Here are 10 ways DOGE can remake our outdated Defense Department
In the early 1990s, the Department of Defense made a pivotal decision that has shaped American defense production for decades. Then-Secretary of Defense Les Aspin's infamous "Last Supper" meeting with defense industry leaders signaled that the end of the Cold War would mean a drastic reduction in military spending and that industry consolidation was required. This move, reminiscent of Britain's post-war industrial policies, has led to an inefficient and uncompetitive defense sector.
As we stand at another crossroads, the Department of Government Efficiency has a unique opportunity to modernize the defense business, to bring it to the level of innovation and efficiency enjoyed by America’s private sector. As detailed in a recent American Enterprise Institute report, there are steps that the Pentagon could take to propel the modernization of the American military.
The consolidation of the defense industry, much like Britain's failed "national champions" policy, has stifled competition and innovation. The Pentagon's long, inflexible procurement process, last overhauled in 1986, has only exacerbated these issues. Each successive reform has added layers of complexity, making the system less responsive and more bureaucratic. The result is a defense sector plagued by cost overruns and delays.
Today, we have a chance to change this trajectory. The presence of tech industry titans at the recent inauguration, coupled with Google's decision to allow its AI technology to be used in American military weapons, suggests that big tech firms are beginning to recognize their American identity and the importance of supporting national defense. This shift could mark the beginning of a more innovative, efficient and productive future for the Department of Defense.
To achieve this future, DOGE must help the Pentagon rethink its approach to defense production. Here are 10 specific actions that can help align requirements with warfighting needs, eliminate excessive acquisition regulations, promote competition and modernize the defense budget:
- Eliminate the acquirer-operator divide: The defense organizational structure currently separates innovators and acquirers from the people who will actually use the innovations. The services should reallocate by mission area those innovation organizations that have been established to work around the system so they are closely in touch with the warfighters they support. This would start to reverse the centralization of power that began with the Goldwater-Nichols legislation in 1986. Special Operations Command has demonstrated the effectiveness of this model, innovating faster and better than the services.
- Cut regulations: Reduce the Defense Acquisition rulebook by 75 percent, starting with non-statutory regulations. Encourage the acquisition workforce to balance diligence with aggressive creativity and seek input from industry on regulatory barriers.
- Rescind executive orders: Work with the White House to find and rescind executive orders that impose unnecessary compliance burdens on defense contractors.
- Forbid joint programs: Stop creating joint and multi-service programs to drive competition back into the procurement system. The Joint Strike Fighter program exemplifies the inefficiencies and cost overruns these programs currently create.
- Prioritize scalability: Focus on scalable, cost-effective and timely delivery of weapons and munitions. The military should prepare for two long-duration wars — one in Europe and one in the Pacific — and avoid expensive, un-scalable weapons.
- Simplify accounting: Eliminate the requirement for defense companies to maintain separate financials for the Department of Defense, reducing administrative overhead in industry and encouraging commercial best practices.
- Modernize the budget: Overhaul the defense budget structure by eliminating legacy statutory appropriations titles to remove barriers between development, procurement and sustainment. Consolidate program elements and budget line items to simplify oversight and execution.
- Create a rapid response fund: Establish a large, no-color, multi-year appropriation for buying drones and new information technology systems, allowing for rapid response to national security challenges.
- Revise contracting practices: Empower contracting officers to write new contracts faster and more efficiently and prohibit the use of "thin primes" that subcontract most of the work. This will save taxpayer money and improve control over contractors.
- Strip obsolete statutes: Propose that the fiscal 2026 National Defense Authorization Act remove statutory provisions that no longer make sense, fostering a more dynamic and competitive defense sector.
The post-“Last Supper” consolidations of the 1990s transformed the U.S. defense industry into a state-managed sector, echoing the failed industrial policies of post-war Britain. The result has been monopolization, inefficiency and stagnation. To maintain its military and technological edge, the U.S. must break free from this legacy and restore genuine industrial competition.
The Pentagon must stop acting as a central planner and start fostering an environment where innovation, efficiency and competition can thrive once again. Otherwise, America's defense industrial base risks suffering the same fate as British industry: once dominant, now a cautionary tale.
Elaine McCusker is a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute. She previously served as the Pentagon’s acting undersecretary of defense (comptroller). Todd Harrison is a senior fellow at AEI. He previously worked as a senior executive in the defense industry and as an officer in the Air Force Reserves. Retired U.S. Army Maj. Gen. John G. Ferrari is a senior nonresident fellow at AEI. He previously served as a director of program analysis and evaluation for the service.
-
Postal Service Reaches Deal With Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency
The U.S. Postal Service has long struggled with its finances. President Trump and Mr. Musk have both suggested it should be privatized.The New York Times - 3d -
DOGE Is Putting Major Government Efficiency Projects at Risk
In its apparent quest to cut government spending and improve efficiency, DOGE has fired entire tech teams devoted to those very things.Wired - Mar. 7 -
Musk having ‘great difficulty’ running businesses amid DOGE obligations, Tesla stock slide
Tech billionaire Elon Musk admitted he is having “great difficulty” running his various businesses as he juggles an advisory role in the Trump administration and leads the Department of Government ...The Hill - 6d -
Vance: Musk has made some ‘mistakes’ with DOGE’s federal worker firings
Vice President Vance said during an interview that senior President Trump adviser Elon Musk has made some “mistakes” with the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) firings of federal ...The Hill - 2d -
60 percent of voters unhappy with DOGE handling of federal workers: Poll
A majority of voters are unhappy with the Department of Government Efficiency’s (DOGE) handling of federal workers, according to a new poll. When asked about “the way Elon Musk and DOGE are dealing ...The Hill - 3d -
How DOGE is already changing the spending process in Congress
The Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) has done significant work in exposing wasteful government programs, but this has created a difficult situation for the Trump administration as they ...The Hill - 5d -
Postal Service signs cost-cutting deal with DOGE
The United States Postal Service said it has signed a deal with the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) to cut costs at the agency. Postmaster General Louis DeJoy told congressional leaders ...The Hill - 3d -
Karl Rove: Trump claims of DOGE 'fraud' discoveries will backfire
Republican strategist Karl Rove said President Trump’s claims that the Department of Government Efficiency (DOGE) has discovered “hundreds of billions” in government “fraud” will backfire when ...The Hill - 6d -
DOGE lease cancellations: Which government offices could be closed this year and when
The General Services Administration, working with Elon Musk’s Department of Government Efficiency, has notified landlords that federal agencies will be terminating hundreds of leases for offices ...ABC News - 3d
More from The Hill
-
Trump is tackling every ‘emergency’ except the important one — climate change
While Team Trump dwells inside their bubble of false facts and alternative realities, the rest of America is experiencing a relentless succession of tragedies. The human and economic costs are ...The Hill - 20m -
HUD, Interior announce plan to use federal land for affordable housing
Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Secretary Scott Turner and Department of the Interior Secretary Doug Burgum announced on Monday plans to identify federal lands where affordable ...The Hill - 23m -
What is Tren de Aragua, Venezuelan gang targeted by Trump for deportations?
Tren de Aragua, commonly known as TdA, is the Venezuelan gang targeted by President Trump in recent mass deportations. On Saturday, Trump invoked the Alien Enemies Act of 1798, the first time it’s ...The Hill - 28m -
White House says it will eliminate national monuments — then scrubs the announcement
The White House said Friday night that it would eliminate protections from millions of acres declared by former President Biden as national monuments — but later scrubbed that language from its ...The Hill - 28m -
Schumer: Democrats have 'a real direction now'
Senate Democratic Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.), who has been the target of scathing criticism from members of his own party after voting for a Republican-drafted stopgap spending bill that cut ...The Hill - 34m
More in Politics
-
Trump is tackling every ‘emergency’ except the important one — climate change
While Team Trump dwells inside their bubble of false facts and alternative realities, the rest of America is experiencing a relentless succession of tragedies. The human and economic costs are ...The Hill - 20m -
HUD, Interior announce plan to use federal land for affordable housing
Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Secretary Scott Turner and Department of the Interior Secretary Doug Burgum announced on Monday plans to identify federal lands where affordable ...The Hill - 23m -
What is Tren de Aragua, Venezuelan gang targeted by Trump for deportations?
Tren de Aragua, commonly known as TdA, is the Venezuelan gang targeted by President Trump in recent mass deportations. On Saturday, Trump invoked the Alien Enemies Act of 1798, the first time it’s ...The Hill - 28m -
White House says it will eliminate national monuments — then scrubs the announcement
The White House said Friday night that it would eliminate protections from millions of acres declared by former President Biden as national monuments — but later scrubbed that language from its ...The Hill - 28m -
Trump signs executive order aimed at gutting Voice of America and six other federal agencies
President Donald Trump signed an executive order to gut the parent of U.S. government-funded media outlet Voice of America and six other federal agencies. NBC News' Aaron Gilchrist reports on the ...NBC News - 34m