Grading the Arizona Cardinals' most recent free agent moves
The Arizona Cardinals have made several moves in free agency this week. We graded those first moves from early in the week. Since adding linebackers Josh Sweat and Akeem Davis-Gaither and re-signing linebacker Baron Browning, guard Evan Brown and tackle Kelvin Beachum, they have done more.
They added quarterback Jacoby Brissett, linebacker Mykal Walker and defensive tackle Dalvin Tomlinson. They are bringing back receiver Zay Jones and defensive tackle L.J. Collier. They tendered receiver Greg Dortch.
What grades do they deserve for those moves?
Arizona Cardinals free agency grades, Part 2
QB Jacoby Brissett: B
Brissett gives the Cardinals a proven backup quarterback who can win games in a starters role. Granted, he is only 19-34 in 53 career starts, he has the NFL's lowest interception percentage in league history among qualified quarterbacks. He is experienced. He is reliable. He is a much better option than Clayton Tune, although much more expensive at $12.5 million over two seasons. This is the most the Cardinals have ever paid for a backup quarterback.
DT Dalvin Tomlinson: A+
The Cardinals swung and missed in their attempt to land Milton Williams, who got $26 million per year to join the Patriots. Instead, they get a more proven player in Tomlinson, cut by the Cleveland Browns only for cap reasons, for $29 million over two years. This is a home run of a deal. He is disruptive, consistent and a proven commodity both against the run and the pass.
LB Mykal Walker: B
Walker is fine. He is a special teams player with starting experience. The Cardinals need experienced depth and special teams play. And at under $2 million, it's fine. Nonetheless, it isn't a signing to get excited about. He is just a guy they need at a position that people won't notice.
WR Zay Jones: C
Jones only had eight catches last season and got a contract worth double than the one he had last season, making a reported $4.5 million this coming season. That said, he is a better player than he performed. His five-game suspension to start the season really derailed his season. Should they go get another receiver? Probably, but a trio of Jone with Michael Wilson and Marvin Harrison Jr. is at least a group you can play a game with.
WR Greg Dortch (tender offer): C
Dortch can still test the market but can return at his highest salary ever at $3.3 million. However, that is not guaranteed. As a receiver, he isn't reliable. He is a playmaker with the ball in his hands, so they have to manufacture touches. At minimum, the Cardinals secure their punt returner at a reasonable price.
DL L.J. Collier: B
Collier, playing in every game for the first time since 2020, was solid. He started 15 games and had a career-high 3.5 sacks. He is a solid NFL starter, but having him as a rotational player makes things even better. While he might not produce more than he did last season in a different role, if he has the same numbers while being the fourth or fifth-best D-lineman on the team, that means the team is significantly better.
Get more Cardinals and NFL coverage from Cards Wire's Jess Root and others by listening to the latest on the Rise Up, See Red podcast. Subscribe on Spotify, YouTube or Apple podcasts.
This article originally appeared on Cards Wire: NFL free agency grades: Looking at Arizona Cardinals' recent moves
-
Cardinals hosted free agent visit with Asante Samuel Jr.
Free agent cornerback Asante Samuel Jr. took a trip to Arizona on Thursday.Yahoo Sports - 3h -
Free Agency Grades: Darnold to Seattle, Fields to the Jets, Adams to LA! | Football 301
Nate Tice and Matt Harmon break down free agency's biggest moves and give grades for each signing.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
2025 NFL free agency Day 4 grades: Chiefs get 'A' for adding Patrick Mahomes' new backup, plus other moves
Which of the latest moves are moving the needle?CBS Sports - 5h -
9 quality bank stocks most likely to rise as much as 45% after recent market declines
Recent action shows investors can never really predict how interest rates will move.MarketWatch - 1d -
Arizona Cardinals meet with former Chargers CB Asante Samuel
The Cardinals appear to be in the market for a cornerback as they had 2021 second-round pick Asante Samuel Jr. in for a meeting.Yahoo Sports - 13h -
Arizona Cardinals announce signing of LB Akeem Davis-Gaither
The Cardinals officially signed linebacker Akeem Davis-Gaither to a two-year deal after five seasons with the Bengals.Yahoo Sports - 13h -
Cardinals add OL depth with former Bear, Seahawks
In a minor move, the Cardinals are signing former Seahawks and Bears OL Jake Curhan.Yahoo Sports - 9h -
Jaguars sign free agents to 'raise the floor.' They'll use the draft to raise ceiling of the team
Jacksonville’s approach to free agency was much different than what the floundering franchise tried to accomplish in recent years. The Jaguars signed nine free agents, including four plug-and-play ...Yahoo Sports - 14h -
Free agency reaction show: Which moves matter the most? | Yahoo Fantasy Forecast
The NFL's legal tampering window did not disappoint. While the new league year officially begins tomorrow most of the free agency dominoes have already fallen. Yahoo's senior NFL reporter Jori ...Yahoo Sports - 2d -
NFL free agency 2025: 10 teams that addressed massive roster needs with early moves
NFL free agency can provide a quick fix for teams facing a pressing need, and the Bears and Cardinals were among those who paid up to solve a problem.Yahoo Sports - 2h -
The best signings and most puzzling decisions of the NFL free agency period so far
The NFL's free-agent signing period is officially underway. Which teams have made the best and worst decisions so far?NBC News - 1d -
2025 NFL free agency Day 3 grades: Vikings earn 'A' for Javon Hargrave deal, Steelers get 'B-' for Darius Slay
Which teams improved the most on WednesdayCBS Sports - 20h -
Bengals lose another free agent as lack of moves continues
Another Bengals player has signed elsewhere while the team continues to not do much.Yahoo Sports - 11h -
Free agent S Camryn Bynum to sign a 4-year, $60 million deal with the Colts
The Colts haven't been a team known to spend big on free agency in recent years, so this is a bit out of character for them.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
2025 Fantasy Football: Early projections for Justin Fields, Najee Harris and other Monday free agent movers
Early projections for free agent moversCBS Sports - 2d -
NFL free agency: When it starts, top free agents and teams with most cap space
There's a flurry of NFL activity in next week's forecast.Yahoo Sports - 6d -
How 49ers hope reported free-agent addition Farrell fits offense
Luke Farrell will be tasked with filling a role the San Francisco 49ers had hoped recent draft picks would.Yahoo Sports - 3d -
2025 Fantasy Football: Projections for Geno Smith, Davante Adams, DK Metcalf, free agents, and more
Early Fantasy Football projections for players on the moveCBS Sports - 3d -
NFL free-agent rankings: Top 5 running backs won't be as strong as last year's class
Last season was a boon for free agent running backs.Yahoo Sports - Mar. 7 -
Bears add free agent WR Olamide Zaccheaus
Free agent wide receiver Olamide Zaccheaus is signing with the Bears, Tom Pelissero of NFL Media reports.Yahoo Sports - 13h -
2025 NFL free agency tracker: Updates on top 100 free agents, Cooper Kupp, Amari Cooper among best available
A running tracker of all the big free agent deals and player movementCBS Sports - 21h -
NFL free-agent rankings: Top 5 interior DL includes some intriguing talents
Some defensive tackles are among the best free agents in this class.Yahoo Sports - Mar. 7 -
2025 NFL free agent defensive lineman rankings: Best team fits, projected deals for Milton Williams, others
A look at the top defensive linemen hitting the free agent marketCBS Sports - 5d -
Super Bowl stars Josh Sweat and Milton Williams headline a list of NFL free agents
NFL teams can start reshaping their rosters by signing free agents this weekABC News - 4d -
Rodgers a free agent for 1st time as Jets cut QB
The Jets officially released Aaron Rodgers on Wednesday, making him a free agent for the first time in his career.ESPN - 1d -
New York Giants host QB Joe Flacco on free agent visit
The New York Giants hosted veteran quarterback Joe Flacco in East Rutherford on Thursday for a free agent visit.Yahoo Sports - 13h -
Colts free agent signee QB Daniel Jones on competing with Anthony Richardson
While meeting with the media, Colts' free agent signee at QB Daniel Jones spoke about competing with Anthony Richardson.Yahoo Sports - 13h -
Jersey numbers revealed for Patriots first wave of free agent signings
The jersey numbers were revealed for the New England Patriots' first wave of free agent signings.Yahoo Sports - 12h -
Report: Jaguars 'not in' on Rams free agent WR Cooper Kupp
According to a report from one NFL insider, the Jaguars are "not in" on Rams' free agent WR Cooper Kupp.Yahoo Sports - 11h -
Top 2026 NFL free agents: Best players available in free agency next year
NFL teams spent hundreds of millions of dollars on free agents this offseason. Here are the top names in next year's class.Yahoo Sports - 14h -
2025 NFL free agent edge rusher rankings: Best team fits, projected deals for Josh Sweat, Khalil Mack, more
A look at the pass rushers projected to hit the free agent marketCBS Sports - 5d -
2025 NFL free agent TE rankings: Best team fits, projected deals for Evan Engram, Zach Ertz, other top vets
A look at the best tight ends projected to hit the free agent marketCBS Sports - 5d -
Top free-agent cornerback said he picked Lions over Commanders
One of the NFL's top free-agent cornerbacks said he chose the Lions over Commanders. But we thought Adam Peters wasn't being aggressive?Yahoo Sports - 2h -
Ravens, Ronnie Stanley agree to extension: LT gets new 3-year deal worth $60M, avoids free agency, per report
Stanley was slated to be an unrestricted free agentCBS Sports - 5d -
2025 NFL free agency live tracker: Full list of team-by-team signings and trades, plus updates on every move
All the free agency deals and other moves around the leagueCBS Sports - 12h -
NFL free agency grades: Guess who is getting an A?
Between a few big trades and a flurry of overall activity, aggressive teams improved. But some teams took hits with players leaving.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Nate Hobbs's new four-year contract is really a one-year deal, with three one-year options
The free-agency period entails a storm of reports regarding new contracts, with all of them painted in the light most favorable to the sources for those reports — the players' agents.Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Ex-Eagles star Sweat to Cards on $76.4M deal
After losing out on former Eagles lineman Milton Williams, the Cardinals made their first splash of free agency by agreeing to a four-year contract with another former Eagle, pass rusher Josh ...ESPN - 3d -
After flurry of agreements, Cam Robinson is the highest-ranked free agent available
Free agency officially begins Wednesday at 4 p.m.Yahoo Sports - 2d
More from Yahoo Sports
-
Report: New Orleans Saints have 'got their eye' on former All-Pro free agent WR
Dianna Russini reports that the Saints have 'got their eye' on Cooper Kupp's free agency market. What kind of contract is the former All-Pro seeking?Yahoo Sports - 8m -
Q&A: How LSU's Flau'jae Johnson defies expectations with 2 (!) successful careers simultaneously
Flau'jae Johnson has careers in basketball and music. For The Win recently sat down with the LSU star to talk about how she defies expectations.Yahoo Sports - 12m -
Prince William Reveals Key Role His Kids Play in His Soccer Superstitions — and How He Secretly Goes on Fan Forums
"I do have a bit of superstition about where I sit when I’m watching," the royal said about his soccer rituals on Friday, March 14Yahoo Sports - 12m -
10 years ago, Rafael dos Anjos blew up the brief 'Showtime Era' at UFC 185
In 2015, Anthony Pettis was riding high and had been for years. Pettis came to the UFC as the final WEC champion on the heels of his famed "Showtime Kick" against Benson Henderson. He was outworked ...Yahoo Sports - 12m -
Inter to Lock Up Manchester United and Napoli Target
Inter are in advanced talks to renew the contract of Francesco Pio Esposito, who is being tracked by Manchester United and Leicester City because of his strong performances with Spezia in Serie ...Yahoo Sports - 13m
More in Sports
-
Report: New Orleans Saints have 'got their eye' on former All-Pro free agent WR
Dianna Russini reports that the Saints have 'got their eye' on Cooper Kupp's free agency market. What kind of contract is the former All-Pro seeking?Yahoo Sports - 8m -
Power Rankings: Capitals back at No. 1, plus each team's playoff scoring leaders
With March Madness coming soon, who is each NHL team's postseason tournament hero?ESPN - 9m -
Inside the Sabres' never-ending rebuild -- and how they get back to the playoffs
From Ryan O'Reilly to Jack Eichel to Sam Reinhart and more, success follows for a player once he leaves, with Buffalo set to miss the playoffs again.ESPN - 9m -
Ronald Acuna Jr. says he'll be more careful this season -- but no one believes him
From 40/70 to 40/30? The Braves' 2023 NL MVP is rehabbing with a plan to be stronger -- and healthier.ESPN - 9m -
Q&A: How LSU's Flau'jae Johnson defies expectations with 2 (!) successful careers simultaneously
Flau'jae Johnson has careers in basketball and music. For The Win recently sat down with the LSU star to talk about how she defies expectations.Yahoo Sports - 12m