Meetings with China, without deterrence, will not stop its aggression against Taiwan
Jake Sullivan’s visit to Beijing last month was the first by a U.S. national security adviser in eight years. The purpose of the trip was to address rising tensions between the United States and China over Beijing’s increasingly aggressive actions in the South China Sea and toward Taiwan, as well as China’s ongoing support for Russia’s war on Ukraine.
Sullivan said his discussion with Gen. Zhang Youxia of the Central Military Commission was a “very important meeting,” and the White House affirmed that it was “to prevent competition from veering into conflict.”
Zhou Bo, a retired senior colonel in the People’s Liberation Army, said, “Any talks at any level between China and the US are always welcome....The key is to avoid a conflict and the way forward is to keep open lines of communication wherever possible.”
But over the past three and a half years, there have been multiple U.S.-China talks with military and civilian officials at various levels, up to and including President Biden and General Secretary Xi Jinping. Not long after each meeting, China has taken some action — military, economic or diplomatic — that has precipitated a U.S. response and begun a new cycle of deteriorating relations that require renewed meetings or phone calls to lower tensions.
China and its sympathizers argue that dramatic Chinese actions, such as the firing of missiles over Taiwan and the obvious rehearsal for a blockade of the island, followed provocative Taiwanese and/or American actions, such as U.S. House Speaker Pelosi’s visit to Taiwan in 2022.
But China considers any normal commercial, diplomatic or security interaction between Taiwan and the U.S. (or other countries) as encouraging Taiwan’s separation and independence from China. As Zhang told Sullivan, “The core of the U.S.-China conflict is the Taiwan issue. The U.S. must refrain from interfering in Taiwan for a constructive relationship between our countries. We demand that the U.S. halt its arms sales to Taiwan and stop spreading false narratives about the issue.”
Congress passed the Taiwan Relations Act in 1979 to counter the devastating effect of President Jimmy Carter’s sudden switch of U.S. diplomatic relations from Taipei to Beijing. It states that “any effort to determine the future of Taiwan by other than peaceful means, including by boycotts or embargoes, [is] a threat to the peace and security of the Western Pacific area and of grave concern to the United States.”
The act mandates two roles for the U.S. in Taiwan’s security: first, to provide weapons “of a defensive nature” to Taiwan, and second, “to maintain the capacity of the United States to resist any resort to force or other forms of coercion … [against] … the people on Taiwan.”
The act also contains a potential bombshell for U.S.-China relations: “to make clear that the United States decision to establish diplomatic relations with the People’s Republic of China rests upon the expectation that the future of Taiwan will be determined by peaceful means.” That means that if China “resorts to force or other forms of coercion” against Taiwan, the U.S. is justified in breaking diplomatic relations with Beijing — a much more drastic outcome than economic decoupling.
Zhang also emphasized, “Opposing Taiwan’s independence and promoting reunification is the mission and responsibility of the Chinese military. We will firmly counter any provocations from forces supporting Taiwan’s independence.”
The United States constantly seeks to assuage Beijing by declaring “We do not support Taiwan independence.”
But the China-U.S. problem over Taiwan is much deeper and more intractable than discouraging Taiwan from declaring formal independence, which is what the U.S. disclaimer is generally taken to mean. Beijing just as vehemently opposes Taiwan’s de facto independence, which is what Taiwan presently enjoys. The normal, daily political intercourse between Taiwan and the U.S. and other countries demonstrates Taiwan’s ongoing practical independence, and that is a bone in Beijing’s throat.
China’s 2005 Anti-Secession Law reflects its absolutist approach to the Taiwan question. It arrogates to itself the prerogative to use force against Taiwan if it simply takes too long to submit to unification. Henry Kissinger endorsed China’s ultimatum when he warned Taiwan in 2007 that “China will not wait forever.” (He delivered that advice from the Asia Society in New York, having never found time in his century on earth to visit Taiwan.) Shortly after taking power in 2014, Xi Jinping reinforced the message of the law, and Kissinger’s warning, by declaring that the Taiwan question “cannot be passed from one generation to the next.”
Did the Sullivan-Zhang meeting help lower Washington-Beijing tensions in the region or ameliorate Beijing’s behavior? China not only continued but escalated its naval and air incursions around and through Taiwan’s waters and Air Defense Identification Zone. It deployed a Chinese aircraft carrier, accompanied by two destroyers, through waters northeast of Taiwan, and for the first time entered Japan’s contiguous zone. Yet, since 2007, the United States has not dared to send one of its own carrier battle groups through the international waters of the Taiwan Strait.
Nor has China stopped funding and arming Russia’s aggression in Ukraine. Outgoing NATO Secretary-General Jens Stoltenberg said last week, “China has become a decisive enabler of Russia's war against Ukraine. China is the one that enables production of many of the weapons that Russia uses....I call on China to stop supporting Russia's illegal war."
Hopefully, Sullivan gave an equally strong message in Beijing.
Joseph Bosco served as China country director for the secretary of Defense from 2005 to 2006 and as Asia-Pacific director of humanitarian assistance and disaster relief from 2009 to 2010. He is a nonresident fellow at the Institute for Corean-American Studies and a member of the advisory board of the Global Taiwan Institute.
Date: | |
Tag: | China |
Topics
-
Financial Times - World
US and Taiwan seek to strengthen drone supply chain to keep out China
Co-operation would be part of wider western ‘de-risking’ because of security fears over Chinese products4 days ago - China -
CBS News - Top stories
Will mortgage rates drop in October without a Fed meeting?
Mortgage rates are in the 6.00% range now, but could that change? Here's what could happen in October, experts say.2 hours ago - Mortgage -
The Guardian - World
Is Labour on track to meet its promises on the environment?
Though the party has plenty to celebrate at its first conference in power for 15 years, there is much work to do to on net zero. When Keir Starmer arrives in Liverpool this weekend promising an ...3 days ago -
The New York Times - Top stories
China Is Striking Deals to Cement Its Role as Asia’s Trade Hub
Beijing’s leaders are working with regional neighbors on the country’s western, northern and southern borders to develop new rail and sea links.12 hours ago - China -
CNBC - Business
Secret Service blames poor planning, 'complacency' for its failure to stop Trump assassination attempt
Trump was grazed with a bullet at a presidential campaign rally near Butler, Pennsylvania, in July when shooter Thomas Crooks opened fire at the stage.3 days ago - Donald Trump -
CBS News - Top stories
Meet the California Democrats getting money from Big Oil and voting against environmental laws
At the State Capitol, CBS News California found that Democrats get more money from big oil than Republicans. And unlike their D.C. counterparts, Democrats in the California statehouse often vote ...19 hours ago - California -
CNBC - Business
Anti-Defamation League sues Intel, its first-ever discrimination case against major American company
The Anti-Defamation League joins lawsuit alleging discrimination at Intel tied to Israel-Gaza War, the first time it has sued a major company in over 100 years.4 days ago -
BBC News - Top stories
Taiwan says it did not make Hezbollah pager parts
The pagers that exploded had labels pointing to a Taiwanese firm - but it denied making the devices.4 days ago -
Financial Times - Business
Netanyahu’s polls rebound after aggressive Israeli operations
Since approving assassinations in Beirut and Tehran, premier’s Likud party has taken lead in national surveys12 hours ago - Israel
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Congress must restore humanitarian funding to stop famine in Gaza
Continuing to block U.S. funding for UNRWA’s vital work is a cruel and unwarranted mistake that will only needlessly exacerbate the already catastrophic humanitarian suffering in Gaza.33 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Brett Favre says he has Parkinson’s
Brett Favre revealed that he was diagnosed with Parkinson's disease in a congressional hearing on welfare accountability Tuesday. Favre testified at the hearing of the House Ways and Means ...37 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
SNAP increases – and changes to who qualifies – take effect Oct. 1
As inflation continues to drive grocery prices higher, food assistance benefits are going up, as well.57 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Meryl Streep: Afghan women have fewer rights than cats, birds
Hollywood actress Meryl Streep criticized the Taliban and the severe restrictions posed on women's rights in Afghanistan since its takeover in 2021, urging the international community to do more. ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
To defeat Hamas, Israel must control Gaza’s border with Egypt
Defeating Hamas requires starting in the place it gained much of its power from: the border with Egypt.1 hour ago - Israel