‘Woke’ didn’t lose the US election: the patrician class who hijacked identity politics did | Nesrine Malik
Why is this simple explanation being so widely embraced? Because it does not require a commitment to real, structural change
The day that wokeness died. That has been one of the primary analyses of Donald Trump’s resounding election victory: that it was a resounding rejection of the “woke” left and the casting off of the shackles of political correctness. According to sections of the media and political establishment, people are tired of being harangued and scolded for not using the right language, annoyed by a constant focus on race and identity, and alarmed by a new orthodoxy of radical politics eager to please individual groups at the expense of common sense. “The era,” summarised one British journalist, “of Black Lives Matter, Latinx, critical race theory, pronouns and defunding the police is over.” It’s a neat conclusion – it’s hard not to see this result as a rejection of something. But was that something “woke” values in particular?
As a starting point, it is worth looking at Kamala Harris’s campaign rather than the assumptions about it. In reality, she seemed to avoid any focus on identity and “wokeness”. She didn’t make much of her race, or even her gender, choosing instead to ground her identity in her background as a middle-class person raised in a rental household by a hardworking mother. Her position on race softened from when she was running in 2019: she previously backed “some form” of reparations but did not stake out a position as part of her bid. Trump wanted Harris “to say something to turn off white voters. She was wise not to take the bait,” wrote the author Keith Boykin. She was hardline on immigration, keen to show that she is a gun owner (memorably telling Oprah Winfrey: “If someone breaks into my house they’re getting shot”). And she was evasive on gender-affirming care for transgender Americans.
Nesrine Malik is a Guardian columnist
Do you have an opinion on the issues raised in this article? If you would like to submit a response of up to 300 words by email to be considered for publication in our letters section, please click here.
Continue reading...Topics
-
We’re supposed to ‘put politics aside’ to celebrate Kemi Badenoch – but how can we? | Nesrine Malik
World - The Guardian - November 4 -
In Shift From 2020, Identity Politics Loses Its Grip on the Country
Top stories - The New York Times - November 2 -
Caleb Williams and Bears didn’t snap losing streak vs. Packers. But did they snap out of their offensive rut?
Sports - Yahoo Sports - November 18 -
Did the US election polls fail?
Top stories - BBC News - November 7 -
Who did these undecided US voters finally pick?
Top stories - BBC News - November 4 -
Democrats and the Case of Mistaken Identity Politics
Top stories - The New York Times - November 9 -
One thing I’m sure of: Harris offered voters nothing on Gaza, and it mattered in the result | Nesrine Malik
World - The Guardian - November 11 -
Behind Trump’s victory lies a cold reality: liberals have no answers for a modern age in crisis | Nesrine Malik
World - The Guardian - November 18 -
Here's how the winner of the 2024 US presidential election did it | Jonathan Freedland
World - The Guardian - November 1
More from The Guardian
-
Displaced residents return to southern Lebanon as Israel-Hezbollah ceasefire appears to hold – Middle East crisis live
World - The Guardian - 23 minutes ago -
Trump’s Gorka pick met with outrage: he’s ‘as dangerous as he is unqualified’
World - The Guardian - 3 hours ago -
Russia-Ukraine war live: Ukrainian envoy in South Korea to discuss arms; Moscow tells US to stop supplying Kyiv
World - The Guardian - 24 minutes ago -
Elusive deer spotted wearing high-vis jacket in Canada: ‘Who is responsible?’
World - The Guardian - 3 hours ago -
Von der Leyen calls for more EU defence spending after narrow election victory
World - The Guardian - 38 minutes ago