The Memo: Democrats, lawyers left reeling from Paul, Weiss firm’s Trump deal

A Washington Post editorial appeared earlier this week headlined “Trump’s efforts to intimidate the legal profession cannot stand.”

Within 48 hours later, those efforts were not merely standing. They had worked — at least in one case.

The major law firm of Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison (called Paul, Weiss), targeted by President Trump in an executive order, opted to mollify rather than confront the president. In short, it backed down.

Democrats, as well as many lawyers, are grappling with the implications.

Paul, Weiss agreed to provide $40 million in pro bono work on causes backed by the administration and to hire an outside expert to audit its hiring and employment practices.

After the firm had made those concessions, and some others, Trump agreed to lift an executive order that would have taken away security clearances from the law firm’s staff.

On social media, critics accuse the law firm of giving in to a “shakedown” or “extortion” by Trump.

The firm’s chair, Brad Karp, defended the deal he struck in an email to all employees, according to The New York Times.

Karp reportedly argued he had merely “reaffirmed” the firm’s principles. Others have noted that the $40 million pro bono commitment amounts to only about one-fifth of the pro-bono work the massive firm typically does each year.

That being said, the appearance of appearing to bend the knee to Trump with such alacrity has caused widespread alarm in legal circles.

Prominent attorney Mark Zaid told this column that a “horrible message” was being sent both to the legal profession and to the public at large by Paul, Weiss’s "decision to simply capitulate in fear rather than stand up for the rule of law and the ethical principles that guide lawyers.”

Zaid, who is best known for defending whistleblowers of all political persuasions, had his own security clearance revoked by Trump recently. But he remains unbowed.

“There are many of us,” he said, “who will not be bullied or intimidated, notwithstanding the continuing attacks on lawyers.”

In addition to the Paul, Weiss firm, other law firms have been targeted by Trump.

The most prominent in the firing line was Perkins Coie, the firm that represented the presidential campaign of 2016 Democratic nominee Hillary Clinton.

In that capacity, it contracted another organization called Fusion GPS to do opposition research on Trump. Fusion GPS in turn sought the assistance of retired British spy Christopher Steele, who produced the now-infamous “Steele dossier.”

This history appears to have drawn the lasting enmity of Trump.

But Perkins Coie — unlike Paul, Weiss — has chosen to fight. It won an interim victory when U.S. District Judge Beryl Howell earlier this month froze parts of Trump’s executive order against the firm pending further hearings.

On Friday, Trump’s Department of Justice tried to get Howell thrown off the case, alleging that she had shown “partiality” against Trump.

A third legal firm, Covington & Burling, was also the subject of a Trump targeting. It has so far navigated a lower profile, middle ground in which it is neither challenging the president so publicly as Perkins Coie, nor accommodating him like Paul, Weiss.

For all three legal firms — and for others eyeing these developments with alarm — there is a near-certainty that they would lose significant numbers of clients if they lose their security clearances. In the case of Perkins Coie, the Trump administration has signaled it will not do federal business with the firm’s clients — a massive pressure point that could call the firm’s existence into question.

But Democrats and other Trump critics worry about a broader attempt to squelch dissent.

Part of that, to be sure, is concentrated in the legal sphere.

Trump has called for the impeachment of the judge who ruled against him when his administration used the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 to deport Venezuelan migrants last weekend. Elon Musk referred to a separate adverse ruling — this one blocking a ban on openly transgender people serving in the military — as a “judicial coup.”

Trump’s detractors also contend he is targeting the media. They cite the banishment of The Associated Press from the White House press pool for some events over a dispute about language and Trump’s suing of Paramount, the parent company of CBS News, over its editing of an interview with then-Vice President Kamala Harris last fall.

Democrats also fear an effort to use fringe actions, like violent attacks on Tesla vehicles and showrooms, as a pretext to go after organizations that help the party and liberal causes. Vice President Vance has suggested that the Tesla attacks are being funded by "very wealthy left-wing people” while online fundraising platform ActBlue has recently been targeted by Musk.

“I think it’s shocking. But I also think it is something that the Democratic Party has to recognize,” veteran Democratic strategist Tad Devine said. “We are under assault.”

Devine also contended that Democrats had to unite on a message.

He contended the message should be that Trump acts “not to take care of the people of this country but to take care of himself and his wealthy friends.”

Democrats, of course, have not yet united on any message.

And whether they can find one that would stop the Trump juggernaut from rolling is another question entirely.

The Memo is a reported column by Niall Stanage.

Topics

Paul Weiss Deal With Trump Faces Backlash From Legal Profession

Paul Weiss, a law firm targeted by President Trump, reached a deal to settle a conflict. Many in the legal field are condemning the agreement.
The New York Times - 15h
Paul Weiss Chair Says Deal With Trump Adheres to Firm’s Principles

In an email message, the law firm’s chairman, Brad Karp, reassured employees that its deal with President Trump was in keeping with its principles.
The New York Times - 1d
Trump rescinds order targeting Paul, Weiss citing commitments from law firm

President Trump on Thursday rescinded an executive order he signed less than a week ago targeting the Paul, Weiss law firm, citing an agreement with the firm that includes pro bono support for the ...
The Hill - 2d
How a Major Democratic Law Firm Ended Up Bowing to Trump

Paul Weiss was targeted by an executive order from President Trump. Its chairman, who had worked against Mr. Trump during his first term, then went to the Oval Office and cut a deal.
The New York Times - 1d
Trump pulls security clearance of Paul Weiss law firm

President Trump has continued his attack against prominent law firms, pulling the security clearances of attorneys at New York-based Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison LLP (Paul Weiss), and ...
The Hill - Mar. 15
What to Know About Paul Weiss, the Law Firm Bowing to Trump’s Demands

The 150-year-old firm has employed many Democrats, including Manhattan’s former U.S. attorney. Its revenue was more than $2.6 billion last year.
The New York Times - 1d
Trump suggests law firms 'want to make deals' after rescinding Paul, Weiss order

President Trump on Friday defended a series of executive actions he’s taken to target major law firms associated with individuals he holds grudges against, one day after one of those law firms ...
The Hill - 1d
Legal community shaken by a powerful law firm's decision to give in to Trump's demands

President Donald Trump rescinded his executive order targeting Paul Weiss — after the law firm agreed to certain conditions.
NBC News - 1d
Law Firm Bends in Face of Trump Demands

Paul, Weiss — one of three law firms targeted by President Trump as part of his retribution campaign — said it resolved the conflict by agreeing to a range of commitments.
The New York Times - 2d
Trump drops Paul Weiss order after law firm pledges $40mn of pro bono support

New York firm has agreed not to pursue any diversity, equity and inclusion policies, says US president
Financial Times - 1d
The Memo: Divided Democrats squander chances to expose Trump’s vulnerability

President Trump is not the political colossus he and his supporters claim — and everything from the stock market to his opinion poll ratings prove it. The problem for Democrats is that their own ...
The Hill - Mar. 15
Trump rescinds order targeting law firm after it makes $40m promise

Paul, Weiss promised $40 million of free legal work to the White House and to change its diversity policies.
BBC News - 1d
Trump signs executive order targeting 3rd law firm

President Donald Trump signed an executive order suspending security clearances of Mark Pomerantz and those who work at Paul, Weiss, Rifkind, Wharton & Garrison.
ABC News - Mar. 15
With New Decree, Trump Threatens Lawyers and Law Firms

A presidential memorandum aimed at lawyers everywhere struck a menacing tone.
The New York Times - 9h
David Sacks sold $200M in crypto-related holdings before taking White House job, ethics memo says

David Sacks, the Trump administration’s AI and crypto czar, sold over $200 million worth of digital asset-related investments personally and through his firm, Craft Ventures, before starting the ...
NBC News - Mar. 14
Chuck Schumer is in a real shutdown mess. Can he lead Democrats out of it?

Despite pressure from the left to hold firm, some Democratic senators seem headed for an off-ramp.
Politico - Mar. 12
Stephen A. Smith to Democrats: Find deals Trump is willing to make

Media personality Stephen A. Smith is urging Democrats to find deals they can make with President Trump, criticizing their protests. “What we’ve been seeing from them, it doesn’t resonate," Smith ...
The Hill - Mar. 13
Perkins Coie sues over Trump's order stripping security clearances

Law firm Perkins Coie has launched a suit to challenge President Trump’s stripping of security clearances for lawyers at the firm, saying it was targeted due to its past work for Democrats. Perkins ...
The Hill - Mar. 11
Shutdown showdown leaves Democrats deeply divided: From the Politics Desk

The fight over a looming government shutdown as left the Democratic Party deeply divided as they try to find their footing in the second Trump administration.
NBC News - Mar. 14
Trump waging ‘sickening’ psychological war, deported Venezuelan’s lawyer says

One detained man’s lawyer says he is gay artist who had fled persecution in his home country, not a gang member. A lawyer for one of the Venezuelan immigrants sent from the US to a notorious mega ...
The Guardian - 4d
‘People Are Scared’: Inside CISA as It Reels From Trump’s Purge

Employees at the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency tell WIRED they’re struggling to protect the US while the administration dismisses their colleagues and poisons their partnerships.
Wired - Mar. 13
Judge blocks 'unlawful' Trump order targeting Clinton 2016 law firm

A federal judge entered an emergency order barring the Trump administration from implementing parts of its executive order targeting the law firm Perkins Coie.
ABC News - Mar. 12
The law must not bend to Trump’s crusade of political retribution

Lawyers must not sit on the sidelines as firms and judges are attacked merely for doing their jobs.
The Hill - 3d
Sen. Lindsey Graham rebukes lawyers who defended Trump foes: "I hope they pay a price"

President Trump has targeted several law firms by terminating security clearances and other executive actions.
CBS News - 6d
Dr. Mehmet Oz may have underpaid Medicare and Social Security taxes, Senate Democratic memo finds

Dr. Mehmet Oz, President Donald Trump’s nominee to oversee the Center for Medicare and Medicare Services, may have “significantly” underpaid Medicare and Social Security taxes.
NBC News - Mar. 13
For the left’s Ukraine hawks, the real war is against Trump

The liberal left has shifted from opposing muscular policies toward Russia to advocating for a robust Cold War, despite a history of opposing it and giving Russia excuses.
The Hill - 4d
The left talks about antisemitism. The right actually fights it.

A Republican consulting firm has helped build a department to fight antisemitism and support Israel, while the Democratic Party has failed to crack down on pro-Hamas mobs and has defended a Hamas ...
The Hill - 6d
Judge blocks parts of Trump executive order targeting law firm Perkins Coie

U.S. District Judge Beryl Howell issued a temporary restraining order that stops three parts of Trump's executive order from being implemented against the law firm Perkins Coie.
CBS News - Mar. 12
Attorney urges major law firm to resist Trump attacks in viral resignation letter

An attorney resigned from the law firm Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom, posting a sharply critical resignation letter that called on the company to stand up to President Trump' amid a ...
The Hill - 10h
House GOP blocks Democrats from forcing vote on repealing Trump tariffs

House Republicans on Tuesday approved a provision that would prevent Democrats from forcing votes for the remainder of the year on repealing recent tariffs implemented by President Trump. It ...
The Hill - Mar. 11
Lawyer Appointed in Adams Case Says Charges Should Be Dropped

Paul D. Clement also said a judge should not allow the Trump administration to use the court’s authority to compel Mr. Adams’s support in the White House’s mass deportation efforts.
The New York Times - Mar. 8
Democrats facing outrage from constituents at town halls

Democrats are facing outrage from their constituents at town halls who believe their elected officials are not doing enough to counter the Trump administration's agenda. NBC News' Julie Tsirkin has ...
NBC News - 1d
Trump signs spending bill that united Republicans but divided Democrats

President Trump signed Congress' bill to keep the government open on Saturday. The vote for the six-month spending bill united Republicans but left Democrats bitterly divided. Willie James Inman ...
CBS News - Mar. 15
Transportation secretary rescinds Biden memos prioritizing infrastructure resilience to climate change

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy rescinded memos from the Biden administration prioritizing infrastructure resilience to climate change, according to a Monday press release. According to the ...
The Hill - Mar. 10
Software bug at firm left NHS data 'vulnerable to hackers'

The NHS is looking into claims that a software flaw at Medefer left patient data vulnerable.
BBC News - Mar. 10
Trump Targeting Law Firms Raises Constitutional Concerns

The way Trump targeted the firms could go against of the U.S. Constitution’s First Amendment.
Inc. - Mar. 9
House Democrats launch investigation of DHS ads on Trump immigration policies

House Democrats are launching an investigation into an ad campaign from the Trump administration on its immigration policies, saying it may have violated federal spending guidelines by promoting ...
The Hill - 1d
The Memo: Trump ratchets up confrontation with judiciary

President Trump and his administration ramped up their confrontation with the judiciary to extraordinary heights Monday, demanding that a judge whose ruling had incurred their disfavor should be ...
The Hill - 5d
With Orders, Investigations and Innuendo, Trump and G.O.P. Aim to Cripple the Left

The president and his allies in Congress are targeting the financial, digital and legal machinery that powers the Democratic Party and much of the progressive political world.
The New York Times - 3d

More from The Hill

Pentagon vows investigation into leaks, including polygraph tests

Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth's chief of staff, Joe Kasper, sent a memo Friday saying that members of the Department of Defense (DOD) may be subjected to polygraph tests in a new investigation ...
The Hill - 4h
Former US Attorney found dead in Virginia home at 43

Former U.S. attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia Jessica Aber was found dead on Saturday morning at the age of 43. According to the Alexandria Police Department (APD), the cause and ...
The Hill - 6h
Harris widely favored to lead Dems in 2028, poll shows

Former Vice President Harris is widely favored as a possible candidate in the 2028 Democratic presidential primary field, per a new poll. The 2024 Democratic nominee has the support of 36 percent ...
The Hill - 7h
Witkoff: Putin prayed for Trump after assassination attempt

Trump administration special envoy Steve Witkoff said Friday that Russian President Vladimir Putin prayed for President Trump after he was injured following an assassination attempt during the ...
The Hill - 8h
GOP lawmakers booed at town halls defend hosting events despite advice from leaders

House Republicans who faced hostile crowds and viral confrontations at town halls in their districts are defending their decision to hold the events — despite recommendations from House GOP leaders ...
The Hill - 10h