Two fifth-year option decisions looming for New York Giants
May 1 is the deadline for clubs to exercise the fifth-year option for players selected in the first round of the 2022 NFL draft.
The New York Giants have two such players to make decisions on: Outside linebacker Kayvon Thibodeaux (selected fifth overall) and offensive tackle Evan Neal (selected seventh overall).
Over the Cap recently produced a chart predicting each first-round pick's status and salary based on their performance thus far in the league. The four categories are: Basic, playtime, one Pro Bowl, and multiple Pro Bowls.
Thibodeaux falls into the playtime category. It is calculated from the average of the 3rd to 20th highest salaries at their position over the past five seasons, provided that their snap counts over their first three seasons meet one of the following three criteria: 50% or greater over all three seasons or 75% or greater in two of their first three seasons an average of 75% or greater over all three seasons.
Thibodeaux played 65 percent of the snaps in his rookie season of 2022, 86 percent in 2023 and 54 percent last season, so he qualifies for the playtime rate worth $14.751 million for the 2026 season, fully guaranteed.
Neal falls into the basic category, meaning he did not meet any of the requirements but will be eligible for a fifth-year base salary calculated from the average of the 3rd to 25th highest salaries at their position over the past five seasons.
Neal has largely struggled at right tackle and has played through multiple injuries. Out of a possible 51 regular season games, Neal has only dressed for 29, starting 27. Should the Giants pick up his fifth-year option, it will cost them $16.7 million next season.
The consensus is that the Giants will pick up Thibodeaux's option but decline Neal's. But that has come into question after signing Chauncey Golston in free agency and the real possibility of Penn State edge rusher Abdul Carter being available to them in the draft at No. 3 overall.
Golston could be seen as a replacement for Azeez Ojulari, however. Ojulari signed with Philadelphia recently in free agency.
As for Neal, the Giants would be wise to take their chances. If he happens to break out this season, they'll deal with things next offseason. If he continues to struggle and underperform, they will have made the right decision.
This article originally appeared on Giants Wire: Two fifth-year option decisions looming for Giants
-
Giants and Jameis Winston agree on two-year deal per reports
The former No. 1 overall pick in the 2015 NFL draft has reportedly signed a two-year deal with the New York Giants.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Jameis Winston agrees to two-year, $8m contract with New York Giants
Former Heisman winner joins Giants in two-year contract Winston, 31, joins DeVito as only QBs on New York roster Jameis Winston is ready to take a bite out of the Big Apple. And maybe eat some ...The Guardian - 3d -
Report: Aaron Rodgers may prefer retirement over playing for New York Giants
The New York Giants are patiently waiting for QB Aaron Rodgers to make a decision on his future but that may include retirement over playing for them.Yahoo Sports - Mar. 16 -
NFL Draft 2025: Ranking top 4 options for Giants in first round, including trade up for Cam Ward
What New York could do in Round 1CBS Sports - 6h -
New York Giants named a 'logical destination' for QB Joe Milton III
As they continue their pursuit for quarterbacks, the New York Giants have been named a "logical option" for Joe Milton III.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Report: Russell Wilson sees New York Giants as 'more viable option' than Steelers
Free agent QB Russell Wilson reportedly views the New York Giants as a "more viable option" than the Pittsburgh Steelers.Yahoo Sports - 4d -
Giants host this veteran QB before meeting with Russell Wilson; team still waiting on Aaron Rodgers decision
New York is exhausting all free agent optionsCBS Sports - Mar. 13 -
New York Giants named 'best team fit' for two notable free agent QBs
The New York Giants have been named a "best team fit" for two veteran free agent quarterbacks.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
New York Giants are signing WR Lil'Jordan Humphrey to one-year deal
The New York Giants have agreed to terms with veteran wide receiver Lil'Jordan Humphrey.Yahoo Sports - 4d
More from Yahoo Sports
-
S. Africa take big World Cup lead, but may lose points over Mokoena
South Africa beat Benin 2-0 on Tuesday to lead an African 2026 World Cup qualifying group by five points, but the advantage could be reduced for fielding an ineligible player last week.- Nigeria ...Yahoo Sports - 40m -
Kim Mulkey laments JuJu Watkins injury, calls her 'such a great ambassador of our game'
During a radio appearance on Wednesday, LSU women's basketball coach Kim Mulkey spoke highly about USC's JuJu Watkins after her season-ending injury.Yahoo Sports - 41m -
The Astros brought Cam Smith’s family into the clubhouse to surprise him about making the big-league roster
A moment that Cam Smith will never forget.Yahoo Sports - 42m -
Bills have big plans for Dalton Kincaid after injury-filled second season
Brandon Beane was quick to pump the brakes. It was April 27, 2023 and Beane just traded up two spots to select tight end Dalton Kincaid in the first round of the draft. Not only that, but the ...Yahoo Sports - 42m -
Top 50 people who will impact the 2025 MLB season: Nos. 50-26
From Chandler Simpson to Mike Trout to Fernando Tatis Jr., these are the names to know as the regular season begins.Yahoo Sports - 45m
More in Sports
-
Women's Sweet 16 rankings: UConn is No. 1, USC holds tight at No. 4
The Sweet 16 is set, and there's a new No. 1. But all eyes are on USC and injured JuJu Watkins.ESPN - 40m -
Picks, predictions, key players for every women's Sweet 16 game
Why might every Sweet 16 team win its regional semifinal matchup in Birmingham and Spokane? We predict the winners.ESPN - 40m -
Cal Raleigh contract extension: Mariners locking up star catcher on six-year, $105 million deal, per reports
The deal will buy out Raleigh's first three years of free agencyCBS Sports - 40m -
S. Africa take big World Cup lead, but may lose points over Mokoena
South Africa beat Benin 2-0 on Tuesday to lead an African 2026 World Cup qualifying group by five points, but the advantage could be reduced for fielding an ineligible player last week.- Nigeria ...Yahoo Sports - 40m -
Kim Mulkey laments JuJu Watkins injury, calls her 'such a great ambassador of our game'
During a radio appearance on Wednesday, LSU women's basketball coach Kim Mulkey spoke highly about USC's JuJu Watkins after her season-ending injury.Yahoo Sports - 41m