Texas judge rejects temporary injunction seeking gender testing in NCAA women’s sports
LUBBOCK, Texas − A Lubbock district judge on Tuesday denied a request for temporary injunction that would require the NCAA to impose genetic testing on athletes to determine their sex or have the organization and its affiliates remove the word "women" from women's competition.
In the State of Texas v. the NCAA, filed in December in Lubbock County, state attorney general Ken Paxton says the NCAA has been "engaging in false, deceptive, and misleading practices by marketing sporting events as 'women’s' competitions, only to then provide consumers with mixed sex competitions where biological males compete against biological females."
The suit sought an injunction prohibiting the NCAA from "allowing biological males to compete in women’s sporting events in Texas or involving Texas teams, or alternatively requiring the NCAA to stop marketing events as 'women’s' when in fact they are mixed sex competitions."
In December, NCAA President Charlie Baker told a Senate panel that about 510,000 athletes compete in the NCAA and he knows of fewer than 10 who are transgender.
Judge Les Hatch denied the injunction in Lubbock's 237th District Court.
"I'm not commenting about the NCAA policy, whether it was right or wrong at that time," Hatch told the plaintiffs' counsel, "but you've asked me to order SRY gene testing or remove the word 'women,' but I don't think we're there yet. I don't think SRY testing is going to accomplish with 100% certainty what you want it to. Or at least I didn't hear that it does."
President Donald Trump, on Feb. 5, signed an executive order designed to keep transgender athletes out of women's sports.
Hatch made his ruling at the end of seven hours in the courtroom. Most of the proceedings centered on testimony from women who are recent former NCAA athletes who said they'd been adversely affected by having to compete — in one case, unknowingly — with or against a transgender athlete.
Former Kentucky swimmer Riley Gaines testified by Zoom from Wisconsin. Testifying in the courtroom were former San Jose State volleyball player Brooke Slusser, her mother, Kim Slusser, former North Carolina State swimmer Kylee Alons and former Kentucky swimmer Kaitlynn Wheeler.
Hatch said he'd anticipated hearing a lot about SRY gene testing and that he expected it to be "a science hearing as much as anything."
"I do know the executive order does not set out what type of testing President Trump wants in his order," Hatch said. "Instead, he has ordered various people, agencies, to confer to figure out what is a proper methodology to determine male and female — because even the SRY gene, which was abandoned by the Olympics in 1996, because they tested 3,400 women, found eight to have the SRY gene, but then later, upon further investigation, found them to be more female than male due to androgen insensitivity."
He went on to say, "Before I started delving into this lawsuit, I figured there was a test out there that was black and white, that was 100%, but I think if that were the case, that would have been included in the executive order. It's just not there."
The NCAA issued an updated policy on transgender athlete participation on Feb. 6, the day after the Trump executive order. Attorney Tom Riney, part of the defense team, pointed out that some of the women who testified as supporting witnesses for the state, had initially praised the NCAA policy change. The women who had done so said on the stand, however, they didn't immediately grasp the nuances and changed their opinion after reviewing it more carefully.
The Independent Council on Women's Sports (ICONS), in a statement sent to media, says the new NCAA policy is "even more permissive than before.” It noted the NCAA has removed itself from eligibility monitoring, leaving it to schools.
Swimmers, volleyball player Brooke Slusser testify
Gaines, Wheeler and Alons told the court they felt angered and violated having to compete at NCAA swim meets against Lia Thomas, who is transgender.
Alons said she felt "on edge," "uncomfortable" and "vulnerable" sharing a locker room with Thomas and used a dirty, dimly lit storage closet to change into her competition swimsuit.
Brooke Slusser said her senior season at San Jose State was disrupted by the presence of a transgender teammate.
"Especially with the fact that I found out after sharing a locker room and a hotel room and an apartment with this person, I think it affected me a lot," Slusser said. "I felt betrayed."
The hearing and Hatch's ruling came as March Madness, the NCAA Tournament for Division I basketball, was starting. The NCAA Tournament for Division II and Division III are already three rounds deep.
In his opening statement, Riney said the state's complaint made references to NCAA policy being problematic for "over a decade."
"So for over a decade this has been going on," Riney said, "they filed a suit in December of 2024, and here we are after some of the (NCAA) tournaments have already started and it's somehow an emergency that they say demands injunctive relief."
Riney circled back in his closing argument to the disruption an injunction would cause.
"The tournaments have already started," he said. "How is this court going to implement that testing immediately? They've given you no evidence of what that test would require, who would be required to perform it, whether or not it's reliable, whether or not people could cheat on that. They're just asking basically to disrupt the tournament."
Further, Riney said, an injunction requiring references to women be removed presumed late changes would be needed to tournament tickets, logos and merchandise.
This article originally appeared on Lubbock Avalanche-Journal: Judge denies temporary injunction in suit tied to transgender athletes
Topics
-
Judge denies temporary relief in lawsuits challenging Guantánamo migrant detentions
A federal judge on Friday declined to grant temporary injunctive relief to plaintiffs in two lawsuits challenging the Trump administration’s efforts to detain migrants at Guantánamo Bay. U.S. ...The Hill - 4d -
Texas Tech track and field teams put top-10 rankings to test at NCAA championships
Texas Tech men's track and field won the 2024 NCAA championship. The Tech men are No. 6, women No. 8 going into NCAA indoor in Virginia BeachYahoo Sports - 5d -
Reaction to Texas women earning NCAA Tournament No. 1 seed: 'Dancing in Moody'
As a No. 1 in the NCAA Tournament, Texas women's basketball will face either High Point or William and Mary in the first round.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Texas Longhorns women's basketball awarded a No. 1 seed in NCAA Tournament
The Texas Longhorns women's basketball team has been named a No. 1 seed in the upcoming 2025 NCAA Tournament.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
A resort entirely staffed and run by women in Sri Lanka seeks to break gender barriers
Sri Lanka has opened its first resort that's entirely operated and managed by womenABC News - Mar. 8 -
Temitope Adeshina, Tamiah Washington fuel Texas Tech women's track & field at NCAA meet
Texas Tech track and field teams finish eighth on men's side, 10th on women's at NCAA championships. Temitope Adeshina won her first individual titleYahoo Sports - 3d -
UCLA, South Carolina, USC, Texas earn No. 1 seeds in women's NCAA Tournament
UCLA is the top overall seed in the women's NCAA March Madness tournament.CBS News - 2d -
Where Alabama sits in USA TODAY Sports' Coaches Poll entering NCAA Tournament
The Alabama Crimson Tide are yet again ranked in the USA TODAY Sports' Women's Coaches Poll entering the NCAA Tournament.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
This date in Texas history: Longhorns beat Missouri to begin 1986 NCAA championship run
On this date in Texas history, the women's basketball team began its run through the 1986 NCAA tournament.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
UCLA lands NCAA's No. 1 overall women's seed
UCLA, South Carolina and Texas, who all had a turn at No. 1 this season in the Associated Press poll, joined USC on Sunday as the top seeds in the women's NCAA basketball tournament, which will ...ESPN - 2d -
UCLA, South Carolina, Texas and USC claim top seeds in women's NCAA Tournament
When the first round of the NCAA women's basketball tournament begins Friday, the UCLA Bruins will be its top overall seed.NBC News - 2d -
NCAA women's basketball tournament bracket breakdown, best games, players to watch
UCLA, South Carolina, Texas and USC earned No. 1 seeds for the 2025 women's NCAA Tournament. Breaking down the regions and players to watch.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Texas self-reports five NCAA violations related to sports betting: Two football players embroiled in scandal
One of the football players, who has since ended his playing career, was deemed to have a 'problem' with sports bettingCBS Sports - 6d -
Appeals court blocks Ohio's ban on gender-affirming care for minors
Ohio’s ban on gender-affirming care for minors is unconstitutional and must be permanently blocked from being enforced, a three-judge panel of appellate judges ruled Tuesday.NBC News - 6h -
Texas bill would charge transgender people with 'fraud'
Transgender Texans could be charged with fraud under state legislation filed this month that seeks to make publicly identifying as trans illegal. House Bill 3817, introduced last week by ...The Hill - Mar. 11 -
Paramount says Trump's CBS '60 Minutes' lawsuit seeks to 'punish' network
Paramount on Thursday asked a federal judge in Texas to dismiss the $20-billion lawsuit. The media company separately has agreed to have a mediator look at the case.Los Angeles Times - Mar. 6 -
‘Gender numeracy gap’ is hitting women’s earnings power
One in three UK women say they would not apply for jobs that require working with numbers or dataFinancial Times - 6d -
Kornacki: White men, white women and the gap within the gender gap
NBC News National Political Correspondent Steve Kornacki digs into a NBC News poll that shows divisions along race and gender lines in how the American electorate views DEI initiatives and more.NBC News - 23h -
How women's college basketball plans to continue its upward March
The 2025 women's NCAA Tournament features a number of superstars and a plethora of elite teams. The sport has never been in a healthier place.Yahoo Sports - 8h -
CDC's airplane testing seeks to prevent another pandemic
Five years ago, COVID-19 touched down on U.S. soil when a man from Washington state flew home after a trip to Wuhan, China. But for days, officials didn't know he was carrying the virus because the ...CBS News - 5d -
Trump’s Losses Raise a Question: Should One Judge Set National Policy?
Trial-court judges continue to block the president’s agenda with injunctions that apply across the country. Some conservatives want to limit that power.The New York Times - Mar. 12 -
2025 Women's March Madness: Expert bracket picks, predictions for the Final Four, national championship
Our CBS Sports experts make their selections for the 2025 NCAA Women's Basketball TournamentCBS Sports - 48m -
How to run your 2025 March Madness pool: Play for prizes and create your own NCAA Tournament game
The CBS Sports 2025 NCAA Men's and Women's Games have returned for March Madness 2025 office pools.CBS Sports - 3d -
Elite women's sports revenue 'set to top £1.8bn in 2025'
Global revenue generated by elite women's sports is predicted to exceed £1.8bn in 2025, with finance experts Deloitte stating the "commercial appeal of women's sport and its athletes has never been ...BBC News - 1d -
Judge orders Trump administration to reinstate most fired probationary staff
Ruling by California judge applies to thousands of employees dismissed from six federal agencies. A federal judge in California granted a preliminary injunction to reinstate thousands of fired ...The Guardian - 6d -
Judge restores teacher preparation grants axed by Trump administration
A district judge temporarily restored teacher preparation grants that were axed by the Trump administration in February. District Judge Julie Rubin issued an injunction restoring the grants, saying ...The Hill - 1d -
Steve Kornacki: White men, white women and the gap within the gender gap
College-educated white women and white men without college degrees have come to exist in polar opposite political and cultural universes, each one unrelatable and probably unrecognizable to the other.NBC News - 23h -
Ad spending on women's sports more than doubled last year
Ads during women's sports programs were 40% more impactful than the average primetime advertisement, according to EDO.CNBC - Mar. 11 -
How new professional sports leagues like SailGP are putting women at the fore
As women’s sports surge in popularity, professional leagues are increasingly touting the value of female athletes.NBC News - 1h -
Rubio says Ukraine partial ceasefire plan 'has promise' ahead of talks
Russia has previously rejected a temporary ceasefire, calling it an attempt to buy time.BBC News - Mar. 11 -
Daniel wins long jump on Day One of NCAA Men's and Women's Indoor track and field championships
Kelsey Daniel became the first Texas Longhorn to win the men’s long jump on the opening day of the Division I men’s and women’s indoor track and field championships, jumping a program record 8.16 ...ABC News - 4d -
Watch: Xavier reacts to NCAA tournament bid, First Four matchup with Texas
Xavier will face the Texas team that eliminated the Musketeers from the 2023 NCAA tournament.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Aging Women’s Brain Mysteries Are Tested in Trio of Studies
Researchers identified a gene that seems to help slow brain aging in women, and studied links between hormone therapy, menopause and Alzheimer’s.The New York Times - Mar. 12 -
Texas stuns Texas A&M in 2OT thriller, make case for NCAA Tournament
The Texas Longhorns held off their in-state rival Texas A&M in a double overtime thriller from the SEC Tournament.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
Where Alabama sits in latest USA TODAY Sports' Coaches poll after Texas A&M sweep
The Alabama Crimson Tide are back on the rise in the latest USA TODAY Sports College Baseball Coaches Poll following a weekend sweep at Texas A&M.Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Rick Barnes, former Texas, now Tennessee coach, makes his case for Texas in NCAA Bracket
Former Texas Longhorns Coach Rick Barnes, now Tennessee Volunteers head coach, offered his opinion on why Texas deserved a NCAA tournament spot.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Did the Longhorns punch their ticket to the NCAA Tournament by beating Texas A&M?
Did the Texas Longhorns men's basketball team ensure a spot in the NCAA Tournament with Thursday's upset win over rival Texas A&M? It's complicated.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
Is Texas A&M still considered a 3-seed in the NCAA Tournament?
Texas A&M's loss to Texas was likely meaningless regarding the Aggies' seeding in the NCAA Tournament, according to ESPN bracket expert Joe Lunardi.Yahoo Sports - 4d -
2025 Women's NCAA Tournament bracket: Ranking all 68 teams in March Madness, from UCLA to William & Mary
The Bruins earned the No. 1 overall seed and rank first in CBS Sports' rankingsCBS Sports - 1d
More from Yahoo Sports
-
The Boston Celtics may have found one of the steals of the 2024 NBA draft on their roster
That steal would be rookie shooting guard Baylor Scheierman.Yahoo Sports - 28m -
Great news for Ruben Amorim as Ayden Heaven to return from injury soon after the international break
Despite being stretchered off against Leicester City in the second half on Sunday, Manchester United defender Ayden Heaven could be back soon after the international break.This update comes from ...Yahoo Sports - 28m -
Man City’s Rebuild: Where Does Bernardo Silva Fit in Guardiola’s Plans
Bernardo Silva’s Future at Manchester City: A Stay or a Standoff?Manchester City’s season has not gone to plan. A side accustomed to relentless dominance finds itself fifth in the Premier League, ...Yahoo Sports - 29m -
New Packers WR Mecole Hardman could be Tyler Ervin 2.0
Mecole Hardman could be a pre-snap motion weapon who gets designed touches and handles both returner roles for the Packers in 2025.Yahoo Sports - 32m -
Pick your poison: Davante Adams says he and Puka Nacua will be a 'hell of a test' for defenses
Rams WR Davante Adams has high expectations for himself and Puka Nacua in LAYahoo Sports - 33m
More in Sports
-
The Boston Celtics may have found one of the steals of the 2024 NBA draft on their roster
That steal would be rookie shooting guard Baylor Scheierman.Yahoo Sports - 28m -
Great news for Ruben Amorim as Ayden Heaven to return from injury soon after the international break
Despite being stretchered off against Leicester City in the second half on Sunday, Manchester United defender Ayden Heaven could be back soon after the international break.This update comes from ...Yahoo Sports - 28m -
Man City’s Rebuild: Where Does Bernardo Silva Fit in Guardiola’s Plans
Bernardo Silva’s Future at Manchester City: A Stay or a Standoff?Manchester City’s season has not gone to plan. A side accustomed to relentless dominance finds itself fifth in the Premier League, ...Yahoo Sports - 29m -
College baseball Week 5: Top 25 rankings, play of the week and what to watch
Here are the latest Top 25 rankings, featuring a new No. 1, plus what we're watching this week.ESPN - 32m -
College softball rankings: The Top 25 teams after Week 6
Is Oklahoma still No. 1? Which team dropped out this week? Here's the updated college softball Top 25 poll for Week 6.ESPN - 32m