A temple to extravagance. And that goes for Manchester United’s new stadium, too | Rowan Moore
Could Norman Foster’s £2bn design for the club, which will be seen 25 miles away, turn out to be a case of hubris before ruin?
There’s a phenomenon in architectural history whereby great empires build their grandest monuments just before they fall. The Parthenon was completed just before Athens embarked on the devastating Peloponnesian War. Manhattan’s most celebrated skyscrapers went up on the brink of the Great Depression. The British inaugurated the imposing government buildings of New Delhi 16 years before the end of the Raj. I won’t say that this will definitely be the case with the £2bn stadium designed by the Mancunian Norman Foster for Manchester United Football Club, but it’s striking that it’s proposed at a time when the club has closed its staff canteen and made redundant hundreds of workers to cut costs.
Every good thing is promised. It is to be “the world’s greatest football stadium”, iconic AND sustainable, with both rainwater harvesting and a “trident” of 200m-high masts visible from 25 miles away. There is to be a “public space” twice the size of Trafalgar Square and a “mixed use mini-city” around it. There are things to like about the plans, including an attempt to avoid the fortress-like exteriors presented by most stadiums in favour of something more open and lively. But they’d probably do well to concentrate on doing fewer things as well as possible. Otherwise, the building might be like one of those football teams made up of extravagant signings who somehow don’t gel.
Continue reading...
Read more at The Guardian
Topics
-
Manchester United to replace Old Trafford with new 100,000-seater stadium
Soccer giant Manchester United plans to say goodbye to its storied Old Trafford stadium and build a new 100,000-seat stadium nearby.NBC News - Mar. 11 -
A new Manchester United stadium isn’t about regeneration and never will be | Jonathan Liew
If ‘New Trafford’ is such a nailed-on wealth generator, then why aren’t Ratcliffe and the Glazers funding it themselves?. The roof of the proposed new Manchester United stadium has three points, ...The Guardian - 5d -
Who is Manchester United’s new stadium for?
Norman Foster’s redesign of Old Trafford brings to the fore a long-standing uneasiness about the monetisation of footballFinancial Times - Mar. 15 -
New Manchester United stadium a ‘risk’ to team’s competitiveness, admits CEO
Berrada hopes investment in team will not be affected Plan to build £2bn stadium in five years has this in mind Omar Berrada has admitted it is a “risk” for Manchester United to try to build a ...The Guardian - Mar. 12 -
Man United's new stadium will be big, but it won't be world's biggest football ground
Manchester United's proposed new 100,000-seat home will be one of the world's largest soccer stadiums, but it won't be the biggest.ESPN - Mar. 12 -
Manchester United need permission from airport authorities before progressing with new stadium plans
Manchester United have grand plans for a new 100,000-seater stadium to replace Old Trafford with the designs already out on social media.The design incorporates the trident design from the club ...Yahoo Sports - 6d -
Watch: Man Utd release images of new stadium
Look at plans for Manchester United's new stadium as they aim to build an "iconic" new 100,000-seater ground close to Old Trafford.BBC News - Mar. 11 -
Man Utd's new stadium - 11 key questions
BBC Sport looks at some of the key questions surrounding Manchester United's proposed new stadium.BBC News - Mar. 11 -
Government “really keen to crack on” with new Man United stadium
Manchester United’s plans for a new 100,000-capacity stadium received a huge boost with the UK Government revealed to be “really keen to crack on” with the project. The ambitious plot to build w...Yahoo Sports - 3d -
Manchester United to Build 100,000-Seat Stadium
The Premier League club has chosen to build a new venue rather than redevelop Old Trafford’s existing structure.The New York Times - Mar. 12 -
Man Utd to leave Old Trafford for new stadium
Manchester United have officially announced plans to leave Old Trafford, their home for more than 100 years, and move into a new stadium.ESPN - Mar. 11 -
Manchester United reveals plans for the "world's greatest" soccer stadium to replace Old Trafford
Manchester United has unveiled plans to build the biggest stadium in the United KingdomABC News - Mar. 11 -
Architects promise to preserve Old Trafford’s history in new stadium
The architects behind Manchester United’s new stadium have pledged to honour Old Trafford’s rich history.Last week, United confirmed plans to build a new 100,000-seater stadium rather than refurbi...Yahoo Sports - 4d -
Manchester United reveals plans for new 100,000-seater stadium
Arena is expected to cost at least £2bn and be the ‘centrepiece’ of a major regeneration projectFinancial Times - Mar. 11 -
Manchester United Pitches New Stadium as Key to Government Growth Plan
Jim Ratcliffe, the billionaire co-owner of the soccer club, framed plans for the 100,000-seat venue as crucial to the British government’s plan to revive the northern English city.The New York Times - Mar. 11 -
Man Utd CEO: New stadium poses 'risk' to team
Manchester United CEO Omar Berrada has admitted the club "risk" falling further behind their rivals while they invest in their new stadium.ESPN - Mar. 12 -
‘Eiffel Tower of the north’? Manchester United unveil 100,000-seat new stadium project
Officials say plan will create 92,000 jobs and 17,000 homes Architect Norman Foster puts ‘vast umbrella’ over ground A new 100,000-seat stadium that will be the largest in the UK. A venue ...The Guardian - Mar. 11 -
Man Utd plan to build 'iconic' £2bn 100,000-capacity stadium
Manchester United announce plans to build the biggest stadium in the UK - an "iconic" new £2bn 100,000-seater ground close to Old Trafford.BBC News - Mar. 11 -
Leicester v Manchester United: Match Preview, Team News and How to Watch
Leicester v Manchester United: Match Preview, Team News and How to WatchUnited Face Tough Test at King PowerManchester United return to Premier League action on Sunday night as they travel to the ...Yahoo Sports - Mar. 15 -
Manchester United transfer news: Forward targets lined up for summer — Report
It appears Manchester United have a very clear idea on where they want to strengthen this summer.Yahoo Sports - 4d -
Rasmus Højlund ends goal drought as Manchester United cruise past Leicester
Jamie Vardy rolled the ball into the Manchester United net to huge cheers and about 10 minutes later, amid swirling rain, Ruud van Nistelrooy’s name echoed around this stadium. The only problem for ...The Guardian - 6d -
Ayden Heaven injury update — Teenager, Amorim speak after Manchester United defender stretchered off
Manchester United teenage defender Ayden Heaven was stretchered off the King Power Stadium pitch following an ugly injury in a match at Leicester City on Sunday.Yahoo Sports - 4d -
Report: Manchester United Must Pay £60m to Secure Key Striker Target
Manchester United Weigh Move for Jean-Philippe Mateta Amid Striker SearchManchester United’s search for a new striker continues to evolve, with Crystal Palace’s Jean-Philippe Mateta now emerging a...Yahoo Sports - Mar. 14 -
Sir Jim Ratcliffe at Manchester United: Progress or More of the Same?
Manchester United’s Ownership Struggles: Sir Jim Ratcliffe, the Glazers, and the Long Road AheadSir Jim Ratcliffe’s Influence and the Growing ExpectationsManchester United’s new era under Sir Ji...Yahoo Sports - 6d -
Ruben Amorim reaction — Manchester United boss speaks after Bruno Fernandes inspires 3-0 win at Leicester
Ruben Amorim will be thrilled as his Manchester United side showed no weariness or letdown after an exciting midweek in Europe, toppling Leicester City 3-0 at the King Power Stadium on Sunday.Yahoo Sports - 6d -
Manchester United ready to pounce for Real Madrid’s Ferland Mendy in the summer
Manchester United suffered a major transfer blow on Friday as news broke of Chelsea hijacking their summer deal for Sporting CP’s Geovany Quenda.The Blues offered a more lucrative deal for both the ...Yahoo Sports - Mar. 14 -
Andy Burnham pushes for £200mn in government funding for Old Trafford regeneration
Mayor makes case for state support for development plans around Manchester United’s new stadiumFinancial Times - Mar. 13 -
Red Devils Reloaded: What’s next for the squad of Manchester United?
Man U’s youth revolution: Will new blood and budget cuts bring back the glory days?Man U’s identity crisisIt’s been more than a decade since Sir Alex Ferguson stepped down from Manchester United...Yahoo Sports - 6d -
United pilot attacked passenger for taking too long in the bathroom, lawsuit alleges
Yisroel Liebb of New Jersey claims pilot broke lock and pulled him out with his pants down, leaving him exposed. An Orthodox Jewish passenger says a United Airlines pilot forcibly removed him from ...The Guardian - 17h -
Transfer rumors, news: Man United eye move for Éderson
Atalanta midfielder Éderson is at the top of Manchester United's transfer shortlist. Transfer Talk has the latest news, gossip and rumors.ESPN - Mar. 13 -
Transfer rumors, news: Man United scouting Sesko, Ekitike
Will Benjamin Sesko or Hugo Ekitike be able to solve Manchester United's goal-scoring issues? Transfer Talk has the latest news, gossip and rumors.ESPN - 5d -
Transfer rumors, news: Man United prepare €48m offer for Nmecha
Manchester United have identified Borussia Dortmund midfielder Felix Nmecha as a key target. Transfer Talk has the latest news, gossip and rumors.ESPN - 3d -
Manchester City vs Brighton – Match preview and team news
Manchester City welcome a high-flying Brighton to the Etihad Stadium this weekend.The Premier League champions have the opportunity to break into the top four with a win this afternoon. Pep ...Yahoo Sports - Mar. 15 -
Culture and contracts top of Moore's list
Wales' new head of women's rugby Belinda Moore says creating the right culture is among her top priorities.Yahoo Sports - 4d -
Man United set to launch €30 million offer to sign Jan Oblak
Manchester United are reportedly prepared to spend €30 million to sign Atletico Madrid’s Jan Oblak.Despite improving on last season, the Red Devils have still conceded far too many goals and this ...Yahoo Sports - Mar. 15 -
Man United Women boss Marc Skinner closing in on new deal at club
Manchester United Women’s manager Marc Skinner is edging closer to signing a new deal at the club.The former Birmingham head coach is now the longest-serving manager in the Women’s Super League as...Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Transfer rumors, news: No way back for Rashford at Man United
Marcus Rashford has no future at Manchester United once his loan at Aston Villa expires at the end of the season. Transfer Talk has the latest news, gossip and rumors.ESPN - 14h -
Ex-Falcons WR Rondale Moore finds new home in NFC North
Former Falcons WR Rondale Moore finds new home in NFL free agency with Minnesota VikingsYahoo Sports - 3d -
West Ham United vs Tottenham Hotspur LIVE: Women's Super League team news, line-ups and more
Follow all the action from Chigwell Construction StadiumYahoo Sports - 5h
More from The Guardian
-
Ukraine war live: Zelenskyy urges allies to put ‘new pressure’ on Russia to end attacks ahead of ceasefire talks
US and Ukrainian officials to meet for ceasefire discussions in Saudi Arabia, ahead of separate US-Russia talks on Monday. My colleagues Pjotr Sauer , Shaun Walker and Andrew Roth have ...The Guardian - 23m -
Gaza medics issue malnutrition alert as total Israeli blockade enters fourth week
Israel continues to batter territory in renewed offensive as Palestinian officials say death toll of war has passed 50,000. Malnutrition is spreading in Gaza, medics and aid workers in the ...The Guardian - 1h -
Istanbul mayor jailed on day of likely presidential nomination
Ekrem İmamoğlu, rival of Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, placed in pre-trial detention along with dozens of staff and officials. An Istanbul court has formally arrested the city’s mayor, Ekrem İmamoğlu, on ...The Guardian - 1h -
Mark Carney to announce Canadian election and will run in Ottawa’s Nepean riding
Recently installed prime minister expected to confirm 28 April ballot as he seeks to keep Liberal party in government. Mark Carney will run for election in the Ottawa riding of Nepean as the new ...The Guardian - 12h -
Pope Francis greets crowds in Rome before discharge from hospital
Pontiff says he has ‘had the opportunity to experience the Lord’s patience’ and pays tribute to ‘tireless care’ of medics. Pope Francis greeted a large crowd of pilgrims gathered outside Gemelli ...The Guardian - 3h
More in World
-
England v Italy: Women’s Six Nations – live
Updates from the champions’ opener in York (3pm KO) Team-by-team guide to the tournament Sign up for the Breakdown newsletter | Email Simon 2 mins: Italy have the ball for a while, but ...The Guardian - 20m -
Manchester City v Chelsea: Women’s Super League – live
The two clubs clash again in the third of four meetings Any thoughts? You can email Daniel with them Millie Bright says Chelsea didn’t turn up in that and they were really disappointed by ...The Guardian - 20m -
Ukraine war live: Zelenskyy urges allies to put ‘new pressure’ on Russia to end attacks ahead of ceasefire talks
US and Ukrainian officials to meet for ceasefire discussions in Saudi Arabia, ahead of separate US-Russia talks on Monday. My colleagues Pjotr Sauer , Shaun Walker and Andrew Roth have ...The Guardian - 23m -
Gerard Depardieu sexual assault trial marks a cultural reckoning for post-#MeToo France
When French actor Gérard Depardieu walks into a Paris courtroom on Monday, he won’t just be facing two women who accuse him of sexual assault — he’ll also be confronting a nation long criticized ...ABC News - 28m -
Gerard Depardieu sexual assault trial marks a cultural reckoning for post-#MeToo France
When French actor Gérard Depardieu walks into a Paris courtroom on Monday, he won’t just be facing two women who accuse him of sexual assault — he’ll also be confronting a nation long criticized ...ABC News - 28m