What America should learn from South Korea’s democratic crisis
South Korean President v’s martial law declaration on Dec. 3 shocked the world. How could a vibrant, advanced democracy like South Korea revert so suddenly?
To stop the decree, 190 of the 300 members of parliament battled their way past gun-bearing soldiers to enter the National Assembly and vote to repeal martial law as thousands of citizens joined in protest. Yoon reversed his decree within six hours, but he defiantly resisted calls for his resignation and impeachment. Although Yoon survived the first impeachment attempt, pressure mounted for his removal. On Dec. 14, the National Assembly voted 204 to 85 to impeach the president.
The free world hailed the outcome as a win for democracy. Some cited South Korea as a teachable moment for America, with one commentator dubbing the episode as the “reverse Jan. 6.”
The same optimism abounded almost exactly eight years ago, when over 1 million candlelight protesters called to oust South Korean President Park Geun-hye on corruption charges. In what appeared to be a textbook case of democratic institutions at work, a successful impeachment and peaceful power transition ensued.
South Korea’s democracy has many merits. Its remarkable transition from a military dictatorship to a consolidated democracy in 30 years is one of the greatest democratic success stories in the post-World War II era. Democracy appears strong, as attested by high voter turnout, free and fair elections and a vibrant protest culture. South Korea’s 2024 Freedom Index score is 83 out of a 100, the same as the United States.
What belies this success, however, is the fact that South Koreans are living through near back-to-back presidential impeachment processes in under a decade. This is not an emblem of a strong democracy but the symptom of a deeply troubled one. As our research shows, the root of the crisis lies deeper than the political failings of Yoon or his party.
As in the U.S., a particular form of partisan polarization has intensified in South Korea — one that centers competing nationalisms. Party factions in South Korea are still divided along the lines of the Cold War era’s nationalist conflict, with the left espousing an ethnonationalist “One Korea” reunified with North Korea and the right championing a “Global Korea” aligned with the U.S.-led liberal order.
Any “us vs. them” dynamic can be dangerous for democracy. But when that divide centers on mutually exclusive visions of a nation, the effects are uniquely detrimental.
Nations are inherently “state-seeking”: they are political communities that pursue self-rule through exclusive and total ownership of the state. When political parties are consumed by nationalist pursuits, the rules of the democratic game are distorted. The end goal is not representation, but state capture; the opposition is not a valid competitor, but an existential threat to be eliminated. Nationalist polarization encourages party elites to violate the norms of forbearance and mutual tolerance, which function as the informal guardrails of democracy.
Such violations have long been rampant in South Korean politics. Yoon claimed that the opposition-controlled National Assembly motioned to impeach 22 of his appointments, including the minister of the Interior and chairperson of the Communications Commission. The opposition also moved to investigate Yoon’s wife, Kim Keon Hee, on corruption charges three times, which Yoon vetoed each time. Conversely, the ruling conservative party has put the opposition Democratic Party leader Lee Jae-myung through the ringer, indicting him for various corruption charges and finally convicting him of election law violations to sentence him to prison. Such vicious retribution cycles have followed every presidential turnover.
Political leaders and their families are not above the law, and, if found guilty, should be held accountable. But nationalist polarization has turned South Korean politics into a blood sport as political elites seek not to compete with, but destroy, the other side in the name of “our” nation. President Joe Biden’s controversial pardon of his son Hunter and possibly more in his inner circle — a preemptive measure against feared retribution from the incoming Trump administration — presents an America parallel.
Yoon’s action is a setback to South Korean democracy. It is also a harbinger for what can happen when nationalist polarization goes unchecked. The lesson for Americans who wish to safeguard democracy is not to praise South Koreans’ swift resistance, but to work to prevent the conditions that demanded it. Finding the core national values that still unite us despite growing disparities is key for democracy’s survival.
Andrew Yeo is the SK-Korea Foundation Chair at the Brooking Institution’s Center for Asia Policy Studies and professor of politics at the Catholic University of America. Aram Hur is the Kim Koo Chair in Korean Studies and assistant professor of political science at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University. They are co-authors of the article “Democratic Ceilings: The Long Shadow of Nationalist Polarization in East Asia.”
-
Column: What I learned from watching Fox News after the New Orleans terrorist attack
I don't regret my decision to turn on Fox News on New Year's Day, because it was a sobering, necessary reminder of the fetid information ecosystem that put Donald Trump in the White House,Los Angeles Times - 1d -
South Korea’s Dueling Protests
A standoff between the impeached president’s security team and officials seeking to detain him was echoed on the streets outside the presidential residence.The New York Times - 2d -
Canceling the apocalypse? What can we learn from films set in 2025
From monsters fighting robots to a grim look at a decaying healthcare system, past movies set in this new year offer a mixed outlook on what’s to come. The year 2025: It certainly has that ...The Guardian - 3d -
Democrats’ Battleground Leader, Exiting Congress, Reflects on What She Learned
Representative Abigail Spanberger of Virginia, the only Democrat in a leadership position to leave Congress this year, talked about her party, her competitive district, and what the Trump era has ...The New York Times - 4d -
South Korea plane crash investigators extract data from Jeju Air black box
Authorities hope for vital clues as contents of cockpit recorder are converted into audio format. Investigators in South Korea have extracted data from one of two black boxes retrieved from a ...The Guardian - 5d -
Experts from U.S. join South Korea plane crash probe
Experts from the National Transportation Safety Board, Federal Aviation Administration and Boeing joined the probe into the South Korea plane crash that killed all but two of the 181 people on ...CBS News - 5d
More from The Hill
-
Biden: Jan. 6 reminds us that democracy 'is never guaranteed'
President Biden said in a Sunday opinion piece for The Washington Post that the Jan. 6, 2021 attack on the U.S. Capitol reminds Americans that democracy “is never guaranteed.” “We should commit to ...The Hill - 3h -
Trump blasts the 'corrupt' and 'broken' legal system ahead of his sentencing
President-elect Trump on Sunday blasted the “corrupt” and “broken” legal system ahead of a Jan. 10 sentencing date in his New York hush money case. In a Truth Social post highlighted by Mediaite, ...The Hill - 4h -
Trump calls on GOP to pass his agenda in 'one powerful bill'
President-elect Trump on Sunday made public his support for Republican lawmakers to pass key components of his agenda into law with a single reconciliation bill, previewing what is expected to be a ...The Hill - 4h -
MSNBC host blasts Trump for Mar-a-Lago event with John Eastman documentary: 'Sickening'
MSNBC’s Symone Sanders-Townsend on Sunday criticized a recent event featuring a documentary about President-elect Trump’s ally John Eastman that occurred at the president-elect’s Mar-a-Lago estate. ...The Hill - 5h -
Biden signs Social Security bill, says American retirees deserve 'economic security and dignity'
President Biden on Sunday signed a Social Security bill repealing two statutes that have diminished payouts to public sector workers including firefighters and teachers for years. “The bill I’m ...The Hill - 7h
More in Politics
-
Biden: Jan. 6 reminds us that democracy 'is never guaranteed'
President Biden said in a Sunday opinion piece for The Washington Post that the Jan. 6, 2021 attack on the U.S. Capitol reminds Americans that democracy “is never guaranteed.” “We should commit to ...The Hill - 3h -
Trump blasts the 'corrupt' and 'broken' legal system ahead of his sentencing
President-elect Trump on Sunday blasted the “corrupt” and “broken” legal system ahead of a Jan. 10 sentencing date in his New York hush money case. In a Truth Social post highlighted by Mediaite, ...The Hill - 4h -
Trump calls on GOP to pass his agenda in 'one powerful bill'
President-elect Trump on Sunday made public his support for Republican lawmakers to pass key components of his agenda into law with a single reconciliation bill, previewing what is expected to be a ...The Hill - 4h -
Trump backs massive single bill for taxes, border and energy
Some Republicans have expressed support for enacting two pieces of legislation, instead of trying to stuff everything into one bill.Politico - 5h -
MSNBC host blasts Trump for Mar-a-Lago event with John Eastman documentary: 'Sickening'
MSNBC’s Symone Sanders-Townsend on Sunday criticized a recent event featuring a documentary about President-elect Trump’s ally John Eastman that occurred at the president-elect’s Mar-a-Lago estate. ...The Hill - 5h