Government efficiency is good — fiscal responsibility is better

The U.S. debt ceiling is in the news again.

With the national debt at its $36.1 trillion limit, lawmakers must scramble to raise the ceiling or risk a default. Such debt ceiling gymnastics have become so common that the “game of chicken” played by both parties typically leads to 11th hour compromises and concessions. Yet the need to raise the debt ceiling is symptomatic of a bigger issue: the federal government is broke.

Many will wonder, how can a wealthy country like the U.S. be broke? Well, as a country, we are not. We have an abundance of assets that provides a standard of living envied by people around the world. Even those considered poor in the U.S. would be considered comfortable in most other countries, based on the goods and services they have access to.

For example, 98 percent of people in the U.S. own a mobile phone. Yet more than 11 percent live below the poverty line. This means that a large majority of those living below the poverty line own a mobile phone.

The federal government is broke because it spends more than the revenue it collects. This has been the case for over two decades, dating back to 2001, the last year the federal government had a budget surplus. Such a history of budget imbalances is unsustainable, leading to the situation faced by lawmakers every time they must raise the debt ceiling.

The national debt now exceeds the nation’s gross domestic product by over 20 percent. If a company managed its finances the way that the federal government does, it would need to file for bankruptcy, sell off its assets and/or cease to operate — none of these are options for the U.S. For example, the federal government has over eight times more liabilities than assets ($45.5 trillion versus $5.6 trillion, as of Sept. 30, 2024).

What makes the federal government unique is that it can create money. It covers annual deficits by selling its debt to individuals, corporations and countries around the world.

Foreign countries own over 22 percent of our national debt (around $8 trillion total, as of April 2024). Japan owns over $1.1 trillion of the debt, while China owns around $750 billion. It is worth noting that China has been reducing its exposure to U.S. debt over the past decade, with its peak holding at over $1.66 trillion in 2013.

So what are lawmakers and the executive branch doing about this situation?

The so-called Department of Government Efficiency was created to root out government inefficiencies, fraud and waste within the federal government. An excellent idea, with a failed implementation to date, will likely cost taxpayers more than it will save. As with any complex system, the “devil is always in the details,” and with DOGE, the details are woefully inadequate.

The financial problem faced by the federal government is that it has numerous worthy investments that serve the interests of the population but not enough revenue to cover them all. This means that priorities must be set.

Before USAID was shuttered, its $40 billion budget was viewed to provide a positive return to the nation, effectively making it safer for all Americans. The White House has now identified numerous USAID uses of funds that it deems waste and fraud, some of which do indeed appear wasteful. However, others appear more ideological differences than actual misuse of funds. But throwing out the baby with the bath water is a formula for disaster. Cutting the organization and its mission will ultimately lead to a larger deficit in the future, assuming problems and conflicts that USAID investments would have prevented or deterred require resources to address down the road.

The same applies to pediatric vaccines. If Robert F. Kennedy Jr, the new secretary of Health and Human Services, gets his way and pediatric vaccine uptake wanes, the healthcare costs to treat sick children will far exceed the cost of the vaccines and the benefits (health and financial) they offer. The recent measles outbreak in Texas is a real-time case study of what happens when vaccine acceptance is dampened. RFK Jr’s about-face during the Texas outbreak is a poor response to a situation that could have been averted with stronger leadership and more direct guidance.

A deep dive into where the federal government spends the most money reveals that Social Security must be examined. Since the program now functions as “pay as you go,” in terms of funding, it is critical that the Social Security payroll taxes collected exceed the Social Security checks payments issued.

One place to look is to eliminate the cap on earnings, now set at $176,000. Just 6 percent of people who contribute to Social Security reach this threshold each year. The formula is based on a person’s average indexed monthly earnings over their top 35 earning years.

Analogous to how federal income taxes are progressive, Social Security uses two “bend points“ that provide lower paybacks for higher average indexed monthly earning levels. The final value is called the Primary Insurance Amount. To add high income earners’ contributions to the Social Security system, one can create a third “bend point” for them, paying out just one-half of 1 percent of the Primary Insurance Amount above this new bend point. This means that such high-income earners will certainly contribute more than they will ever collect during their lifetime.

Whether changes to Social Security involve modifications to the payment formula, collecting more payroll taxes from all earners, increasing the retirement age, or some combination of these, a bipartisan effort to keep Social Security solvent must be a priority.

Another big and growing item is interest paid on the national debt. This is projected to be close to $1 trillion in 2025. With the possibility of both higher inflation and higher interest rates in the future, coupled with ongoing annual deficits, this number will only get bigger over time.

Poor fiscal decisions in the past have created the mess faced today by the federal government. There is no easy solution. What is needed more than a Department of Government Efficiency is a Department of Fiscal Responsibility, which sets a standard that lawmakers must adhere to in order to get spending in line with revenue. The Office of Management and Budget appears to serve such a role yet, has no power or authority to effect or enforce change.

Lawmakers on both sides of the aisle must come together to support and enact laws and policies that will get our government fiscal condition in order. Changes to Social Security should be the first of many actions. If executed with a unified front, the risk of being voted out of office by people who continue to demand more from the government than it can offer is diminished.

Without such actions, the federal government will continue to limp along, fiscally. Even if we do not label the government as broke, that does not change its status and the trajectory that it is following. Fiscal responsibility, not government efficiency, is needed.

Sheldon H. Jacobson, Ph.D., is a computer science professor in the Grainger College of Engineering and the Carle Illinois College of Medicine at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign. He applies his expertise in data-driven risk-based decision-making to evaluate and inform public policy and public health.

Topics

DOGE Is Putting Major Government Efficiency Projects at Risk

In its apparent quest to cut government spending and improve efficiency, DOGE has fired entire tech teams devoted to those very things.
Wired - Mar. 7
Republicans want to repeal Biden’s climate legacy. Good luck with that.

President Trump has used funding pauses and Elon Musk's Department of Government Efficiency to target climate initiatives by the federal government, but will need the help of Congress to repeal the ...
The Hill - 6d
Postal Service Reaches Deal With Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency

The U.S. Postal Service has long struggled with its finances. President Trump and Mr. Musk have both suggested it should be privatized.
The New York Times - 4d
Good Job Games raises $23M to make better match-3 games in Turkiye

Good Job Games, a fast-growing mobile game company based in Turkey, has secured $23 million in a seed funding round.
VentureBeat - Mar. 11
European Union announces retaliatory tariffs on these popular U.S. goods

The European Union is targeting certain emblematic U.S. goods as a response to President Trump's recent tariffs on aluminum and steel. CBS News' Olivia Rinaldi reports.
CBS News - 6d
China’s delivery platforms compete to offer better worker benefits

Leading players act as competition intensifies and Beijing points out their ‘national responsibility’
Financial Times - Mar. 11
Trump to increase steel and aluminum tariffs on Canada in response to electricity surcharge

President Trump on Tuesday said his administration will increase planned steel and aluminum tariffs against Canada in response to an electricity surcharge the Ontario government imposed in the ...
The Hill - Mar. 11
Rodrigo Duterte says he will accept responsibility after ICC arrest over ‘war on drugs’

Former Philippines president filmed a video message en route to the Hague, saying ‘I will be responsible for everything’. Former Philippines president Rodrigo Duterte has said he will accept ...
The Guardian - 5d
Is Elon Musk rooting for a government shutdown?

In just over 48 hours, the government will partially shut down unless Congress can pass a continuing resolution. New reporting from Wired finds Elon Musk and his Department of Government Efficiency ...
CBS News - 5d
This PGA Tour Player Says He's Never Met Anyone Better Than Him At Mario Kart 64

In addition to being a winner on the PGA Tour, golfer Joel Dahmen is a self-proclaimed ace at Mario Kart 64. The 37-year-old said in an appearance on Good Good recently that he's yet to meet ...
GameSpot - 5d
UK expels Russian diplomat and a diplomatic spouse in tit-for-tat response to expulsions in Moscow

Britain’s government says it has expelled a Russian diplomat and a diplomatic spouse in a tit-for-tat response to the expulsion of two British embassy staff in Moscow earlier this week
ABC News - 6d
Google Says Its New AI Mode Will Help You Find Better, Deeper Information

The move to make search more efficient with generative AI is a clear shot at OpenAI’s ChatGPT and Perplexity, an AI-powered search engine.
Inc. - Mar. 10
Myanmar resistance group admits responsibility for killing of Buddhist monk it accused of army ties

A local resistance group fighting against the military government in Myanmar has acknowledged responsibility for the killing last week of a Buddhist monk and his disciple in the country’s eastern ...
ABC News - Mar. 11
Farms, Food Banks Cut Off Guard By Spending Cuts

Promising a return to “fiscally responsible initiatives,” the Agriculture Department ended two Biden-era programs that paid farmers to provide food to schools and low-income families.
The New York Times - 5d
With America First, the US can lead the world into a better future

International development is rooted in America’s greatness and goodness, and American strength is central to world peace.
The Hill - Mar. 10
DOGE lease cancellations: Which government offices could be closed this year and when

The General Services Administration, working with Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency, has notified landlords that federal agencies will be terminating hundreds of leases for offices ...
ABC News - 4d
China Outlines Plan to Bolster Consumption in Face of Trump Tariffs

Beijing’s leaders are ordering fiscally strapped local governments to spend more to help workers, consumers and businesses.
The New York Times - 19h
Ukraine war live: Putin response to peace plan ‘not good enough’, says UK, as international militaries prepare to meet in London

Representatives from numerous international militaries will meet in London on Thursday, says UK prime minister. Few resonant phrases are repeated in politics without a deliberate reason, and Keir ...
The Guardian - 3d
Syrians Demand Better Protection Amid a Spate of Kidnappings

When the new government took over, it dismissed the Assad regime police and other forces, leaving a security vacuum. Now, many residents fear going out after dark.
The New York Times - Mar. 10
How good is your 401(k)? New features may help workers save more and spend better.

AI, annuity options, stickier enrollment and more comprehensive advice are setting the new standards for workplace retirement savings plans
MarketWatch - 6h
Beware America’s fake fiscal conservatives

Republicans are indulging in budgetary chicanery in order to preserve Trump’s tax cuts
Financial Times - 5d
Canada will level $20B in tariffs in response to Trump moves on steel, aluminum

Canada is expected to impose $20.7 billion in retaliatory tariffs after President Trump decided to enforce a 25 percent tariff on steel and aluminum, which went into effect Wednesday. ...
The Hill - 6d
Here are 10 ways DOGE can remake our outdated Defense Department

The Department of Government Efficiency has a unique opportunity to modernize the defense business, to bring it to the level of innovation and efficiency enjoyed by America’s private sector.
The Hill - 1d
Congress must save the good journalists at VOA

President Trump's sudden decision to shut down US government-funded entities such as the Voice of America is understandable, but it is crushing for a number of journalists there who have not ...
The Hill - 1d
Congress avoids a shutdown — and gives Trump more tariff power against Canada and Mexico

Congress avoided a government shutdown Friday evening, after the Senate passed legislation that funds the federal government through September at spending levels similar to the 2024 fiscal year.
MarketWatch - 3d
Switzerland told it must do better on climate after older women’s ECHR win

Council of Europe says Swiss government failing to respect human rights court’s ruling on emissions. Europe live – latest updates The Swiss government has been told it must do more to show ...
The Guardian - Mar. 7
Dollar General CEO warns consumers are cash-strapped, and says 2025 won't be better

Tariffs and potential changes to government entitlement programs present potential further headwinds for core customers, said CEO Todd Vasos.
CNBC - 5d
The Dangerously High Cost of Tolerating Trump

Making government more efficient is an admirable goal. But this administration is bent on destroying it, putting our lives and businesses at risk.
Inc. - Mar. 11
Trump calls Tesla boycott 'illegal' and says he's buying one to support Elon Musk

Trump called Musk, the controversial leader of Tesla and a new government efficiency initiative, a "truly great American."
CNBC - Mar. 11
Musk’s cuts fail to stop US federal spending hitting new record

Government spending rose to $603bn in February despite hyperactive efficiency drive, data shows
Financial Times - 6d
DOGE Staff Marches Into U.S. Institute of Peace and Evicts Its Officials

A bubbling dispute broke into a dramatic standoff that ended with police involvement and the Department of Government Efficiency taking up residence at the independent agency.
The New York Times - 17h
The stock market is wobbly. Is now a good time to change how much I invest?

With markets falling in response to economic uncertainty as the Trump administration moves forward with a trade war, some investors are wondering if they should keep investing in the stock market ...
MarketWatch - 5d
'Much better': DBacks' Jordan Montgomery feeling better after backfield game

After struggling last weekend, Arizona Diamondbacks lefty Jordan Montgomery looked much better in a backfield game on Thursday afternoon.
Yahoo Sports - 4d
We 'must act': Europe retaliates against Trump's 25% tariffs on steel and aluminum imports

The European Union said it would impose counter-tariffs on 26 billion euros ($28.33 billion) worth of U.S. goods starting in April in response to the duties.
CNBC - 6d
Mar 10: CBS News 24/7, 10am ET

U.S. tanker collides with container ship off the coast of U.K.; Vatican says Pope Francis experienced "good response" to recent hospital treatments.
CBS News - 5h
State Republicans Eager to Climb on Cost-Cutting Bandwagon

G.O.P. governors and legislators are parroting the federal Department of Government Efficiency by creating panels at the state level. But the similarities only go so far.
The New York Times - Mar. 9
Meet the federal worker who went rogue: ‘I hope that it lights a fire under people’

To billionaire Elon Musk and his cost-cutting team at the Department of Government Efficiency, Karen Ortiz may just be one of many faceless bureaucrats
ABC News - Mar. 10
Hundreds protest Tesla showrooms over Musk's DOGE work

Hundreds of protestors gathered outside of Tesla showrooms on Saturday to showcase their disdain for CEO Elon Musk and his work with the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) in an effort to ...
The Hill - 2d
Judge finds Elon Musk likely acted unconstitutionally in shuttering USAID

A federal judge ruled Tuesday that Elon Musk and the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) likely exercised unconstitutional authority “in multiple ways” in dismantling the U.S. Agency for ...
The Hill - 2h

More in Politics

Democrat on Trump-Putin call: 'Russia remains the obstacle to peace'

Sen. Chris Coons (D-Del.) said it's clear that Russia "remains the obstacle to peace" following a highly anticipated phone call between President Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin on ...
The Hill - 44m
Trump, Putin agree on limited ceasefire in Ukraine

PRESIDENT TRUMP and Russian President Vladimir Putin appeared to make progress on a limited ceasefire agreement in Ukraine during a lengthy phone call on Tuesday that the White House says is the ...
The Hill - 46m
Kornacki: White men, white women and the gap within the gender gap

NBC News National Political Correspondent Steve Kornacki digs into a NBC News poll that shows divisions along race and gender lines in how the American electorate views DEI initiatives and more.
NBC News - 53m
Kentucky lawmakers pass legislation removing conversion therapy restrictions

Kentucky lawmakers passed a measure Friday seeking to protect the controversial practice known as conversion therapy for LGBTQ youth, repealing an executive order from Democratic Gov. Andy Beshear ...
The Hill - 1h
Trump must understand Putin ‘respects strength’ during talks over Ukraine war: Fmr. Amb. to Russia

Former U.S. Ambassador to Russia Michael McFaul discusses the call between President Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin and what talks could mean for the end of the war in Ukraine.
NBC News - 1h