Why CEOs should want better enforcement of labor law
We assume that if a company breaks the law, it will be punished. But when it comes to many foundational worker protections, the actual punishment for a violation is little more than a slap on the wrist. A new bill introduced by House Democrats in July — the LET’S Protect Workers Act — seeks to change that by raising penalties for breaking major labor and employment laws.
This action is long overdue and would be a boon not just to vulnerable workers, but also to ethical business leaders who risk being undercut by unscrupulous competitors. Right now, penalties are often so low that a simple cost-benefit calculation, absent ethical considerations, would tell many firms to break the law.
Take the Fair Labor Standards Act, the federal law that guarantees workers a minimum wage (set at $7.25 an hour since 2009) and overtime if they work more than 40 hours in a week. In the statute, there’s scope for very hefty punishments for firms that break the law. But in practice, punishments are scant.
My research shows that most firms caught underpaying workers by the Department of Labor are just required to pay the worker the wages owed in the first place — with no additional financial cost to the firm at all. About one-third of firms have to pay additional damages. Only 6 percent are required to pay a civil monetary penalty on top of this — and the amounts are small, very rarely adding up to much more than the initial underpayment. While many states have heftier enforcement apparatuses and higher penalties, the federal level is the baseline for more than half of the U.S.
Perhaps the starkest contrast is with property theft — a crime that is routinely punished by imprisonment. Shoplifting goods worth $2,500 or more, for example, can lead to felony charges and imprisonment in every state. Failing to pay workers what they are legally owed — wage theft — can in theory also lead to criminal charges, but almost never does.
From 2005 to 2020, the Department of Labor identified more than 90,000 cases where a firm underpaid its workers by $2,500 or more — with total underpayment across these cases of $570 million. Only 26 cases from this time led to criminal convictions, with three fines and no prison sentences.
When people steal from companies, they pay a heavy price. When companies steal from their workers, they don’t.
That is, if a violating firm gets caught at all. The Department of Labor’s inspection resources simply can’t stretch as far as their remit: for every federal wage-and-hour division investigator, there are about 175,000 workers covered by the statutes they enforce. The Labor Department targets its enforcement activity on sectors with high violation risk, but even in these cases research estimates the chance of a random inspection in any given year is less than 2 percent.
The troubling reality is that it’s more profitable for many firms to break minimum wage and overtime laws than to comply with them — and indeed they do, in droves. Companies illegally underpay workers in this way to the tune of several billion dollars each year.
This is striking enough, but for certain other worker protections, the incentive for employers to comply is even weaker. Look at the union protections in the National Labor Relations Act. The NLRA imposes no financial penalty for illegally firing a worker for union organizing — it merely requires the offending firm to reinstate the dismissed worker with compensation for lost earnings. And even once workers have voted for a union, a firm may simply stall to avoid reaching a contract. Failure to bargain in good faith is illegal, but carries no financial penalty.
For firms unconcerned with ethics or reputation, this means there is essentially no deterrent to breaking the law. Is it any wonder, then, that at least one worker is illegally fired in an estimated 20 to 30 percent of union elections, and that more than half of newly certified unions don’t get to a first contract within a year?
These labor rights violations are clearly a serious problem for the affected workers (who are disproportionately likely to be lower-income and racial or ethnic minorities). It’s also an underrated problem for the rest of the business world. Unscrupulous firms that break the law undermine the businesses that want to be ethical, and this puts the principled businesses at risk of being out-competed by the firms that don’t mind breaking the law. They’re forced to compete against firms that are obtaining an illegal advantage top cut labor costs. Just a few bad actors can generate a race to the bottom in a whole industry.
For ethical business leaders, this is their problem, too. Supporting increases in penalties for violators, particularly for the most severe and willful violations, is one way to ensure that a level playing field applies across the board. Additionally, they can advocate for a more effective enforcement system — one that is sufficiently well-resourced to inspect firms and respond to worker complaints, and one that actually imposes meaningful penalties on firms that break the law.
Anna Stansbury is the Class of 1948 Career Development Assistant Professor and an assistant professor of Work and Organization Studies at the MIT Sloan School of Management.
Date: |
-
CBS Sports - Sports
Eagles collapse: Why Philadelphia may have been better off going for it on 4th down instead of kicking FG
The Eagles surprisingly gave the Falcons a better chance to win, despite extending their lead5 hours ago -
CBS News - Top stories
Why you should open a long-term CD this week
High interest rates on long-term CDs could be coming to an end this week. Here's why savers should act now.6 hours ago -
CNBC - Business
OpenAI CEO Sam Altman shares his No. 1 strategy for living without regrets: You should 'put a huge premium' on it
The tech leader encouraged high school students to think about taking calculated risks in their future careers. "Most things are not a one-way door," he said.6 hours ago -
CBS Sports - Sports
Why Ben Roethlisberger believes Steelers' Justin Fields should continue to start at QB over Russell Wilson
Fields has Pittsburgh off to a 2-0 start17 hours ago - NFL -
NBC News - Top stories
Georgian parliament approves law curbing LGBTQ rights
Georgian lawmakers approved the third and final reading of a law on “family values and the protection of minors” that would impose sweeping curbs on LGBTQ rights.7 hours ago -
The New York Times - Business
Boeing Restarts Labor Negotiations as It Seeks End to Strike
Federal mediators are helping the aerospace manufacturer and leaders of the union representing more than 33,000 workers who went on strike last week reach a deal.2 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Report on forced labor, child labor raises tough questions in green energy transition
A new report from the Department of Labor raises tough questions about whether and to what extent forced labor and child labor are intertwined with climate-friendly technology. The department ...11 hours ago -
The New York Times - Top stories
New York Philharmonic Opens Its Season Amid Labor Talks and Troubles
The orchestra is working to negotiate a new contract with musicians, resolve a misconduct inquiry and hire a new chief executive.6 hours ago - New York -
Inc. - Business
Stellantis Fight With Union Heats Up as UAW Files Labor Charges
Autoworkers fear the automaker will move jobs out of U.S. plants as the union files a National Labor Relations Board complaint.4 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Hunter Biden asks to push back gun sentencing a few weeks
Hunter Biden, the president’s son, on Tuesday asked the judge overseeing his criminal gun case to push back his upcoming sentencing by a few weeks. Biden asked to move the scheduled Nov. 13 date ...39 minutes ago - Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Watch live: Trump, Sarah Huckabee Sanders hold town hall in Michigan
Former President Trump will speak with voters in the storied auto manufacturing community of Flint, Mich., Tuesday evening at a town hall moderated by Arkansas Gov. Sarah Huckabee Sanders, who ...59 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Jason Carter says grandfather ready to 'turn page' on Trump era
Jason Carter, the oldest of former President Carter's grandchildren, said Tuesday that his grandfather is "excited" to vote for Vice President Harris and ready to "turn the page" on former ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Klobuchar, Warner press tech leaders to take action against election-related disinformation
Democratic Sens. Amy Klobuchar (Minn.) and Mark Warner (Va.) sent a letter to major tech leaders on Tuesday, urging them to take "decisive action" against disinformation related to the 2024 general ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
Tensions rise after apparent Trump assassination attempt
Welcome to The Hill's Campaign newsletter {beacon} Campaign Report Campaign Report The Big Story Tensions rise after apparent Trump assassination attempt Another major event has shaken up the ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump