Diplomacy isn’t enough: Ordinary Israelis and Palestinians must embrace peace
The past year made clear that the Israeli-Palestinian question is not going anywhere, just like the several million Israelis and Palestinians living between “the river and the sea” are there to stay. Moreover, the issue is deeply interwoven with other trouble spots in the Middle East, as the current confrontation between Israel and Hezbollah demonstrates.
Since the Oct. 7 Hamas attacks, world leaders have wracked their brains over how to return quiet to the Middle East and prevent new escalations. While initial efforts have focused on avoiding further human suffering, all parties realize that a longer term, more sustainable solution needs to be found for “the day after.”
Israelis, Palestinians and international players obviously do not agree on what that solution should look like. The “one-state reality” discourse that appeared to gain traction just a few years ago seems to have all but vanished, whereas calls for a type of Israeli-Palestinian confederation have recently been reiterated. Official positions in the U.S., Europe and parts of the Arab world still go out from the two-state solution, the feasibility of which was heavily scrutinized mere weeks before Oct. 7, 2023, at the occasion of the Oslo Accords' 30th anniversary. Current attempts at restoring calm in the Middle East, led mainly by the U.S., focus on some kind of Palestinian self-governance, including in the Gaza Strip, in the context of a shot at regional stabilization hinging on Israeli-Saudi normalization.
But whatever happens next, no outcome will be tenable if diplomatic efforts do not address the structural entrenchment of Israeli and Palestinian narratives (in plural) in their respective communities. High diplomacy needs to include a plan to deal with the conflict’s impact on those aspects of society that directly affect daily life.
Indeed, even if a political agreement is reached and ratified, it will not be able to hold if school systems, media coverage, remembrance ceremonies and the historical-cultural valorization of public space continue to antagonize most Israelis and Palestinians, as is the case today. The century-old conflict with multiple interwoven responsibilities has produced many narratives that are not necessarily untrue, but most often very partial and hence mutually exclusive.
Crucially, these narratives are profoundly anchored in the daily lives of millions of people on both sides who, prey to deep fear and mistrust, see them confirmed time and again.
International actors therefore must, along with high-level talks aimed at brokering a political agreement, bring Israeli and Palestinian leaders to seriously rethink the governance areas affected by the conflict. Only outside parties can do so with the required distance and be even-handed when pointing out shortcomings.
For instance, incitements to violence and hatred in Palestinian textbooks have been recognized as a crucial factor that may even trump any internationally coordinated initiative towards peaceful Palestinian self-governance in Gaza. However, although a review of the Palestinian school system seems to recommend itself, it would be only fitting that the Israeli side — with its factionalized educational landscape — undergo an assessment process as well, as young Israelis can definitely learn a thing or two about the Palestinians they know as enemies, but usually have never actually met.
A societal mapping of the entrenchment of Israeli and Palestinian narratives is thus critical. It does not need to start from scratch, however. Other conflict areas in the world recovering from recent conflicts — such as Northern Ireland and South Africa — provide examples to learn from, through both their successes and their failures. Moreover, structural action through government and administration will benefit from and in turn enhance the work of many of grassroots initiatives that have brought together Israelis and Palestinians through music, sports and nature (to name but a few), and continue to do so today while adapting to the current dire situation.
Any societal process is by definition a long one, and tackling built-in mistrust between Israelis and Palestinians may well take a generation or two. It is nonetheless of the utmost importance in order to avoid the emergence of “spoilers,” as happened during the Oslo process.
Moreover, this type of approach presents two related advantages that are particularly relevant to the current moment. Compared to “pure” high diplomacy, this method is more incremental in nature, since it directs efforts to the areas where they are most necessary and can constitute “gradual wins,” as opposed to end goals that seem unattainable at present.
Furthermore, while work on the societal entrenchment of narratives is critical to implementing any political agreement, it does not dictate any political outcome as such. Therefore, it is the right step — perhaps the only one — to take in a context of heightened tension and instability, as well as inconclusive debates about political solutions.
The current state of the Israeli-Palestinian question is the result of complex processes and intricacies. It is up to the main actors who witnessed its entanglement — the U.S., Europe and the Arab world — to start unraveling it. While a diplomatic push carried forward by strong leaders is needed, a fine-grained approach to the conflict’s impact on society is equally essential.
Even if the disentanglement takes another 100 years, it is still worth it, as better futures for both Israelis and Palestinians depend on each other and will continue to do so.
Dr. Alexander Loengarov managed the EU’s grant scheme for academic mobility with Israeli and Palestinian partners in its first three years. A former official of the European Economic and Social Committee, he is a senior affiliated fellow with the international law department at KU Leuven (Belgium). His views as expressed here are not necessarily those of any of his employers or any other institution.
Date: | |
Tag: | Israel |
-
World - The Guardian
Fifa investigates Israeli ‘discrimination’ after Palestinian FA calls for sanctions
Two investigations announced after council meeting Fifa ‘kicking the can down the road’, claim campaigners Fifa has said it will undertake further investigations into the possibility of ...Yesterday - Israel -
World - ABC News
Palestinian Health Ministry says 14 people killed in an Israeli strike in refugee camp in West Bank
Palestinian Health Ministry says 14 people killed in an Israeli strike in refugee camp in West Bank22 hours ago - Israel -
World - Financial Times
Ehud Olmert and Nasser al-Kidwa: Israelis and Palestinians alike need hope — and a plan
Our peace proposal may be outside of consensus thinking but it could help end this conflict for both our peoples1 hour ago - Israel -
World - Financial Times
War, peace and the American presidency
The Middle East has claimed as many US presidential campaigns as it has given birth to5 hours ago -
Tech - Wired
The Trolling of the 'Minecraft Movie' Trailer Isn’t Exactly What You Think
This is new—but also very old.7 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Palestinians’ approval of US leadership at record low: Gallup
The approval rating in Palestine of U.S. leaders has dropped to a record low, a new survey found. Just 5 percent of Palestinians in the West Bank and East Jerusalem approve of U.S. leadership, the ...Yesterday -
Politics - The Hill
Enough with the debt denial. Let's dig out from this hole.
Former chairs of the House Republican and Democratic campaign committees have warned of the growing national debt and the need for a bipartisan solution to address the issue.Yesterday -
Sports - ABC News
On Football: It's early enough for coaches on the hot seat to cool criticism with a few wins
Doug Pederson won a Super Bowl with a backup quarterback and turned a perennial loser into a playoff winner in his first season6 hours ago -
World - The Guardian
EU court rules gender and nationality enough to grant Afghan women asylum
ECJ ruling follows Afghan women’s challenge to Austrian court refusal to give them refugee status. The European court of justice (ECJ) has ruled that gender and nationality alone are sufficient ...3 hours ago - European Union
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Social media suspensions may be linked to misinformation, not platform bias: study
Social media platforms’ suspensions of accounts may not be rooted in political biases, but rather certain political groups’ tendency to share misinformation, according to a new study. The study, ...29 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Michael Moore: Only 'landslide' loss will guarantee Trump's 'permanent removal from the public eye'
Michael Moore says it'll take former President Trump losing the election "in a landslide" in order to "guarantee" that he fades from the spotlight. "We need to ensure that Trump loses in a ...30 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Trump set to hold 'emotional' rally in Butler, site of assassination attempt
Former President Trump is set to return to Butler, Pa., for what is likely to be a highly charged rally, nearly three months after a bullet grazed his ear at the same site in an attempted ...52 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Hochul: Reports of multiple bomb threats against synagogues 'not credible'
New York State Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) said that the multiple bomb threats against synagogues that were reported Friday were “not credible” and that she has directed the New York State Police to ...53 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Oklahoma defends Bibles-in-schools proposal after report that only Trump's might qualify
Oklahoma Education Superintendent Ryan Walters’s (R) office is defending the process for how the state will be selecting newly mandated Bibles in classrooms after a report was released that the ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump