Supreme Court appears sympathetic toward straight woman’s ‘reverse discrimination’ case
The Supreme Court on Wednesday appeared to lean toward reviving a straight woman’s “reverse discrimination” case brought over claims she was passed over for a promotion and demoted in favor of gay colleagues.
Such a ruling would lower the legal hurdle in many areas of the country for white and straight employees to bring discrimination suits against their employers.
Lower courts ruled against Marlean Ames, who has worked for the Ohio Department of Youth Services for two decades, by finding she must provide more evidence than minority groups to prove her claims, because she is part of a majority group.
At oral arguments Wednesday, a majority of the Supreme Court appeared sympathetic toward Ames’s argument that the additional “background circumstances” requirement goes beyond what Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 requires.
“At the heart of this case, at bottom, all Ms. Ames is asking for is equal justice under law,” said Xiao Wang, Ames’s attorney. “Not more justice, not more justice, but certainly not less and certainly not less because of the color of her skin or because of her sex or because of her religion,”
Conservative Justice Amy Coney Barrett at one point asked Ames’ attorney to respond to Ohio’s contention that lowering the legal standard “is just going to throw the door wide open to Title VII suits because now everybody can say, ‘hey, this was discrimination on the basis of race, gender, et cetera?’”
“I don't think that contention is well taken,” Wang responded.
The case comes amid the backdrop of President Trump’s efforts to broadly crack down on support for diversity, equity and inclusion (DEI) programs. Under both the Biden and Trump administrations, the Justice Department has backed Ames.
Ames started working at the youth services department as an executive secretary in 2004 and received positive reviews and multiple promotions. In 2019, Ames unsuccessfully applied for a promotion to bureau chief. The position remained open for months and was given to a gay woman who did not apply for the job.
Afterwards, Ames says, the department demoted her back to executive secretary and hired a gay man who hadn’t formally applied to take her existing role.
The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals agreed that Ames’s case would meet the usual requirements for establishing a discrimination case if she was part of a minority group. But the court still ruled against her.
Like several other federal appeals courts, the 6th Circuit has held that majority groups must, in addition to those normal requirements, prove “background circumstances” that show theirs is the unusual case where an employer is discriminating against the majority.
“Suppose that the plaintiff said: Look, they discriminated against me because I'm heterosexual, and here are five other instances where they did the same thing,” conservative Justice Samuel Alito pressed Ohio’s attorney.
“Is that going to come in? Is the court going to have mini-trials or mini-summary judgment proceedings on all of these other alleged instances?” Alito continued.
T. Elliot Gaiser, Ohio’s solicitor general, urged the justices to uphold the lower court’s ruling.
“Ohio agrees it is wrong to hold some litigants to a higher standard because of their protected characteristics. But that is not what happened in this case,” Gaiser said.
A decision in the case, Ames v. Ohio Department of Youth Services, is expected by early summer.
-
Supreme Court leans toward reviving straight woman's reverse discrimination claim
The Supreme Court appeared likely to allow a woman to pursue a claim that she was discriminated at work because she is straight.NBC News - 5h -
Supreme Court tackles straight woman’s 'reverse' discrimination case
The Supreme Court will hear the case of Marlean Ames, a straight woman who said she was denied a promotion and demoted in favor of two people who are gay.NBC News - 5d -
Supreme Court may side with Ohio woman on "reverse discrimination" case
The Supreme Court appears poised to side with an Ohio woman who alleges that she was denied a promotion and demoted because she is straight. CBS News' Catherine Cole reports.CBS News - 2h -
Supreme Court Poised to Rule for Straight Woman in Discrimination Case
Justices across the ideological spectrum and lawyers on both sides agreed that an appeals court erred in requiring members of majority groups to meet a heightened burden.The New York Times - 4h -
Supreme Court to hear arguments in "reverse discrimination" case
Marlean Ames is seeking to revive her lawsuit alleging her employer engaged in reverse discrimination when she was denied a promotion and then demoted.CBS News - 1d -
Supreme Court hearing arguments on "reverse discrimination" case
The Supreme Court is hearing arguments on a "reverse discrimination" case after an Ohio woman claimed she was denied a promotion at work because she is heterosexual. CBS News' Jan Crawford reports.CBS News - 6h -
Supreme Court finds 'radical agreement' in employment discrimination case
The Supreme Court seemed to find common ground in a high-profile case brought by a straight woman alleging "reverse" job discrimination in favor of gay people.ABC News - 3h -
Supreme Court to hear case of woman alleging she was demoted because she is heterosexual
The Supreme Court on Wednesday will hear a case that could change how the courts look at discrimination claims in the workplace. Marlean Ames, a state government employee in Ohio, sued, arguing she ...CBS News - 8h -
Supreme Court schedules arguments in case where Trump administration is defending ACA
The Supreme Court on Monday scheduled arguments for April 21 in a case that could decide the legality of the Affordable Care Act’s (ACA) requirement that insurers cover certain preventive ...The Hill - 2d
More from The Hill
-
Donalds responds to DeSantis: 'My record in the state legislature speaks for itself'
Florida gubernatorial candidate and Rep. Byron Donalds (R-Fla.) on Wednesday responded to Gov. Ron DeSantis’s (R) criticism that the congressman hasn’t been a part of conservative victories in ...The Hill - 35m -
3.2 million people get boosted Social Security: Who qualifies for retroactive payments?
A law signed by former President Joe Biden in January is starting to show its impact, as millions of people begin to receive bigger Social Security payments plus back pay.The Hill - 36m -
HUD secretary announcing elimination of rule Trump warned would 'destroy the value of houses'
Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Secretary Scott Turner said he would terminate the Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing (AFFH) rule on Wednesday, repealing the law which was ...The Hill - 37m -
EPA completes phrase one of Los Angeles wildfire cleanup ahead of deadline
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) said it has completed the first phase of the Los Angeles wildfire cleanup, ahead of its deadline. “President Trump set an extremely ambitious deadline for ...The Hill - 41m -
Interior halts employee spending and travel
Click for more from The Hill. {beacon} Energy & Environment Energy & Environment The Big Story Interior halts employee spending and travel The Interior Department has paused spending and travel ...The Hill - 52m
More in Politics
-
Donalds responds to DeSantis: 'My record in the state legislature speaks for itself'
Florida gubernatorial candidate and Rep. Byron Donalds (R-Fla.) on Wednesday responded to Gov. Ron DeSantis’s (R) criticism that the congressman hasn’t been a part of conservative victories in ...The Hill - 35m -
3.2 million people get boosted Social Security: Who qualifies for retroactive payments?
A law signed by former President Joe Biden in January is starting to show its impact, as millions of people begin to receive bigger Social Security payments plus back pay.The Hill - 36m -
HUD secretary announcing elimination of rule Trump warned would 'destroy the value of houses'
Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Secretary Scott Turner said he would terminate the Affirmatively Furthering Fair Housing (AFFH) rule on Wednesday, repealing the law which was ...The Hill - 37m -
EPA completes phrase one of Los Angeles wildfire cleanup ahead of deadline
The Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) said it has completed the first phase of the Los Angeles wildfire cleanup, ahead of its deadline. “President Trump set an extremely ambitious deadline for ...The Hill - 41m -
Interior halts employee spending and travel
Click for more from The Hill. {beacon} Energy & Environment Energy & Environment The Big Story Interior halts employee spending and travel The Interior Department has paused spending and travel ...The Hill - 52m