Behind Trump’s victory lies a cold reality: liberals have no answers for a modern age in crisis | Nesrine Malik

As authoritarians triumph by lying and scapegoating, there is no hope for centrists doubling down on a broken neoliberal system

The most useful lesson of growing up under a dictatorship is that dictatorships are never absolute. Sometimes they are even democracies – ones that thrive by co-opting those with proximity to power and managing those who do not benefit. That management is often through brute oppression, but mainly it is through securing consent by convincing enough people that things are about to get really great. Any minute now, once the enemies of the people are thwarted, a corner will be turned. Authoritarian democracies recognise anger, foment it, then bottle it for their own purposes.

The trick is to always have a horizon, distant but in sight, beyond which things will get better. While this happens, the trappings of national success assuage the masses and give a sense of power, prosperity and momentum. In Egypt, as the jails swelled with political prisoners, the military government erected grand pharaonic monuments and embarked on a colossal construction project in the capital. In India, Narendra Modi entrenched authoritarianism while he wooed big business and launched enormous infrastructure projects and Hindu temples. Dictators establish themselves as both great modernisers and stabilisers, promising both conservatism and futurism. They emphasise traditions and values but wrap these up in technology, urbanisation and even a certain aesthetic – clean lines, mirrors, glass and steel skyscrapers.

Nesrine Malik is a Guardian columnist

Topics

Latest in World

Bangladesh tribunal tells investigators to finish probe against ousted premier Hasina by next month
World - ABC News - 3 minutes ago
Australia v Pakistan: third Twenty20 international – live
World - The Guardian - 15 minutes ago
Clip of Pakistan military chief touching Saudi crown prince's knee is AI generated
World - Yahoo News - 20 minutes ago
Hizbollah chief spokesperson killed in Israeli strike on Beirut
World - Financial Times - 22 minutes ago
Ukraine war live: Biden decision to allow Kyiv to use US missile inside Russia an escalation ‘to the max’, Russian politician says
World - The Guardian - 25 minutes ago

Behind Trump’s victory lies a cold reality: liberals have no answers for a modern age in crisis | Nesrine Malik

Topics

Related

Trump supporters who bought his lies about the last election face reality in court

The lesson of Israel’s unfathomably cruel war: ours is still a world where might is right | Nesrine Malik

We’re supposed to ‘put politics aside’ to celebrate Kemi Badenoch – but how can we? | Nesrine Malik

One thing I’m sure of: Harris offered voters nothing on Gaza, and it mattered in the result | Nesrine Malik

The Guardian view on Ukraine after Trump’s victory: bracing for what lies ahead | Editorial

Trump says win ushers ‘golden age of America’ in victory speech

Trump’s victory will change America. But Europe can have a different future

Middle East crisis live: France sees ‘window’ to end wars in Gaza and Lebanon after Trump victory

Soaring grocery prices helped Trump to victory. The climate crisis is only going to make this worse | James Meadway

More from The Guardian

Ukraine war live: Biden decision to allow Kyiv to use US missile inside Russia an escalation ‘to the max’, Russian politician says

Climate crisis to blame for dozens of ‘impossible’ heatwaves, studies reveal

Starmer aims to build ‘pragmatic and serious relationship’ in meeting with Xi

Vladimir Shklyarov, Russian ballet star, dies aged 39 after falling from building

Women’s rights groups fear FGM is rife among Sudanese refugees in Chad

Latest in World

Bangladesh tribunal tells investigators to finish probe against ousted premier Hasina by next month

Australia v Pakistan: third Twenty20 international – live

Clip of Pakistan military chief touching Saudi crown prince's knee is AI generated

Hizbollah chief spokesperson killed in Israeli strike on Beirut

Ukraine war live: Biden decision to allow Kyiv to use US missile inside Russia an escalation ‘to the max’, Russian politician says