NFL owners to consider Detroit Lions proposal to change seeding in playoffs
The Detroit Lions and Minnesota Vikings shared the best record in the NFC when they met in a winner-take-all game in Week 18 of the regular season last year. The winner got the No. 1 seed, a first-round bye and homefield advantage, the loser got a wild-card spot and road trips likely for the duration of the playoffs.
The Lions won the game and, like the Vikings, flamed out in their playoff opener, but now they want to change to playoff seeding format to reward teams for their regular season record.
The Lions submitted three rule- or bylaw-proposal changes for the NFL's annual meeting in Palm Beach, Fla., later this month, including one that would "amend the current playoff seeding format to allow Wild Card teams to be seeded higher than Division Champions if the Wild Card team has a better regular season record."
Had the proposal been in effect last season, the Lions would have been the No. 1 seed in the NFC, followed by the Philadelphia Eagles at No. 2, the Vikings at No. 3 and the Washington Commanders at No. 4, while the NFC West champion Los Angeles Rams and NFC South champion Tampa Bay Buccaneers would have gone on the road in the wild-card round.
The Vikings lost to the Rams in L.A., the Commanders beat the Bucs in Tampa, the Eagles won a wild-card home game against the Green Bay Packers, and the Lions lost in the divisional round to the Commanders.
If the Lions' proposal is adopted, playoff seeding in future years would be determined by record only, with division champs having the tie-breaker advantage over wild-card teams with the same record. In the second round, the top seed would continue to play the lowest remaining seed, like the format is now.
In literature about club-proposed changes released Wednesday, the reason for the proposal was "competitive equity" to provide "excitement and competition in late season games" and to reward "the best-performing teams from the regular season."
The Lions, who have regularly submitted bylaw and rules proposals since Brad Holmes took over as general manager and Dan Campbell as head coach in 2021, also submitted proposals to exclude players placed on injured reserve from the 90-man roster limit, unless they are designated for return, and to eliminate an automatic first down as a penalty for defensive holding and illegal contact.
Last year, the Lions submitted four rule or bylaw proposals, including ones to push back the trade deadline and tweak the challenge rules.
The NFL adopted the Lions' proposal to allow teams to get a third challenge if they won one of their first two challenges. Previously, teams were only allowed a third challenge if both of their first two challenges were successful.
Owners also modified the emergency quarterback rule following a Lions proposal in 2023.
Along with the Lions' three proposals this year, NFL owners will consider playing rules proposals by the Green Bay Packers to ban the tush push short-yardage play popularized by the Eagles in recent years, and by the Eagles to align the postseason and regular season overtime rules by granting both teams at least one possession in overtime.
The Pittsburgh Steelers also submitted a proposal to allow teams to have one video or phone call with a prospective unrestricted free agent during the free agent negotiating period.
The NFL's competition committee will submit additional proposals next week. The annual meeting is March 30-April 1.
Campbell, who previously said he was in favor of keeping the tush push a legal play, has said he is not interested in being on the competition committee.
Dave Birkett will sign copies of his book, "Detroit Lions: An Illustrated Timeline," at 7 p.m., March 24, at the Birmingham Public Library. Order your copy here. Contact him at dbirkett@freepress.com. Follow him on Bluesky, X and Instagram at @davebirkett.
This article originally appeared on Detroit Free Press: Detroit Lions submit proposal to dramatically alter playoff seeding
-
Lions propose significant playoff seeding change
The Lions have proposed a significant change to NFL playoff seeding that would largely use regular-season records as the guiding principle.ESPN - 1h -
Banning the tush push and changes to playoff seeding are among proposed NFL rule changes
The Green Bay Packers have formally proposed a rule change to ban the tush push and the Detroit Lions proposed that playoff seeding be done based on record instead of automatically placing division ...Yahoo Sports - 5h -
The Lions’ proposed NFL playoff change would make divisions kind of pointless
This NFL playoff change proposed by the Lions makes logical sense, but would only serve to ultimately make the regular season meaningless.Yahoo Sports - 4h -
Lions propose playoff seeding without regard to division championship
The current structure of the NFL often results in teams with lesser records hosting playoff games, because every division champion is guaranteed one of the top four spots on the conference's ...Yahoo Sports - 5h -
NFL to consider tush push ban, changes to playoff seeding
NFL team owners will consider proposals to ban the tush push and for a change to playoff seeding format this off-season, the league announced Wednesday.Yahoo Sports - 4h -
NFL rule changes 2025: Eagles, Lions, Packers make proposals including 'Tush Push' ban
The Packers are seeking to stop the Eagles' 'Tush Push' once and for all while the Lions are looking to change the NFL's playoff format.Yahoo Sports - 5h -
NFL rule changes 2025: Packers move to outlaw 'Tush Push,' while Lions suggest major playoff seeding change
The competition committee will review several potential changes this offseasonCBS Sports - 4h -
8 proposed NFL changes by teams for 2025
A rundown of all the team-proposed changes for playing rules, bylaws and practices for 2025. Some are pretty interesting.Yahoo Sports - 4h -
Soccer: Greenville Lions, two Caddo Mills teams advance to playoffs
Greenville dropped its regular season finale 4-0 at home on Friday night to McKinney North but is still headed to the soccer playoffs. Adan Rajendran scored two goals to lead the Bulldogs to ...Yahoo Sports - 20h
More from Yahoo Sports
-
West Virginia's Baker is 'resilient' after NCAA Tournament snub and losing DeVries to Indiana
First, West Virginia was a surprising omission from the NCAA Tournament. Then, the Mountaineers lost their coach. It's been a lousy week for a school now facing its third men's basketball ...Yahoo Sports - 27m -
Report: Man Utd Among Six Clubs Tracking Championship Star
Jobe Bellingham’s Premier League Future: Manchester United and Rivals CircleManchester United are one of several Premier League clubs considering a move for Sunderland midfielder Jobe Bellingham, ...Yahoo Sports - 28m -
The Mood In The Rangers Locker Room is ‘Intense’ With Eyes On The Playoffs
The New York Rangers’ 2-1 loss to the Calgary Flames on Tuesday night was inexcusable and there’s no doubt about that.Yahoo Sports - 29m -
Will Wade to become next North Carolina State men's basketball coach | Reports
Will Wade is set to become the next North Carolina State men's basketball coach after McNeese State's March Madness run is over, according to reports.Yahoo Sports - 29m -
Barca on track for women's Champions League semis after thumping Wolfsburg
Defending champions Barcelona are on track for the final four of the women's Champions League after a dominant 4-1 win in their quarter-final first leg at Wolfsburg on Wednesday. Later, Manchester ...Yahoo Sports - 31m
More in Sports
-
LSU football recruiting: Five-star prospect Tristen Keys commits as Tigers land No. 1 WR in 2026 class
Keys rates as the No. 1 wide receiver in the Class of 2026CBS Sports - 21m -
USMNT's Concacaf Nations League squad: Meet Mauricio Pochettino's team from Christian Pulisic to Diego Luna
These are the 23 players set to try and defend the title this weekCBS Sports - 25m -
Could Steelers trade George Pickens? Top landing spots for big-play WR if Pittsburgh decides to move on
Plenty of teams would probably be interested in acquiring PickensCBS Sports - 26m -
2025 Valspar Championship predictions, betting picks: Will Zalatoris among longshots to target at Copperhead
SportsLine's model simulated the 2025 Valspar Championship 10,000 times and revealed its PGA Tour longshotsCBS Sports - 26m -
West Virginia's Baker is 'resilient' after NCAA Tournament snub and losing DeVries to Indiana
First, West Virginia was a surprising omission from the NCAA Tournament. Then, the Mountaineers lost their coach. It's been a lousy week for a school now facing its third men's basketball ...Yahoo Sports - 27m