Supreme Court to review vape review venue
The Supreme Court agreed Friday to wade into another case implicating federal approval of vapes at the Biden administration’s request.
The Justice Department hopes to crack down on looser rules that make it easier for vape companies to funnel challenges through the nation’s most conservative federal appeals court, rather than another venue.
The 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals has been more sympathetic to the industry, making it an attractive place for companies to contest their products being denied.
“This Court should grant review to put a stop to that practice,” U.S. Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar wrote in court filings.
Under federal law, companies can challenge the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) denying a new tobacco product in Washington, D.C., or where the company’s principal place of business is located.
The 5th Circuit’s rule effectively enables it to host any tobacco company’s challenge, so long as its lawsuit is joined by a convenience store or other retail seller within the 5th Circuit’s borders — which spans Louisiana, Mississippi and Texas.
“The Fifth Circuit’s decision permits retail sellers of a tobacco product who have no right of judicial review under the Act to nevertheless gain review; effectively nullifies the Act’s limits on venue; facilitates blatant forum shopping; and undermines the precedents of other circuits,” Prelogar wrote.
The case arose after the FDA denied R.J. Reynolds Vapor Company’s request to introduce three flavored vapes on the market. The FDA said the company failed to meet federal requirements concerning tobacco products’ marketing, but the company contends the decision was arbitrary and capricious.
The company is based in North Carolina, but the federal appeals courts located there and in D.C. already had precedent on the books unfavorable to the manufacturer.
So it instead filed its challenge in the 5th Circuit alongside Avail Vapor Texas and the Mississippi Petroleum Marketers an.d Convenience Stores Association. The federal government attempted to move venues, but the 5th Circuit said the additional challengers meant the case was properly brought.
“There is no circuit conflict over the meaning of this venue provision. And other vehicle problems abound,” the company wrote in court filings urging the justices to turn away the appeal.
No matter which way the justices rule, they are not expected to address the merits of the FDA’s denial. The Supreme Court only took up the question of whether the 5th Circuit was a proper venue.
But in a separate case the court has already taken up for its upcoming term, the justices will review the FDA’s denial of other vape products from coming on the market.
Decisions in both cases are expected by next summer.
Date: |
-
World - Yahoo News
Mexico Top Court to Consider Request to Review Judicial Reform
17 hours ago -
Tech - Wired
13 Best WIRED Tested and Reviewed Blenders (2024)
The perfect kitchen companion, these versatile blenders can whip up breakfasts, dips, milks, cocktails, and everything in between.Yesterday -
Entertainment - ABC News
Movie Review: 'Folie à Deux' reckons with 'The Joker'
Todd Phillips has followed his very anti-hero take on the Joker with a very anti-sequel follow-upYesterday - Entertainment -
World - The Guardian
Unleashed by Boris Johnson review – memoirs of a clown
All the fancy verbiage in the world cannot disguise the emptiness at the heart of this self-serving, solipsistic book. Written once their authors have lost power, most prime ministerial memoirs try ...21 hours ago -
World - The Guardian
Odyssey by Stephen Fry review – a jaunty version of Homer
The last in Fry’s four-book retelling of the Greek myths is relatable and full of humour. Not long ago, Elon Musk took a break from predicting civil war to offer his followers on X a book ...9 hours ago -
Top stories - BBC News
Notorious Menendez brothers murder case to be reviewed
The brothers, who were jailed for killing their parents at a Beverly Hills mansion, say it was self-defence.8 hours ago -
Top stories - NBC News
Prosecutors to review new evidence in Menendez brothers case
The Los Angeles District Attorney’s office has agreed to review new evidence in the 35-year-old case of Erik and Lyle Menendez. Meanwhile, Kim Kardashian has published a personal essay calling for ...4 hours ago -
Top stories - CBS News
The Supreme Court cases to look out for this term
The new Supreme Court term begins on Oct. 7. The last session saw consequential decisions, including giving presidents broader immunity, preserving abortion pill access and upholding a domestic ...15 hours ago -
World - The Guardian
Caribou: Honey review – this AI-aided album is dubious on so many levels
(City Slang/Merge) Evidently running out of ideas, the Canadian musician has used AI to alter his voice into rappers and singers – a dismally insular style of working that produces little of note. ...Yesterday
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Diplomacy isn’t enough: Ordinary Israelis and Palestinians must embrace peace
No outcome will be tenable if diplomatic efforts do not address the structural entrenchment of Israeli and Palestinian narratives (in plural) in their respective communities.17 minutes ago - Israel -
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: JD Vance rallies voters in battleground Georgia
Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio), former President Trump's running mate, is rallying voters in the battleground state of Georgia Friday afternoon. The Trump campaign canceled two events in the state earlier ...18 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
White House bashes GOP 'lies' about FEMA funds
The White House on Friday bashed Republicans for what it argues are lies about the Hurricane Helene federal response effort. The White House focused on the claim that the Federal Emergency ...21 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
FEMA warns of Helene misinformation, launches 'rumor response' page
The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) is warning the public to be wary of misinformation surrounding Hurricane Helene and the federal government's response, launching a “rumor response” ...38 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Raskin, Ocasio-Cortez demand answers from Roberts on Alito, Thomas actions
Reps. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.) and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) are asking Chief Justice John Roberts to answer a series of questions about his awareness of an upside-down American flag that flew ...42 minutes ago