Final Yankees 26-man roster prediction for 2025 season
The Yankees can't get to Opening Day soon enough.
Injuries have plagued New York this spring, and the team is trying to get to March 27 without any more. The Yankees lost their ace Gerrit Cole to Tommy John surgery, and the status of Giancarlo Stanton and DJ LeMahieu remains a mystery.
That's in addition to not having AL Rookie of the Year Luis Gil to start the season and now Clarke Schmidt is dealing with shoulder soreness and his availability for the start of the 2025 season is in question.
With all that in mind, and barring any last-minute additions, here is our final Yankees 26-man roster prediction for the 2025 season…
Starting Lineup
Austin Wells: C
Paul Goldschmidt: 1B
Jazz Chisholm Jr.: 2B
Anthony Volpe: SS
Oswaldo Cabrera: 3B
Jasson Dominguez: LF
Aaron Judge: RF
Cody Bellinger: CF
Ben Rice: DH
When I created this lineup last time, I had right-hander Everson Pereira making the team. It seemed like a no-brainer, with the once-touted prospect hitting .333 with two home runs in spring but two things likely went against the outfielder.
The first is that Pereira is coming back from Tommy John surgery. The Yankees will want the youngster to get more reps, especially in the outfield, down in the minors before coming up to test his durability.
The second potential reason is that Pereira has a minor league option. Although he has only one more option remaining, that can be used if the team needs a right-handed spark off the bench later in the year.
So, that gives us Rice as the left-handed DH to start the season. Rice, who was given a runway last year playing first base for the injured Anthony Rizzo, is having a monster spring. After a slow start, Rice has smashed four home runs in his last five games and has raised his average to .283.
Rotation
Max Fried: LHP
Carlos Rodon: LHP
Marcus Stroman: RHP
Carlos Carrasco: RHP
Will Warren: RHP
The Yankees' starting rotation was hit the hardest by injuries, which has caused Stroman to remain in pinstripes at least for the time being. I believe Schmidt will be fine in the long run but for the sake of Opening Day, I'm a bit pessimistic about his availability. That's why I see Warren getting the nod to start the season.
He does have two options, so he can be sent down once Schmidt comes back.
Carrasco is the logical choice to be a part of this rotation as a non-roster invitee. Carrasco has an opt-out on March 22, which is when the Yankees have to decide on the veteran's future.
Carrasco, 37, has pitched well enough this spring to garner that final spot. In four games (three starts), Carrasco has pitched to a 1.69 ERA and a 0.94 WHIP while striking out 15 batters across 16 innings.
His addition to the roster would be easy with Cole's 60-day IL designation opening up a spot for the veteran right-hander.
Bullpen
Devin Williams: RHP
Yerry De Los Santos: RHP
Mark Leiter Jr.: RHP
Ian Hamilton: RHP
Fernando Cruz: RHP
Tim Hill: LHP
Luke Weaver: RHP
Yoendrys Gomez: RHP
The bullpen, like the rotation, has been bit by the injury bug, especially to Tyler Matzek (oblique) who I predicted would make the roster as a second lefty option. Obliques are tricky, and with Matzek's age, he will likely not be ready for Opening Day -- which leaves Cruz as his replacement.
Leiter and Hamilton have missed time this spring as well, but they both are on track to make Opening Day. So assuming the health of those guys, this could be how the bullpen will look.
Bench
Trent Grisham: OF
Dom Smith: 1B/OF
J.C. Escarra: C
Oswald Peraza: INF
I originally thought right-hander Alex Jackson would win the backup catcher spot but the Yankees have pretty much shown their hand on how they plan to approach the position.
In March, Jackson has had just 13 at-bats. Escarra has 38.
It sure seems like Boone is prepping Escarra to get as many at-bats as possible to be ready for the regular season.
Peraza, without any options remaining, will make the roster or else the Yankees risk losing their former prospect. Grisham is entrenched as the fourth outfielder and Smith, a non-roster invitee, makes the cut thanks to his solid spring and versatility.
-
One week out from Opening Day, a look at the Yankees' projected roster
It's our last, best guess at the 26 players going north for Yankees Opening Day, with Ben Rice, Pablo Reyes and Carlos Carrasco making strides.Yahoo Sports - 21h -
Detroit Tigers 2025 roster prediction 4.0: Who replaces Parker Meadows, Matt Vierling?
Here's a look at our fourth version of how the Detroit Tigers should fill their 2025 Opening Day roster — without Parker Meadows or Matt Vierling.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Colts way too early 53-man roster prediction after first wave of NFL free agency
Here is a way-too-early look ahead at what the Colts' 53-man roster could look like for the 2025 season following the first wave of NFL free agency.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
Best-guessing at the Yankees' possible Opening Day lineup, and why it might work
After the Yankees sported one of MLB's best lineups in 2024 with Juan Soto, here's what the new-look lineup could be for Opening Day 2025.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Our Final Four, National Championship Predictions for March Madness 2025
Here are our staff predictions for this year's March Madness.Yahoo Sports - 14h -
Louisville basketball roster 2025-26: An early look at Pat Kelsey's team for Year 2
After Louisville basketball's loss to Creighton in first found of March Madness, here's an early look at Pat Kelsey's next 2025-26 Louisville roster:Yahoo Sports - 10h -
Jaguars way too early 53-man roster prediction after first wave of NFL free agency
After the first wave of NFL free agency, here is a way too early projection of the Jaguars' 53-man roster.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
Women’s March Madness Final Four predictions 2025: Who will win NCAA Tournament
Who will win 2025 NCAA Women’s Tournament? Our best March Madness Final Four predictions and picks are in.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Final Four predictions: Women's March Madness bracket picks for 2025 NCAA Tournament
Who will win 2025 NCAA bracket? Our best women’s March Madness, Final Four predictions and picks are in for every game.Yahoo Sports - 3d
More from Yahoo Sports
-
Bronny James co-leads shorthanded Lakers with career-high 17 points in lopsided loss to Bucks
Down their top four scorers on Thursday, the Lakers turned to Bronny James,Yahoo Sports - 21m -
Report: Kansas City Chiefs to re-sign veteran DL Charles Omenihu
On Thursday night, news broke that the Kansas City #Chiefs intend to re-sign veteran DL Charles Omenihu.Yahoo Sports - 24m -
OKC Thunder officially clinch the West's No. 1 seed for 2025 NBA playoffs
Oklahoma City Thunder officially clinch the West's No. 1 seed for 2025 NBA playoffs.Yahoo Sports - 24m -
Injury Report: Steph Curry (pelvic contusion) ruled out for remainder of game vs. Raptors
After a tough fall against the Raptors, the All-Star point guard was ruled out for the remainder of the game.Yahoo Sports - 30m -
Mets Spring Training Notes: Max Kranick's stock rising, Luis Torrens showing offensive capability
It was another productive day at spring training for the Mets and a few players in particular stood out.Yahoo Sports - 31m
More in Sports
-
2025 March Madness TV schedule, announcers: How to watch NCAA Tournament, tipoff times, TV channels, bracket
The complete television and streaming schedule for how to watch March Madness 2025 through the Final FourCBS Sports - 18m -
2025 March Madness: John Calipari vs. Rick Pitino to meet when Arkansas battles St. John's in NCAA Tournament
Two of the most iconic college basketball coaches in the sport meet once again in a second-round matchupCBS Sports - 19m -
Celtics sold for record $6.1 billion, sources say
Bill Chisholm has agreed to purchase the Boston Celtics from the Grousbeck family for a valuation for $6.1 billion, sources told ESPN.ESPN - 19m -
Sources: U.S. billionaire eyes Houston NHL team
American billionaire Dan Friedkin has emerged as a strong ownership option to bring the NHL to Houston, sources told ESPN.ESPN - 19m -
McNeese scripts 'biggest day' in upset of Clemson
McNeese coach Will Wade and his boom box-toting manager are moving on in March Madness after the 12th-seeded Cowboys held off No. 5 seed Clemson on Thursday in the first bracket buster of the NCAA ...ESPN - 19m