2024 has been an ‘unprecedented’ election, but the polls are telling us another story
The campaign sprint to Election Day has begun, and as always, an inordinate amount of attention is on public polling. Those polls are telling us the real story of the campaign so far — but are we willing to listen?
Looking across the campaign over the last six months, beyond the wilder twists — including not just two vice presidential selections but also President Biden's unprecedented withdrawal and two attempts on Donald Trump's life — a clearer story emerges. The only significant changes in head-to-head presidential polling happened in quick succession: after Biden’s debate, and then after Harris replaced him as the nominee.
That’s it — all the rest is noise.
Beginning in the spring of this year, Trump held a small but steady lead in the polling averages, ranging from 1 to 2 points. None of the day-to-day drama budged that lead beyond that.
Biden’s debate performance created an immediate and sustained expansion in Trump’s lead, to nearly 4 points nationally. Importantly, key numbers on personal characteristics — including mental sharpness and capacity to make good economic decisions — swung in the former president’s favor. The assassination attempt and GOP convention may have solidified that change, but there is little evidence that it helped expand it.
Biden’s decision to leave the ticket, and Harris’s quick consolidation of support, had a massive effect in the opposite direction. Looking across polling averages, from Trump’s peak to Harris’s peak, collective events around the transition caused a net change of over 6 points.
What about Harris’s recent debate performance? The early returns show no clear surge.
Despite the media’s breathless coverage about “unprecedented” campaign events, polling tells a more boring story: This election looks a lot like two of the last three cycles.
In both 2012 and 2016, the election was very tight at this stage. In 2016, Hillary Clinton held just a 2-point lead two months out; Barack Obama held a 4-point lead at this point in 2012.
The 2012 race tightened after the first Obama-Romney debate, when Romney actually pulled ahead by about 1 point. But in the end, Obama won by 3 points, with 51 percent of the vote and 332 electoral votes.
In 2016, Clinton’s 2-point lead expanded after her final debate against Trump, but then shrank after James Comey announced the FBI was investigating the former secretary of State's use of a private email server. Clinton took the popular vote by 2 points (with 48 percent of the vote), but received just 232 electoral votes in her loss.
What about the states? That’s the right question, because the winning candidate has to win 270 electoral votes by winning states, not the national vote. But when it comes to polling, the math is very complicated. Because of their dominance among rural voters, the GOP is better positioned to win without winning the national popular vote, as Democrats rack up “extra” votes in the urban areas of states like California and New York.
So what do the polls say about which states we should we look at? Here’s where the calculations are hardest. Polls vary in quality and frequency at the state level, making it difficult to truly assess the relative “winnability” of different states.
Moreover, there are at least a dozen realistic combinations of states (and parts of states in Nebraska and Maine) that can lead each side to victory — or to a 269-269 tie. One cycle’s pivotal states are often different from the previous one. In 2020, the pivotal states were Georgia and Arizona. In 2016, it was the “blue wall” of Pennsylvania, Michigan and Wisconsin. And in 2012, Obama took former Republican strongholds Florida, Ohio and Virginia.
What’s it going to be in 2024? Could it be the Blue Wall again? Or perhaps a combination of Georgia and Pennsylvania? The polls will point to any number of states, but just like in 2012 and 2016, the states that determine the election might be different from what we expected.
We are headed for the home stretch. So far, according to the polls, the ups and downs of the campaign are fewer than we want to imagine. Are we ready to listen?
Doug Usher, Ph.D., is partner at Forbes-Tate Partners and an adviser to the master’s program in political analytics at Columbia University School of Professional Studies. Greg Wawro, Ph.D., is director of the master’s program in political analytics at Columbia University School of Professional Studies.
Date: |
-
BBC News - Top stories
What insults tell us about the Trump-Harris election fight
As both campaigns make claims about inflammatory rhetoric, what do the candidates themselves say about their rival?2 days ago - Donald Trump -
The Guardian - World
Labour has been overdoing the doom and gloom – but now Reeves has given us a glimpse of sunshine | Polly Toynbee
Though the freebies scandal soured the start of conference, the party can still shake off despondency and regain the moral high ground . With the hail of bad freebie stories echoing the Mersey ...9 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
Peeping Toms and ‘black Nazis’ – what the Mark Robinson scandal tells us about the US election race | Arwa Mahdawi
The Republican party has more than its share of mean and misguided representatives. But Robinson, the man running for governor of North Carolina, has a good claim to have outdone them all. Do you ...28 minutes ago -
CBS Sports - Sports
2024-25 Fantasy Hockey Busts: Sam Reinhart has been productive but last year's success may not be sustainable
Corey Abbott highlights players you'll want to avoid in your Fantasy drafts3 days ago -
CBS News - Top stories
Jane Fonda on climate activism, 2024 election: "We can't lose another 4 years"
Jane Fonda spoke with CBS News about why she joined the fight: "This isn't just about the environment. This is about the whole planet."Yesterday - Climate -
Financial Times - World
Election day is already here for some US voters as states open the polls early
Tens of millions of Americans will have cast their ballots before polling day on November 52 days ago -
BBC News - Top stories
'I no longer feel afraid to speak up' - survivor tells her story
Natacha says she is speaking out now for her daughters and fellow victims of abuse by Mohamed Al Fayed.4 days ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Vance-Walz VP debate going to be 'most important … in US history': Presidential historian
The vice presidential debate scheduled for next Tuesday between Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz (D) and Sen. J.D. Vance (R-Ohio) will be the most important such meeting in U.S. history, according to one ...36 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Watch live: Senate Judiciary holds hearing on Supreme Court immunity ruling
The Senate Judiciary Committee will hold a hearing Tuesday morning focused on potential risks following the Supreme Court's unprecedented decision earlier this year that determined core ...37 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Watch live: Biden delivers last UN General Assembly address
President Biden is slated to deliver his final address before the U.N. General Assembly Tuesday morning in New York City. Biden will give his farewell speech on what is arguably the biggest global ...37 minutes ago - Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Meetings with China, without deterrence, will not stop its aggression against Taiwan
Jake Sullivan's visit to Beijing aims to address rising tensions between the US and China. Will it lead to lower tensions or escalate the conflict?37 minutes ago - China -
The Hill - Politics
Watch live: Senate HELP committee grills Novo Nordisk on weight loss drug pricing
Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.), chair of the Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions (HELP) Committee, is set to grill Novo Nordisk CEO Lars Jorgenson Tuesday morning over prices on the ...37 minutes ago