Eddie Howe is the best English manager since Sir Bobby Robson
This was a cup win that not only confirmed Eddie Howe is the greatest Newcastle United manager of the modern era, it suggests he is the best English one too.
In winning Newcastle’s first domestic trophy for seven decades; the trophy incidentally, he told the club’s board would be the first one he would target to win when he interviewed for the job in November 2021, Howe now stands head and shoulders above all those who came before him in the 70 years since the last of their FA Cup successes
Kevin Keegan did a wonderful job galvanising the club, breathing life into the corpse of a proud institution, but he could not win a trophy. As good as he was and as important a figure as he is in the club’s history, Howe has done better.
Sir Bobby Robson was the best English manager of his generation, also flirted with a Premier League title challenge and qualified Newcastle for the Champions League, but he could not end the long, painful wait for silverware either.
In the space of less than four years, Howe saved the club from relegation in his first season, qualified for the Champions League in his second, finished in the top seven in his third and won a major trophy in his fourth.
The full-time scenes as Newcastle win the Carabao Cup! 🥳🏆 pic.twitter.com/Un9izHsdr7
— Sky Sports Football (@SkyFootball) March 16, 2025
He has pulled off something truly stunning. It is an achievement that will echo through history. So many others have tried and failed to do what Howe has done and it means he has won as many trophies at Newcastle as Mikel Arteta has in more than five years at Arsenal.
Not since Harry Redknapp won the FA Cup with Portsmouth back in 2008 has an English manager lifted a trophy above his head at Wembley.
Given the work he did at Bournemouth, you can make a strong argument that not since Bobby Robson has this country produced anyone as good. In a Premier League flooded with more fashionable foreign coaches, Howe has become the poster boy for the home-grown. His rise from League Two to the Premier League was already a remarkable story, but this trophy proves he is not just good, he is great.
Howe is destined to manage England at some point. It would be a travesty if he did not. It might not be now, or even if Thomas Tuchel departs after the World Cup in 2026, but even if they have to wait a decade, the FA must give him the job when he is ready to take it.
It was too soon for him last summer. Howe told the FA, before it even asked if he was interested in replacing Gareth Southgate, that he wanted to stay in club football, but his time will come.
As for his status on Tyneside, the question now should be, when and where do you want your statue Eddie? They will build one for him after this. Maybe not this year or even the next, but they will have to. Just like the players who crushed Liverpool, Howe has achieved immortality.
Howe will hate that sort of talk and brushed off a question about it in an emotional post-match press conference. It possibly even offended him. “I don’t think about things like that, I focus every day on what I can do for Newcastle United, that will never change. I never look too far ahead.”
Howe often seems more uncomfortable with praise than he is at handling criticism. It is just one of the reasons this humble, hard-working, emotionally intelligent, utterly football-obsessed individual has thrived at St James’ when so many others have wilted. He has been the perfect manager at the perfect time for a club that has simply been too emotional; too intense and too difficult to handle for most of those who sat in the dugout before him.
This was no fluke. To reach the final Newcastle had to beat Chelsea and then Arsenal over two legs in the semi-final. They won all three of those games. In the final, they outplayed the best team in the country in Liverpool.
When Newcastle’s former co-owner Amanda Staveley said that Howe could become Newcastle United’s Sir Alex Ferguson, people scoffed at the comparison. It does not look silly anymore.
This was the squad Howe built with the financial backing of the new owners, he led recruitment as well as leading the team. The club would do well to remember that in the summer when they look at ways to refresh and improve it.
Howe is a special manager, but more importantly he was the ideal manager for Newcastle United at the ideal time. He has not only spent money to get them where they are, he has improved pretty much every player he inherited.
Newcastle are very lucky to have him and England are too. There will be other clubs, at home and abroad, who may look at the job Howe has done and wonder whether he could do the same for them too.
For now, none of that matters. All that mattered this weekend was that Newcastle won a trophy, ended the drought and sent their loyal fans home happy after a final for a change. That is precisely – as he promised when he took the job – what Howe has done.
Topics
-
Eddie Howe: Carabao Cup win can be turning point for Newcastle United
Eddie Howe believes winning the Carabao Cup can be a “turning point” in the history of Newcastle United. Dan Burn and Alexander Isak scored either side of the interval to give the Magpies a deser...Yahoo Sports - 6h -
Eddie Howe reacts after leading Newcastle to first domestic cup in 70 years, first major trophy since 1969
Newcastle United have won a trophy at Wembley Stadium for the first time since 1955 after Eddie Howe led the Magpies to a 2-1 win over Liverpool on Sunday in the League Cup Final.Yahoo Sports - 7h -
Eddie Howe: 'Chance to make history' in cup final
Eddie Howe has said Newcastle United have the chance to make history by beating Liverpool in the Carabao Cup final on Sunday.ESPN - 2d -
'Eddie, will you hurry up and win a trophy!'
The last captain to win a cup for Newcastle, Bobby Moncur, says it has been "far too long" since the Magpies claimed silverware and wants someone to "take this role over". Bruno Guimaraes has the ...Yahoo Sports - 1d -
Howe amazed as Newcastle 'legends' end drought
Newcastle manager Eddie Howe challenged his players to win more silverware after making themselves "legends" by ending the club's 56-year trophy drought with a 2-1 Carabao Cup final win against ...ESPN - 3h -
Surprise call-up? Young talent pictured training with Newcastle ahead of Carabao Cup final
Newcastle United manager Eddie Howe has perhaps signalled that he’s ready to give a chance to some of the club’s youngsters ahead of the Carabao Cup final.The Magpies are preparing for a huge game...Yahoo Sports - 2d -
Howe's history men to go down in Newcastle folklore
Newcastle United manager Eddie Howe and his players will assume legendary status on Tyneside after winning the club's first trophy in 56 years, said Chief Football Writer Phil McNultyYahoo Sports - 5h -
Eddie Howe Carabao Cup Column "A chance to go one step further"
On behalf of the players, staff and everyone connected with Newcastle United, I’d like you to welcome you all to Wembley for the Carabao Cup final.The two legs of our semi-final against Arsenal ...Yahoo Sports - 18h -
Eddie Howe could have been in Liverpool dugout if the pieces had fallen differently
Could Eddie Howe ever be Liverpool manager? Perhaps the moment has passed forever, and this job is now Arne Slot’s for the life cycle of this current team and beyond. Maybe Howe is bound to ...Yahoo Sports - 17h
More from Yahoo Sports
-
WATCH: Oregon State WBB Previews NCAA Tournament vs North Carolina MORE
PROMO: Join BeaversEdge.com and get 30 DAYS FREE!Hear from Oregon State head coach Scott Rueck and guards Kennedie Shuler and Tiara Bolden following the NCAA Tournament Selection Show that placed ...Yahoo Sports - 13m -
NCAA Tournament West Region predictions: Contenders to challenge Florida in March Madness
Florida earned the No. 1 seed in the West Region of the NCAA but there are plenty of contenders that could keep the Gators from the Final Four.Yahoo Sports - 18m -
UConn's 2025 NCAA Tournament selection draws Arkansas State matchup, No. 2 seed
The UConn women's basketball team is the No. 2 seed in the 2025 NCAA Tournament's Spokane Region 4.Yahoo Sports - 20m -
Mark Pope comments on potential Arkansas-St John's matchup in men's NCAA Tournament
Mark Pope was asked about a potential Arkansas vs. St. John's second-round NCAA Tournament matchup between John Calipari and Rick Pitino.Yahoo Sports - 21m -
Ball State women's basketball tickets for 2025 NCAA Women's Tournament: Prices, how to buy
Want to buy tickets to Ball State women's basketball's NCAA Tournament opener? Here's how, including prices for Women's March Madness tickets:Yahoo Sports - 22m
More in Sports
-
NCAA Tournament 2025 bracket picks, top upsets, Cinderella teams: Model simulates March Madness 10,000 times
SportsLine's college basketball model has called 24 first-round NCAA Tournament upsets by double-digit seedsCBS Sports - 11m -
WATCH: Oregon State WBB Previews NCAA Tournament vs North Carolina MORE
PROMO: Join BeaversEdge.com and get 30 DAYS FREE!Hear from Oregon State head coach Scott Rueck and guards Kennedie Shuler and Tiara Bolden following the NCAA Tournament Selection Show that placed ...Yahoo Sports - 13m -
Women's NCAA Tournament 2025: Printable March Madness bracket as Selection Sunday reveals 68-team field
Get your brackets filled out before the action begins with the First Four on WednesdayCBS Sports - 14m -
NCAA bracket predictions: Model releases surprising March Madness 2025 tournament picks
SportsLine's model nailed 13 of the teams in the Sweet 16 last season and simulated the 2025 NCAA Tournament bracket 10,000 timesCBS Sports - 17m -
NCAA Tournament West Region predictions: Contenders to challenge Florida in March Madness
Florida earned the No. 1 seed in the West Region of the NCAA but there are plenty of contenders that could keep the Gators from the Final Four.Yahoo Sports - 18m