Bridging America's divide: Understanding moral misconceptions
This op-ed is part of The Hill’s “How to Fix America” series exploring solutions to some of America’s most pressing problems.
We often hear that Democrats and Republicans are worlds apart. But what if that perception is the real issue? Even the most thoughtful among us can fall into the habit of assuming the ideals of the other side. Research reveals that this subtle, yet pervasive, belief — not policy differences — is what truly deepens America’s divide.
Put plainly, we tend to assume our political opponents just don't have any morals. If we start by addressing this quiet misconception, could we begin to close the gap?
Right now, levels of tension between Democrats and Republicans feel higher than ever. Aside from controversy over hot-button issues and polarizing media, other factors contribute to perceived levels of disagreement.
One recent study found that overestimations of the other party’s tolerance for immoral acts contribute to political animosity. In other words, both Democrats and Republicans overestimate how much the other party condones objectively immoral behaviors — such as theft or cheating. From social media searches to polling, results indicate that “morality bias” has permeated popular political perception, and the idea that the other party supports objectively wrong acts contributes to hyperpolarization.
“Dehumanization” of opposing party members is on the rise in the U.S. A search using objectively immoral descriptor words — such as “sociopath,” “felon,” and “murderer” — found that this type of rhetoric has been increasingly used in political conversations on social media. This has spiked even higher since 2016.
Furthermore, the survey sampled Democrats and Republicans and asked them to rank the acceptability of a series of immoral issues (e.g. cheating on a spouse, homicide) and then guess how tolerant they think the other party would be of the same issues. Across all issues, both parties overestimated their opponents’ acceptance of immoral behavior.
Biases disincentivize collaboration and increase political animosity. Inversely, an understanding that opponents condemn basic moral injustices increases the desire for bipartisan collaboration. Conversations correcting the “morality bias” would foster cross-partisan cooperation and make people more likely to want to work across the aisle.
Recent polling from Georgetown University's McCourt School supported by American Policy Ventures found that most voters want representatives who are willing to work across the aisle to get things done. The results showed that voters support lawmakers compromising on many divisive issues — such as inflation, immigration and health care reform — in the name of finding the best solution, as opposed to fighting for their values even if it means a conclusion is never reached.
Perhaps misestimations of the other party’s morality are part of what stalls cross-party progress. It certainly won’t solve all current issues with hyperpolarization, but working to correct the morality bias could be a good place to start.
At the very least, an awareness that bias exists at all could help combat the dehumanization of political figures, as voters realize that just because another party disagrees on certain policy issues does not mean that they condone moral wrongdoings. Interestingly, this study shows that bridging the hyper-partisan divide may begin with something as simple as acknowledging the humanity in our fellow Americans.
Liam deClive-Lowe is the co-founder of American Policy Ventures, an organization that builds projects to help policy makers collaborate and get things done.
Date: |
Topics
-
Financial Times - Business
SEC says FTX auditor did not understand the crypto market
Regulator’s case against Prager Metis details alleged failures in examining the exchange before its collapse4 hours ago - Crypto -
BBC News - Top stories
Pager explosions will devastate Hezbollah's morale and manpower
Tuesday's blasts, which Hezbollah blames on Israel, look calculated to sow fear and confusion.3 hours ago -
Inc. - Business
Corporate America Cares Less and Less About Inflation
Fewer S&P 500 companies are mentioning inflation during earnings calls ahead of the Fed's first rate cut.8 hours ago -
CBS News - Top stories
Key Bridge victims' families to take legal action against shipowner
"Justice for me would be to have my husband at my side," said the widow of one of the workers killed in the Francis Scott Key Bridge collapse in Baltimore last spring.11 hours ago -
ABC News - Top stories
For families of Key Bridge collapse victims, a search for justice begins
The families of the six construction workers killed in the collapse of Maryland's Francis Scott Key Bridge plan to file legal claims against the owner and manager of the container ship that lost ...15 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
America’s story is bigger than Trump’s hateful conspiracy theories
The presidential debate is over, but the people of Springfield, Ohio, are only beginning to face its fallout.9 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
It’s official: America’s real wages are up under Biden-Harris
The average working-class American can now answer yes to the question: Are you better off now than you were under Donald Trump?6 hours ago - Joe Biden -
The New York Times - Top stories
America’s Role in the World Is Hard. It Just Got Much Harder.
The explosion of wireless devices across Lebanon casts in sharp relief the challenges of U.S. foreign policy facing Kamala Harris or Donald Trump.2 hours ago -
ABC News - World
Bolivia's iconic ex-President Morales calls for anti-government march as political fight escalates
Evo Morales, Bolivia’s former president, has called on supporters to protest against current President Luis Arce20 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Mail voting faces significant challenges ahead of November
Election officials are warning that mail voting could face delays and disruption if the U.S. mail delivery system fails to fix persistent issues ahead of November’s contests. In a recent letter to ...40 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Johnson outlines economic plan under Trump if GOP controls government in 2025
Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) on Tuesday outlined his economic agenda for the first 100 days under a second Trump administration — a plan that assumes Republicans will win unified control of ...42 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Republicans question proposal to boost Secret Service funding
Some Republicans are questioning whether a boost in spending for the Secret Service as part of the upcoming government funding bill would help protect former President Trump in the immediate term. ...48 minutes ago - Republican Party -
The Hill - Politics
5 takeaways from Harris's interview with NABJ
PHILADELPHIA – Vice President Harris sat for an interview on Tuesday with the National Association of Black Journalists where she fielded a host of questions on matters of domestic and foreign ...56 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Watch live: Supreme Court Justice Gorsuch outlines new book at Constitution Day event
Supreme Court Associate Justice Neil Gorsuch will discuss his new book "Over Ruled: The Human Toll of Too Much Law," along with his co-author and former clerk Janie Nitze, at a town hall event ...59 minutes ago