For the left’s Ukraine hawks, the real war is against Trump

Across the liberal left, the drumbeat for war against Russia has reached a deafening volume. No longer may one doubt Ukraine’s capacity to win back Crimea, or question whether thousands more troops killed and maimed are worth the cost. Those who do are now deemed Russian proxies or Vladimir Putin stooges.

Never before has the liberal-left manifested such hawkishness. On the contrary, both during the Cold War and after, the left consistently opposed muscular policies of deterrence toward Russia and routinely opposed higher defense spending. As one scholar put it, the left “gave the Soviets every excuse … [and] argued for moral equivalence, that whatever the Soviets or contemporary Russians do, we are doing the same.” Leftists scolded conservatives that “their anti-communist, anti-Russian attitudes would bring war and stop the chance for peace.”

In 1977, this worldview prompted then-President Jimmy Carter’s disparaging call-out of Americans’ “inordinate fear of communism,” which Carter claimed drove America “to adopt the flawed … principles and tactics of our adversaries ….” More recently, after Putin’s 2014 invasion and seizure of Crimea, then-President Obama refused Ukraine’s impassioned pleas for American weaponry. While that refusal elicited strong criticism, no one accused Obama of being a Russia proxy or a Putin stooge.

Tellingly, the Trump administration reversed that decision in December 2017, and commenced supplying Ukraine with anti-tank Javelin missiles, sniper rifles and ammunition.

Appeasement and signals of weakness returned in full force under the Biden administration. In May 2021, after Russian hackers disabled a major U.S. oil pipeline and extracted a $4.4 million ransom, the administration did nothing to deter future attacks. That same month Biden lifted sanctions against Russia’s Nordstream II pipeline, which would render Europe ever more dependent on Russian natural gas. Then Biden's administration froze a $100 million military-aid package to Ukraine.

Compounding this signal of weakness, Biden withdrew all U.S. forces from Afghanistan in September 2021, against military advice to maintain a residual force, and amid reports of the Taliban’s violating the withdrawal agreement. The Taliban promptly seized power and imposed a medieval Islamist regime. Then in January 2022, as Russia massed troops along Ukraine’s borders, Biden publicly expressed doubts that there would be a unified Western response “if it’s a minor incursion ….”

Despite those many giveaways to Russia, no one accused Biden of being a Russia proxy or a Putin stooge. And quite predictably, an emboldened Putin in February 2022 launched his full-scale invasion of Ukraine. While Biden then commenced supplying weapons to Ukraine, by October 2022 more than two dozen Democratic members of Congress publicly demanded that Biden “shift course in his Ukraine strategy and pursue direct diplomacy with Russia to bring the months-long conflict to an end.” Again, no one accused those Democrats of being Russia proxies or Putin stooges.

By April 2024 — with the total of Russian and Ukrainian troops killed or wounded approaching 1 million — left-leaning media platforms like CNBC were declaring the war’s prospects to be at best a stalemate, with a real chance of Russia overpowering Ukraine’s defenses. Yet again, no one accused those outlets of being Russia proxies or Putin stooges

But when Donald Trump returned to the presidency and sought negotiations with Russia to end the war, all that changed. Sen. Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) insisted that “[t]he White House has become an arm of the Kremlin,” while the British Independent denounced Trump for “behaving like an agent of the KGB.”

In sum, liberals who for decades opposed a robust Cold War, sought lower defense spending, urged cease fires in virtually all global conflicts, and blamed America for tensions with Russia suddenly discovered their inner cold warrior — and found Trump wanting. This despite the fact that it was Trump, not Obama or Biden, who had first armed Ukraine. And this despite the fact that it was Trump who successfully deterred Russian aggression throughout his presidency, while Russia invaded Ukraine during each of Biden’s and Obama’s weaker presidencies.

All this invites the question: Is the liberal left’s born-again hawkishness the product of newfound geopolitical wisdom and compassion for Ukrainian suffering? Or might it have more to do with their long-expressed hatred of all things Trump? One wishes it were the former; but the evidence, sadly, weighs more toward the latter.

Henry Kopel is a former U.S. federal prosecutor and the author of “War on Hate: How to Stop Genocide, Fight Terrorism, and Defend Freedom” (Lexington Books, 2021).

Topics

Ukraine war in maps: How control has shifted in three years

How are Russia and Ukraine placed after three years of fighting and with Donald Trump suggesting talks on ending the war could begin soon?
BBC News - 5d
Inside the frontlines of Russia as the war with Ukraine continues

NBC News' Keir Simmons gets a rare look inside the frontlines in Russia and talks with residents about the impact of the war with Ukraine as President Trump said he is “strongly considering” ...
NBC News - Mar. 8
Almost half think Trump sympathizes with Russia in Ukraine war: Survey

President Trump is expected to speak with Russian President Vladimir Putin on Tuesday about ongoing negotiations to end the war between Russia and Ukraine, despite nearly half of American voters ...
The Hill - 1d
Ukraine war live: Zelenskyy says Russia has carried out ‘hundreds of attacks’ against Ukraine this week

Ukrainian president calls for strengthened sanctions as he highlights weapons used against his country. Local officials from Russia ’s ruling party have caused controversy by presenting mothers of ...
The Guardian - Mar. 9
What Ukraine's asking for in meetings with U.S. about war with Russia

Officials from the U.S. and Ukraine are holding talks in Saudi Arabia on Tuesday in an effort to end Russia's war against the Ukrainians. Michael Bociurkiw, senior fellow at the Atlantic Council's ...
CBS News - Mar. 11
Trump plans Tuesday talks with Putin on Russia-Ukraine war

US president says ‘a lot of work’ has been done over weekend towards ceasefire deal
Financial Times - 1d
Why Isn’t Ukraine in NATO, and What Has Trump Said?

The mutual-defense alliance has been central to Ukraine’s war against Russia, but the future is uncertain with President Trump back in office.
The New York Times - 4d
Republican Russophilia: how Trump Putin-ised a party of cold war hawks

The idea of Moscow as a paragon of Christian nationalism has penetrated the party of Reagan – and the lurch in US policy has huge implications for the global order. Never miss global breaking ...
The Guardian - 3d
Marco Rubio: one-time Russia hawk makes stunning U-turn under Trump

The secretary of state was once a prominent Ukraine supporter and called Putin a ‘war criminal’ – not any more. Marco Rubio , the US secretary of state, looked on as Donald Trump demanded more ...
The Guardian - Mar. 8