Supreme Court to weigh in on Mexico's lawsuit against US gun manufacturers
The Supreme Court agreed Friday to take up the gun industry’s appeal of a ruling allowing the Mexican government to proceed with its lawsuit against several prominent American firearm manufacturers.
Mexico contends the companies deliberately chose to “profit off the criminal market for their products” and caused a flood of guns to fall into the hands of Mexican cartels. The country says firearms manufacturers should pay billions in damages and change their practices.
U.S. federal law provides broad immunity to the firearm industry, however. A federal judge tossed Mexico’s lawsuit as a result, but an appeals court later reversed that ruling, allowing the case to move ahead.
The companies at the center of the suit are: Smith & Wesson Brands Inc.; Barrett Firearms Manufacturing Inc.; Beretta U.S.A. Corp.; Glock Inc.; Sturm, Ruger & Company Inc.; Witmer Public Safety Group Inc., d/b/a Interstate Arms; Century International Arms Inc.; and Colt’s Manufacturing Company LLC.
By agreeing to hear the gun industry’s appeal, the Supreme Court will need to decide whether immunity applies. The justices’ brief order sets up the case to be heard during the court’s upcoming annual term, with a decision expected by next summer.
Mexico claims its case falls under an exception to the 2005 Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act (PLCAA). Gun control groups have long looked to repeal the law entirely.
The exception allows lawsuits when a gun manufacturer knowingly violates state or federal firearms law and the plaintiff was proximately harmed by the violation. The case marks the first time the Supreme Court will weigh in on the exception’s scope.
The companies assert Mexico’s legal theory does not come close to proving the American gun industry is the proximate cause of cartel violence, describing it as an “eight-step Rube Goldberg.”
“Mexico’s suit has no business in an American court,” the companies wrote in their petition.
Their appeal is backed by all of the nation’s Republican state attorneys general except Ohio's, 27 Republican members of Congress and various gun rights groups.
No matter how the Supreme Court rules, many of the defendants are already off the hook. In August, a federal trial judge ruled on separate grounds that the court had no jurisdiction to hear claims against six of the eight firearms companies, meaning just two companies could face penalties if the Supreme Court decides the case in Mexico's favor.
The Mexican government urged the Supreme Court to turn away the appeal, arguing recent ruling underscores that the case doesn’t merit the attention of the justices.
“The Court should allow further percolation before accepting review of these largely unventilated questions,” Mexico wrote in court filings.
If the Supreme Court ultimately rules in favor of Mexico, the case remains in its early stages, meaning the prospect of damages remains far off.
“At bottom, this case reduces to a clash of national values: Mexico makes no secret that it abhors this country’s approach to firearms, and that it wants to use the American court system to impose domestic gun controls on the United States that the American people themselves would never accept through the ordinary political process,” the industry wrote in its petition.
“But even though that grievance is placed under the lettering of a complaint, and was filed on a docket, it has no basis in law. This Court’s review is badly needed,” it continued.
Date: |
Topics
-
Top stories - CBS News
Supreme Court takes up gun-makers' bid to end Mexican government's lawsuit
The Supreme Court said it will consider a bid by U.S. gun-makers to end a lawsuit from the Mexican government seeking to hold them liable for violence committed by drug cartels.2 hours ago -
Top stories - ABC News
Supreme Court's new term takes on ghost guns, porn access and trans care bans
The U.S. Supreme Court begins a fraught new term on Monday with the nation deeply divided over its recent rulings and skeptical of the justices’ ethics and impartiality.6 hours ago -
Top stories - NBC News
Mexican gun dispute and a straight woman's sex discrimination claim among new Supreme Court cases
The Supreme Court took up several cases Friday ahead of its new term, including a bid by gun companies to evade a lawsuit filed by the Mexican government and a straight woman's claim of sex ...2 hours ago -
World - The Guardian
Jamaica welcomes US move to clamp down on gun trafficking to Caribbean
Horace Chang, deputy PM of country with highest homicide rate, praises US attorneys generals’ support for legislation. Jamaica’s deputy prime minister has welcomed a campaign by the New York ...Yesterday -
Top stories - CBS News
The Supreme Court cases to look out for this term
The new Supreme Court term begins on Oct. 7. The last session saw consequential decisions, including giving presidents broader immunity, preserving abortion pill access and upholding a domestic ...15 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Supreme Court to review vape review venue
The Supreme Court agreed Friday to wade into another case implicating federal approval of vapes at the Biden administration’s request. The Justice Department hopes to crack down on looser rules ...2 hours ago -
World - Yahoo News
Mexico Top Court to Consider Request to Review Judicial Reform
17 hours ago -
Top stories - CBS News
The Supreme Court's new term starts next week. Here's what to know.
Supreme Court justices will take the bench Monday for the first time since issuing blockbuster decisions on guns, abortion and presidential immunity.22 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Diplomacy isn’t enough: Ordinary Israelis and Palestinians must embrace peace
No outcome will be tenable if diplomatic efforts do not address the structural entrenchment of Israeli and Palestinian narratives (in plural) in their respective communities.27 minutes ago - Israel -
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: JD Vance rallies voters in battleground Georgia
Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio), former President Trump's running mate, is rallying voters in the battleground state of Georgia Friday afternoon. The Trump campaign canceled two events in the state earlier ...29 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
White House bashes GOP 'lies' about FEMA funds
The White House on Friday bashed Republicans for what it argues are lies about the Hurricane Helene federal response effort. The White House focused on the claim that the Federal Emergency ...32 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
FEMA warns of Helene misinformation, launches 'rumor response' page
The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) is warning the public to be wary of misinformation surrounding Hurricane Helene and the federal government's response, launching a “rumor response” ...48 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Raskin, Ocasio-Cortez demand answers from Roberts on Alito, Thomas actions
Reps. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.) and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) are asking Chief Justice John Roberts to answer a series of questions about his awareness of an upside-down American flag that flew ...53 minutes ago