Supreme Court partially reinstates Arizona voting law at RNC’s request
![Supreme Court partially reinstates Arizona voting law at RNC’s request](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/08/Kansas_voting.jpg?w=900)
The Supreme Court on Thursday partially agreed to the Republican National Committee’s (RNC) emergency request to revive an Arizona law that strengthens proof-of-citizenship requirements for voting.
In a 5-4 vote, the justices reinstated Arizona’s law mandating officials reject state voter registration forms if the person did not provide proof of citizenship.
The court’s three liberal justices — Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson — dissented alongside conservative Justice Amy Coney Barrett.
But in voting to deny the RNC’s other request, those four found themselves in the majority, bolstered by support from at least one of Chief Justice John Roberts or Justice Brett Kavanaugh.
"A seismic win in the fight to stop non-citizens from voting -- more to come!" RNC Chairman Michael Whatley wrote on social platform X.
The RNC had demanded the reinstatement of Arizona’s prohibition that prevents registered voters from casting ballots for president or in the mail if they didn’t provide citizenship proof, even if they used a federal-level form to register, where proof is not required.
If enacted, Arizona's secretary of state's office estimated it could prevent roughly 42,000 people already registered from voting for president this November.
Justices Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito and Neil Gorsuch, who are viewed as the Supreme Court’s three leading conservatives, voted to reinstate those provisions, too.
The ruling came just ahead of Arizona’s ballot printing deadline, enabling the provision to go into effect for this year’s elections, when Arizona is expected to be a critical swing state in the presidential race.
By not fully agreeing to the RNC’s request, the Supreme Court’s decision sides with the Biden administration.
The Justice Department has sued over the latter provision as conflicting with federal law, but it has not challenged the portion impacting only state-level forms.
“Even putting aside the merits, applicants are not entitled to a stay,” U.S. Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar wrote in court filings.
The Democratic National Committee (DNC) and various voting rights groups have challenged both sets of the provisions. The case revolves around claims that the changes are unconstitutional, preempted by federal law and violate a consent decree a state official signed in 2018.
After a federal district judge blocked the provisions and an appeals court refused to lift it, the RNC, joined by Arizona’s top two Republican state lawmakers, thrusted the Supreme Court into the dispute earlier this month by filing an emergency appeal.
They urged the justices to stay the lower ruling by Aug. 22, which is the state’s ballot printing deadline, arguing that the state was authorized to make the voter registration changes.
The challengers, however, urged the Supreme Court to stay out the case, insisting the RNC hadn’t cleared their high burden to receive emergency relief.
Lawyers for the DNC and other private plaintiffs told the justices the RNC “sat on their hands” after losing in a lower court.
“The tardiness is particularly inexcusable here, as applicants seek to weaponize Arizona’s forthcoming ballot-printing deadline to obtain relief,” their written response reads.
Democratic Arizona state officials, meanwhile, argued that the Supreme Court’s intervention “would be destabilizing” given the short timeframe before November’s election.
Updated 3:27 p.m.
Date: |
Topics
-
CBS News - Top stories
Black student enrollment falls at Harvard, more schools after Supreme Court ends affirmative action
Harvard University reported that students identifying as Black made up 14% of this year's freshman class, compared with 18% in 2023. Some other top schools also reported falls in Black student ...21 minutes ago -
Inc. - Business
Utah Social Media Age Verification Law Blocked by Judge
A FederalDistrict Court ruled the measure, intended to protect children, infringed onthe First Amendment rights of social media companies.55 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Why CEOs should want better enforcement of labor law
Right now, penalties are often so low that a simple cost-benefit calculation, absent ethical considerations, would tell many firms to break the law.59 minutes ago -
CBS News - Top stories
States ramp up efforts to enact stricter immigration laws, group finds
Efforts by state lawmakers to pass stricter immigration laws have increased significantly over the past four years, a national civil rights group found in a new report.3 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Taylor Swift urges people to register to vote at VMAs
Pop superstar Taylor Swift urged people to register to vote Wednesday evening during MTV's 2024 Video Music Awards (VMAs). “If you are over 18, please register to vote for something else that’s ...3 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
Jude Law: ‘Playing Henry VIII messed up my back. I’m still trying to sort it out’
The actor answers your questions about football-spectator stress, playing down his good looks, and why he’d like to play Dickie Greenleaf in his 50s. Why did the paps used to call you “Celebrity ...4 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
New York’s top court throws out Trump gag order appeal
New York’s high court tossed out former President Trump’s appeal of the gag order in his hush money criminal case Thursday. The gag order, which remains in partial effect ahead of Trump’s ...4 hours ago - Donald Trump -
GameSpot - Tech
Xbox Friend Requests Are Finally Coming Back
For the first time since the Xbox 360 days, Xbox users will be able to send and receive friend requests. The announcement was made via a blog post on the official Xbox website, which provided more ...4 hours ago -
The New York Times - Lifestyle
During NYFW, Jill Biden, Anna Wintour and More March for Voting Awareness
Jill Biden, Anna Wintour and top American designers participated in a voting awareness march at the onset of New York Fashion Week.5 days ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
US proposes two permanent seats for Africa on UN Security Council
The Biden administration is calling for adding two permanent seats for African nations to the United Nations Security Council, and an elected seat for a small-island developing nation. U.S. ...29 minutes ago - United Nations -
The Hill - Politics
Bridging America's divide: Understanding moral misconceptions
Research suggests that the perceived moral differences between Democrats and Republicans are a major factor in America's political divide, and addressing this misconception could help bridge the gap.29 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
When will you need a REAL ID? It may be complicated
A program that is intended to enhance U.S. travel requirements, which has been delayed multiple times, is scheduled to take effect in May 2025. Hiccups during the initial rollout may, however, ...48 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
'Hundreds of millions' could get piece of Oracle privacy settlement: Here's how to file a claim
The massive tech company has agreed to pay out $115 to settle claims it tracked people's online and offline activity, then violated privacy by selling the information to third parties.59 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Why CEOs should want better enforcement of labor law
Right now, penalties are often so low that a simple cost-benefit calculation, absent ethical considerations, would tell many firms to break the law.59 minutes ago