Which UFAs Should The Penguins Bring Back?

Mar 13, 2025; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Penguins defenseman Matt Grzelcyk (24) shoots the puck against the St. Louis Blues during the first period at PPG Paints Arena. (Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images)

Although the Pittsburgh Penguins shipped out most of their unrestricted free agents before the NHL trade deadline on Mar. 7, there are still a few remaining on the roster.

There's really no telling what President of Hockey Operations and General Manager Kyle Dubas will do in free agency this summer, but it is possible that he decides to bring back some of the UFA stragglers who are currently on the NHL roster.

So which UFAs should they keep around, and who should they let walk?

Matt Grzelcyk

Keep: Yes

This may or may not be a polarizing response, but Grzelcyk's career has found new life in Pittsburgh. The 31-year-old left defenseman has already smashed previous offensive career-highs - his 32 points so far this season have beaten his previous career-best total of 26 - and he has helped revive a pronounced-dead Penguins' power play.

Given that the Pittsburgh's left defensive corps are a bit thin as far as talent right now, it might not be the worst thing to sign him to another one- or two-year deal to help bridge the gap for the younger guys - like Owen Pickering and Emil Pieniniemi - coming up through the system.

Matt Nieto

Keep: No

Nieto's return to play this season after missing nearly an entire year with knee injuries was certainly inspiring. However, his performance over time did not warrant the Penguins keeping him on their NHL roster, as they waived him on Feb. 26.

There isn't really any reason for the Penguins to keep Nieto beyond this season, especially with some young prospects vying for roster spots in 2025-26.

Emil Bemstrom

Keep: Yes

Prior to his latest Pittsburgh call-up on Feb. 27, Bemstrom was enjoying an impressive season in Wilkes-Barre/Scranton (WBS). He put up 21 goals and 46 points in 43 games and was named to the AHL All-Star Classic.

Although he will be 26 next season, Bemstrom is a good depth option to have. He is a proven AHL player and may have a bit more to offer at the NHL level. He has also been pretty effective in generating chances through a short 10-game sample this season.

Bring him back cheap, and he's a decent insurance option - especially in the event of injury or if a younger player needs to be sent back for development at some point during the season next year.

Boko Imama

Mar 21, 2025; Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Penguins left wing Bokondji Imama (14) and Columbus Blue Jackets right wing Mathieu Olivier (24) fight during the first period at PPG Paints Arena. (Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images)

Keep: Yes

Imama is not only a high-energy guy on the ice, he's also someone you want to have in a locker room. His teammates love him, and his positive energy is contagious.

He shouldn't be in the lineup on a nightly basis if the Penguins bring him back. There are younger players who are due for NHL opportunities, and for the type of player Imama is - one of the NHL's few true enforcers - he doesn't need to be in the lineup every night, anyway.

Imama would be fine to bring back as a 13th or 14th forward whose roster spot wouldn't really be hindering a younger player's development.

Joona Koppanen

Keep: No

Koppanen, 27, has enjoyed a pretty decent season in WBS. He registered six goals and 21 points in 53 AHL games, and his two-way conscientiousness is definitely something that has value.

But there are dozens of other Koppanens around the league, including many who are younger. If he returns on a cheap AHL-level contract, that's understandable. But he's the kind of player who - at the NHL level - might block prospects like Vasily Ponomarev, Avery Hayes, and Tristan Broz.

Forward depth in the system is never a bad thing. But bringing Koppanen back certainly isn't a "must."

Other UFA predictions:

Keep:

- C Jimmy Huntington
- RW Marc Johnstone
- D Nathan Clurman

Bookmark THN - Pittsburgh Penguins on your Google News tab to follow the latest Penguins news, roster moves, player features, and more!

Topics

New Penguins Defenseman Earning New Contract

The Pittsburgh Penguins were clear sellers at the NHL trade deadline this season, as they netted a lot of picks and few rostered players.
Yahoo Sports - 4d
3 Takeaways From Penguins Shutout Loss To Golden Knights

The Pittsburgh Penguins (24-31-10) were active leading up to the NHL Trade Deadline. However, their roster adjustments did not help them score a goal against the Vegas Golden Knights. The Penguins ...
Yahoo Sports - Mar. 8
Checking In On Eight NHL Players Moved At Or Before The 2025 Trade Deadline

It’s been a week since the NHL’s trade deadline has passed, and in most cases of traded players, we’ve seen a decent sample size to judge how well or poorly they might be doing with their new team.
Yahoo Sports - Mar. 15
New Bruins Forward Could Be Big Surprise

Before the 2025 NHL trade deadline passes, the Boston Bruins traded Justin Brazeau to the Minnesota Wild. The move was understandable, as Brazeau was a pending unrestricted free agent, and the ...
Yahoo Sports - Mar. 17
Islanders’ third-period outburst overwhelms Penguins

The Pittsburgh Penguins had virtually no margin for error before they played the New York Islanders Tuesday night at PPG Paints Arena.
Yahoo Sports - 5d
Can Penguins Achieve Goal Scoring Feat For Second Time In Crosby Era?

Pittsburgh Penguins prospect Joona Koppanen scored his first NHL goal on Tuesday night against the New York Islanders.
Yahoo Sports - 4d
3 Remaining free agent options for Colts to boost depth at positions of need

If the Colts are still looking to add to their roster prior to the draft, here are a few players at positions of need who could provide a boost.
Yahoo Sports - 21h
Erik Karlsson's power-play goal carries Penguins past Devils, 7-3

Erik Karlsson scored a power-play goal and the Pittsburgh Penguins beat the New Jersey Devils 7-3 on Saturday. Rickard Rakell scored his team-leading 31st goal. Connor Dewar scored twice, and ...
Yahoo Sports - Mar. 15
Five post-NHL trade deadline Bruins storylines to watch

What should Bruins fans watch for after a busy NHL trade deadline? Here's a look at five important storylines.
Yahoo Sports - Mar. 11

Which UFAs Should The Penguins Bring Back?

Matt Grzelcyk

Matt Nieto

Emil Bemstrom

Boko Imama

Joona Koppanen

Other UFA predictions:

Topics

Related

New Penguins Defenseman Earning New Contract

3 Takeaways From Penguins Shutout Loss To Golden Knights

Checking In On Eight NHL Players Moved At Or Before The 2025 Trade Deadline

New Bruins Forward Could Be Big Surprise

Islanders’ third-period outburst overwhelms Penguins

Can Penguins Achieve Goal Scoring Feat For Second Time In Crosby Era?

3 Remaining free agent options for Colts to boost depth at positions of need

Erik Karlsson's power-play goal carries Penguins past Devils, 7-3

Five post-NHL trade deadline Bruins storylines to watch

More from Yahoo Sports

Jason Licht gives positive update on Chris Godwin's injury recovery

Premier League clubs in talks to end transfer window before start of season

Seahawks draft dominant OL in latest 2025 NFL mock draft

College football analyst discusses USC's recruiting and NIL surge

Rams named 'best fit' for Pro Bowl WR Keenan Allen

More in Sports

Sources: Texas nearing deal with Xavier's Miller

Hurley: UConn's historic run ends with 'honor'

Queen's buzzer shot sends Terrapins to Sweet 16

Poch: U.S. has 'time' to fix issues before World Cup

Ole Miss cruises, becomes 7th SEC Sweet 16 team