliber team. An early March Madness exit hasn't settled
What if? Missouri basketball's season ended at the hands of Drake in the first round of March Madness. The Tigers will grapple with that for a while.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
March Madness: BYU fends off stunning Wisconsin rally, hands Big Ten its first loss after 10-0 start in NCAA tournament
Few saw the final moments of this game coming.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
What's next for UConn after early March Madness exit? Three massive pivot points for Dan Hurley's offseason
UConn has some big decisions to make as it gets an early start to the offseasonCBS Sports - 3h -
What Wisconsin's tournament championship loss to Michigan means for March Madness chances
Wisconsin basketball fell one minute short of a Big Ten Tournament title on Sunday afternoon, narrowly falling to the Michigan Wolverines 59-53.Yahoo Sports - Mar. 16 -
Wisconsin back in March Madness win column, 85-66 over Montana
Wisconsin grinded its way back into the March Madness win column, getting double-digit scoring from five players on the way to an 85-66 victory over MontanaABC News - 3d -
Drake basketball: 3 takeaways from Bulldogs' win over Missouri in March Madness
Here are three takeaways from Drake basketball's win over Missouri in the first round of the NCAA Tournament.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
3 Nets takeaways from 116-110 loss at Bulls
Here are three Brooklyn Nets takeaways from Thursday's 116-110 loss at the Chicago Bulls.Yahoo Sports - Mar. 14 -
3 Nets takeaways from 115-113 loss to Celtics
Here are three Brooklyn Nets takeaways from Saturday's 115-113 loss to the Boston Celtics.Yahoo Sports - Mar. 16 -
3 Nets takeaways from 104-96 loss at Celtics
Here are three Brooklyn Nets takeaways from Tuesday's 104-96 loss at the Boston Celtics.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
3 Nets takeaways from 105-99 overtime loss at the Pacers
Here are three Brooklyn Nets takeaways from Thursday's 105-99 overtime loss at the Indiana Pacers.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
3 Nets takeaways from 108-103 loss at the Pacers
Here are three Brooklyn Nets takeaways from Saturday's 108-103 loss at the Indiana Pacers.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Iowa State basketball: 3 takeaways from the Cyclones' NCAA Tournament win over Lipscomb
Iowa State opened up its NCAA Tournament journey with a first-round win over Lipscomb. Here are three takeaways from March Madness.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
BYU vs. VCU odds, March Madness predictions, start time: 2025 NCAA Tournament picks from proven model
SportsLine's model revealed its college basketball predictions for VCU Rams vs. BYU Cougars on Thursday in the first round of the 2025 NCAA TournamentCBS Sports - 3d -
Georgia basketball fans react after blowout March Madness loss
Georgia basketball fans react after getting outscored 27-3 early, more in loss to GonzagaYahoo Sports - 3d -
'Wisconsin might have gotten the worst draw' in March Madness, says Field of 68 podcast host Rob Dauster
As a result, Rob Dauster has the Badgers falling to BYU in the second round.Yahoo Sports - 4d -
Three Takeaways From Flyers Loss vs. Capitals
There are losses that sting, and then there are losses that frustrate. This one? A little bit of both.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Louisville basketball roster 2025-26: An early look at Pat Kelsey's team for Year 2
After Louisville basketball's loss to Creighton in first found of March Madness, here's an early look at Pat Kelsey's next 2025-26 Louisville roster:Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Kentucky basketball roster 2025-26: An early look at Kenny Brooks' team for Year 2
After Kentucky basketball's loss to Kansas State in second round of March Madness, here's an early look at Kenny Brooks' 2025-26 Kentucky roster:Yahoo Sports - 20h -
Louisville women's basketball roster 2025-26: An early look at Jeff Walz's team
After Louisville basketball's loss to TCU in second round of March Madness, here's an early look at Jeff Walz's next 2025-26 Louisville roster:Yahoo Sports - 15h -
BYU vs VCU schedule, TV channel: How to watch March Madness NCAA Tournament game
What time is the BYU vs VCU NCAA Tournament game? How to watch Cougars vs Rams March Madness game on Thursday, March 20 on TV.Yahoo Sports - Mar. 17 -
Takeaways as Illinois bounces Iowa basketball from Big Ten Tournament
Was this the end for Payton Sandfort and Fran McCaffery? The biggest takeaways from Iowa's loss vs. No. 25 Illinois in the Big Ten Tournament.Yahoo Sports - Mar. 14 -
What does BYU stand for? What to know of Cougars' basketball team amid March Madness run
For fans tuning in to watch BYU basketball's March Madness run, a question may arise: What exactly does it stand for? Here's what to know:Yahoo Sports - 1d -
March Madness Thursday recap: No redemption for bad ACC, rare early exit for Kansas and Calipari vs. Pitino is renewed
The SEC largely held its own on the first day of the NCAA tournament.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Analysis: BYU takes ‘survive and advance’ to a whole different level in wire-to-wire win over Wisconsin
BYU overcame a 37-point performance by John Tonje and got 25 points from Richie Saunders to nip Wisconsin 91-89 in the NCAA Tournament Saturday night in DenverYahoo Sports - 1d -
March Madness 2025: BYU's Dawson Baker ejected for elbowing Wisconsin player in the groin
Any non-incidental contact to the groin is an automatic flagrant 2.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Wisconsin basketball's comeback vs. BYU falls short in second round of March Madness
Graduate guard John Tonje's last-second attempt to force overtime was off the mark and the Badgers lost to the Cougars, 91-89, Saturday night.Yahoo Sports - 1d
More from Yahoo Sports
-
Kevin Lee 'in full training' for potential GFL fight vs. Tony Ferguson, doubts Dillon Danis shows up
MIAMI – Kevin Lee has a feeling he'll end up rematching Tony Ferguson in a few weeks' time. Despite the two not having a booked bout, Lee thinks he'll likely get the call to fight "El Cucuy" since ...Yahoo Sports - 28m -
Kevin Lee 'in full training' for potential GFL fight vs. Tony Ferguson, doubts Dillon Danis shows up
MIAMI – Kevin Lee has a feeling he'll end up rematching Tony Ferguson in a few weeks' time. Despite the two not having a booked bout, Lee thinks he'll likely get the call to fight "El Cucuy" since ...Yahoo Sports - 28m -
Jason Licht gives positive update on Chris Godwin's injury recovery
Jason Licht shares news that every Bucs fan will be happy to hear as it relates to Chris Godwin.Yahoo Sports - 1h -
Lindsey Vonn medals for first time after coming out of retirement, sets record to keep Olympics hopes alive
Lindsey Vonn inched closer to making her Olympic dreams a reality.Yahoo Sports - 3h -
Yahoo Sports AM: The Sweet 16 is set
In today's edition: The men's Sweet 16 is set, the women's tournament has been filled with blowouts, Vonn finds the podium in her comeback, Ingebrigtsen makes history at Indoor Worlds, and more.Yahoo Sports - 3h
More in Sports
-
Why the NBA could be headed for 'worst tanking stretch we've ever seen'
Teams are getting really good at tanking. Can the NBA do anything more to stop it? Here's what's next for the race to the bottom.ESPN - 22m -
From a $765 million signing to the new Evil Empire: The moves that sent shock waves through MLB
Juan Soto got how much!? The Dodgers added how many stars? It's time to get up to speed after a wild winter.ESPN - 23m -
Iowa hires Drake's McCollum as hoops coach
Iowa has hired Drake's Ben McCollum as its next men's basketball coach, the school announced Monday.ESPN - 23m -
Sources: Texas nearing deal with Xavier's Miller
Less than a week after appearing in the First Four of the NCAA tournament, where it lost to Xavier, Texas on Sunday informed coach Rodney Terry that he has been fired, with athletic director Chris ...ESPN - 23m -
Queen's buzzer shot sends Terrapins to Sweet 16
Derik Queen banked in a fadeaway jumper at the buzzer to lift Maryland over Colorado State 72-71 and into the Sweet 16.ESPN - 23m