Supreme Court gravitates toward gun industry in bid to end Mexico lawsuit
The Supreme Court gravitated toward the American firearm industry Tuesday in its fight to end a $10 billion lawsuit brought by the Mexican government over claims the gunmakers are fueling cartel violence.
The case has become a major battle over the scope of the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act (PLCAA), which has provided broad immunity to gunmakers for two decades despite gun control activists’ attempt to repeal it.
At oral arguments Tuesday, the justices posed piercing questions to Mexico’s attorney about claims the country's lawsuit falls under an exception to the 2005 law, raising concerns that accepting that position would cause a flood of litigation against the gun industry.
“How is your suit different from the types of suits that prompted the passage of PLCAA?” Justice Clarence Thomas asked.
It wasn’t only the court’s conservatives, like Thomas, who pressed Mexico.
“I’m just wondering whether the PLCAA statute itself is telling us that we don’t want the courts to be the ones to be crafting remedies that amount to regulation on this industry. That was really the point of the entire thing,” said Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, one of the court’s three Democratic appointees.
“And so to the extent that we're now reading an exception to allow the very thing that the statute seems to preclude, I'm concerned about that,” she continued.
Mexico originally sued seven American firearms manufacturers and one wholesaler in 2021, alleging they aided and abetted violence in Mexico by not doing more stop their guns from falling into cartels’ hands. Most of the companies have since been dismissed from the lawsuit on other grounds, but two remain.
The companies appealed to the justices after a lower court found Mexico’s lawsuit is covered by a narrow exception to PLCAA, which permits lawsuits when a company “knowingly violated” firearms laws and the violation proximately harmed the plaintiff.
“Petitioners’ arguments would rewrite PLCAA and proximate cause law far beyond this case,” said Catherine Stetson, who represented Mexico, at Tuesday's arguments.
Although everyone agrees some guns have ultimately turned up at Mexican crime scenes, several justices raised concerns about a lack of specificity in the lawsuit.
“You haven’t sued any of the retailers that were the most proximate cause of the harm,” noted Justice Amy Coney Barrett, a conservative nominated to the court by President Trump.
“What you don’t have is particular dealers, right?” asked Justice Elena Kagan, another of the court’s liberals. “It’s a pretty — there’s a lot of dealers, and you’re just saying some of them do. But which some of them? I mean, who are they aiding and abetting in this complaint?”
Mexico doesn’t allege the companies were aware of any particular unlawful sale, but the lawsuit claims the industry is liable because of downstream dealers making illegal sales that end up in Mexico. The companies cast Mexico’s argument as an eight-step causal chain, insisting it is too attenuated to claim the exception.
“With respect, there's not a single case in history that comes close to that,” said Noel Francisco, who served as solicitor general during the first Trump administration and represents the firearms companies.
The firearms companies are backed by gun rights groups, including the National Rifle Association, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce, Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.), various Republican lawmakers and 27 Republican state attorneys general. Mexico, meanwhile, is backed by various Democratic members of Congress, gun control groups and 16 Democratic state attorneys general.
A decision in the case, Smith & Wesson Brands v. Estados Unidos Mexicanos, is expected by early summer.
Topics
-
Supreme Court poised to deny Mexico's lawsuit against U.S. gun makers
The case concerns a lawsuit filed by the Mexican government against gun companies seeking accountability for gun violence epidemic.NBC News - 3h -
Supreme Court Appears Skeptical of Mexico’s Lawsuit Against U.S. Gun Makers
A majority of the justices seemed to question Mexico’s claim that it could prove a direct chain linking arms manufacturers to drug cartel violence.The New York Times - 1h -
At Supreme Court, Mexico to Offer Culprit for Cartel Violence: Gun Makers
The dispute focuses on whether Mexico can hold U.S. manufacturers liable for gun violence and comes amid rising tensions between the countries.The New York Times - 1d -
Supreme Court battle spotlights guns trafficked from US into Mexico
In a historic case, the Supreme Court is considering whether American gun manufacturers can be held liable for gun violence in Mexico.ABC News - 8h -
Supreme Court leans toward reviving straight woman's reverse discrimination claim
The Supreme Court appeared likely to allow a woman to pursue a claim that she was discriminated at work because she is straight.NBC News - 6d -
Supreme Court appears sympathetic toward straight woman’s ‘reverse discrimination’ case
The Supreme Court on Wednesday appeared to lean toward reviving a straight woman’s “reverse discrimination” case brought over claims she was passed over for a promotion and demoted in favor of gay ...The Hill - 6d -
Supreme Court declines to intervene for now in bid to fire whistleblower office chief
President Trump removed Hampton Dellinger from his position as special counsel on Feb. 7, but a federal judge ordered him to be reinstated for a short period.CBS News - Feb. 21 -
Supreme Court Rejects, for Now, Trump’s Bid to Fire Government Watchdog
The court’s order indicated that it may return to the issue as soon as next week, when a trial judge’s temporary restraining order is set to expire.The New York Times - Feb. 22 -
Supreme Court unanimously sides with Hungary in Holocaust survivors’ lawsuit
The Supreme Court unanimously sided with Hungary on Friday by rejecting a group of Holocaust survivors’ legal theory that sought to haul the country into American courts to pay compensation. The ...The Hill - Feb. 21
More from The Hill
-
Live updates: Trump to address Congress as Canada, Mexico lash out over tariffs
President Trump will address Congress Tuesday night against the backdrop of newly levied tariffs on the nation's closest trading partners, Canada and Mexico. The leaders of both nations had sharp ...The Hill - 39m -
Texas lt. governor pushes to rebrand New York strip steak
Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick is pushing for the name change of the New York strip steak to the Texas strip steak to give credit to the state's cattlemen and promote the Texas brand.The Hill - 41m -
Americans for Prosperity-Wisconsin rolls out $300K investment in state court race
Americans for Prosperity-Wisconsin (AFP-WI) is rolling out a new investment of $300,000 in the state's Supreme Court race as it looks to support conservative candidate Brad Schimel in the April 1 ...The Hill - 52m -
OPM walks back memo on firing probationary employees, leaving decision to agencies
The Office of Personnel Management on Tuesday updated its guidance to department heads that demanded the firing of federal workers, adding that it's up to the agency on whether to boot their hires. ...The Hill - 1h -
How Trump's new tariffs will affect Americans: 5 things to know
President Trump kicked off a trade war on Tuesday, levying major tariffs on the top three U.S. trading partners — Canada, Mexico and China. He imposed 25-percent import taxes on Canada and Mexico, ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
Live updates: Trump to address Congress as Canada, Mexico lash out over tariffs
President Trump will address Congress Tuesday night against the backdrop of newly levied tariffs on the nation's closest trading partners, Canada and Mexico. The leaders of both nations had sharp ...The Hill - 39m -
Texas lt. governor pushes to rebrand New York strip steak
Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick is pushing for the name change of the New York strip steak to the Texas strip steak to give credit to the state's cattlemen and promote the Texas brand.The Hill - 41m -
Americans for Prosperity-Wisconsin rolls out $300K investment in state court race
Americans for Prosperity-Wisconsin (AFP-WI) is rolling out a new investment of $300,000 in the state's Supreme Court race as it looks to support conservative candidate Brad Schimel in the April 1 ...The Hill - 52m -
OPM walks back memo on firing probationary employees, leaving decision to agencies
The Office of Personnel Management on Tuesday updated its guidance to department heads that demanded the firing of federal workers, adding that it's up to the agency on whether to boot their hires. ...The Hill - 1h -
How Trump's new tariffs will affect Americans: 5 things to know
President Trump kicked off a trade war on Tuesday, levying major tariffs on the top three U.S. trading partners — Canada, Mexico and China. He imposed 25-percent import taxes on Canada and Mexico, ...The Hill - 1h