The Lions’ proposed NFL playoff change would make divisions kind of pointless
One of the best things the NFL has always had going for it was how important its regular season feels. The nature of a condensed schedule means every weekly game carries extra meaning. On a deeper level, the subplot of a division title race, even between mediocre teams in one distinct region of the country, adds intrigue to a season that would've otherwise ceaselessly dragged on. It's a small but significant wrinkle that has helped the NFL separate itself from other major American sports leagues over the years.
And the Detroit Lions are ready to do away with it entirely.
On Wednesday, NFL Network's Tom Pelissero reported that the Lions have proposed shifting how the NFL's annual playoff picture is structured. They want the league to seed wild card teams higher than division winners if they have better records. This would, theoretically, give high-level wild card teams a home playoff game instead of forcing them to go on the road in the first round of the postseason. Any potential shift will be voted on at the NFL's owners meetings from March 30 to April 2.
On its face, the change feels logical. It is a tad silly watching 14-win squads like last year's Minnesota Vikings have to open the crucible of January on the road. But this possibility still misses the forest for the trees in a fashion the NFL can't lose sight of in the long term:
This is interesting: The #Lions proposed a bylaw change that would allow wild card teams to be seeded higher than division winners based on record.
— Tom Pelissero (@TomPelissero) March 19, 2025
This would’ve been helpful to the rival #Vikings last year, and could be a factor in future years in competitive divisions…. pic.twitter.com/cKs1JBGJU9
We're in a place here where the NFL needs to strike a delicate balance.
So, do you wanna know a good solution for elite wild card teams to host postseason games in the future? They could, you know, win their divisions. They could, you know, finish with the best record amongst the four teams they are grouped together within their conference. I'm well aware this is a novel concept, but it's something everyone should remember: you are actually extremely allowed to win more football games than the three other teams you face the most over the course of the entire year. No one is proposing a ban on that possibility.
I'm not saying I'm entirely against the Lions' proposal. A great wild-card NFL team probably should have a higher seed in most circumstances. It's only fair. But rivalry, no matter how manufactured, gives a sport life. If the NFL is to follow through on what the Lions want here, I'd like there to be a measure of nuance. Maybe division winners in subpar divisions only get to host a home playoff game if they're under .500. Maybe only the No. 4 seed division winner is in real danger of losing its homefield advantage to a top wild-card squad while everyone in the top three is safe. Small subtleties like that come most to mind.
Because if the NFL starts tinkering with a playoff format that makes the regular season less meaningless, it's playing with fire. As vital as the playoffs are, its regular-season product is its best, most consistent, and most compelling. Even in a lost season for lots of teams and their respective fanbases, there is tremendous value in watching a heated win over your division rival that potentially turns the tide of the division title race. Ask a Chicago Bears fan how they feel about playing spoiler to a good Green Bay Packers season. Talk to a New Orleans Saints fan and get their thoughts on beating the hated Atlanta Falcons out of the playoff picture in December when their team is irrelevant.
They'll say the same thing (though not in my words): there is value in winning a micro-battle with three other teams that doesn't have to amount to anything else after the fact.
Not everything has to be about the big picture. Not everything has to build toward The Big Game in February. That's not what this beautifully flawed sport should be all about. Sometimes, giving morose football fans a carrot in November and December, even when there's nothing for them to look forward to afterward, means the world. In this case, that "carrot" is mainly a home playoff game that props up the essentialness of divisions for everyone around.
Want elite wild-card teams to stop getting the short end of the stick? Tell them to win their divisions. Don't lower the spice level of an NFL regular season that doesn't need more unnecessary tinkering.
This article originally appeared on For The Win: Lions propose top NFL wild cards get higher seeds in dramatic shift
-
Lions propose significant playoff seeding change
The Lions have proposed a significant change to NFL playoff seeding that would largely use regular-season records as the guiding principle.ESPN - 44m -
NFL rule changes 2025: Eagles, Lions, Packers make proposals including 'Tush Push' ban
The Packers are seeking to stop the Eagles' 'Tush Push' once and for all while the Lions are looking to change the NFL's playoff format.Yahoo Sports - 5h -
NFL owners to consider Detroit Lions proposal to change seeding in playoffs
Under the Lions' proposal, wild-card teams could have first-round home playoff games instead of division champs.Yahoo Sports - 5h -
Banning the tush push and changes to playoff seeding are among proposed NFL rule changes
The Green Bay Packers have formally proposed a rule change to ban the tush push and the Detroit Lions proposed that playoff seeding be done based on record instead of automatically placing division ...Yahoo Sports - 5h -
Lions propose playoff seeding without regard to division championship
The current structure of the NFL often results in teams with lesser records hosting playoff games, because every division champion is guaranteed one of the top four spots on the conference's ...Yahoo Sports - 6h -
NFL to consider tush push ban, changes to playoff seeding
NFL team owners will consider proposals to ban the tush push and for a change to playoff seeding format this off-season, the league announced Wednesday.Yahoo Sports - 4h -
NFL rules proposal changes carry some interesting suggestions
There are interesting suggestions and proposals by teams for rules changes in the upcoming NFL seasonYahoo Sports - 5h -
NFL rule changes 2025: Packers move to outlaw 'Tush Push,' while Lions suggest major playoff seeding change
The competition committee will review several potential changes this offseasonCBS Sports - 5h -
Mitchell Agude overcame a severe childhood injury to make it to year two with the Lions
The Lions re-signed LB Mitchell Agude, who overcame a severe childhood injury to make it in the NFLYahoo Sports - 8h
More from Yahoo Sports
-
Doc Rivers reportedly meets with Lillard, Antetokounmpo to discuss what is holding Bucks back
Milwaukee has gone 2-5 in its last seven and is 0-11 against the teams with the four best records in the NBA.Yahoo Sports - 10m -
Updated depth chart following the Texans' signing of OT Cam Robinson
The Houston Texans have 73 players on the roster after inking a new deal with veteran offensive tackle Cam RobinsonYahoo Sports - 14m -
Commanders rework Deebo Samuel's contract to guarantee $17 million in 2025 salary, AP source says
Deebo Samuel and the Washington Commanders have reworked the wide receiver's contract to guarantee $17 million this season with $3 million in additional incentives, according to a person with ...Yahoo Sports - 14m -
Navy basketball coach Ed DeChellis is retiring after 29 years as a collegiate head coach
DeChellis coached a school-record 426 games at Navy. The Midshipmen reached the championship game of the Patriot League Tournament this year before losing to American.Yahoo Sports - 15m -
Updated lottery standings as Sixers prepare to face Thunder on the road
Here is an updated look at the lottery standings as the Philadelphia 76ers prepare to face the Oklahoma City Thunder on the road.Yahoo Sports - 16m
More in Sports
-
Doc Rivers reportedly meets with Lillard, Antetokounmpo to discuss what is holding Bucks back
Milwaukee has gone 2-5 in its last seven and is 0-11 against the teams with the four best records in the NBA.Yahoo Sports - 10m -
Updated depth chart following the Texans' signing of OT Cam Robinson
The Houston Texans have 73 players on the roster after inking a new deal with veteran offensive tackle Cam RobinsonYahoo Sports - 14m -
Commanders rework Deebo Samuel's contract to guarantee $17 million in 2025 salary, AP source says
Deebo Samuel and the Washington Commanders have reworked the wide receiver's contract to guarantee $17 million this season with $3 million in additional incentives, according to a person with ...Yahoo Sports - 14m -
Navy basketball coach Ed DeChellis is retiring after 29 years as a collegiate head coach
DeChellis coached a school-record 426 games at Navy. The Midshipmen reached the championship game of the Patriot League Tournament this year before losing to American.Yahoo Sports - 15m -
Updated lottery standings as Sixers prepare to face Thunder on the road
Here is an updated look at the lottery standings as the Philadelphia 76ers prepare to face the Oklahoma City Thunder on the road.Yahoo Sports - 16m