Commanders' Javon Kinlaw is a 'big overpay' says one analyst
Free agency has been positive for the Washington Commanders in 2025. The players they have brought in look to be solid fits for the team and provide an opportunity for the Commanders to get the remaining pieces they need in the 2025 NFL draft. As always in free agency, some deals are better than others, and two ESPN analysts are very confused about the Commanders' contract for Javon Kinlaw.
Eric Moody, fantasy football writer: The Commanders signing defensive lineman Javon Kinlaw. The three-year, $45 million contract was surprising, considering the depth of the 2025 draft class at defensive line. The $30 million in guaranteed money is also concerning because of Kinlaw's health and statistical production. He has played in just 58 games since being drafted in 2020, with only 9.5 sacks and 74 pressures.
Ben Solak, NFL analyst: The Commanders signing Kinlaw. It is a big overpay, though it's not surprising why it happened. Commanders general manager Adam Peters drafted Kinlaw with the 49ers, and he remains one of the most physically impressive defensive tackles. Dan Quinn's defense is a good fit for his skill set, too -- simple, upfield responsibilities. But $15 million per year is a huge number for a player who hasn't strung together consistent, starting-caliber play.
It's clear that Adam Peters liked what he saw from Kinlaw in San Francisco, or they wouldn't have gone after him at all. The problem is that Kinlaw's history is muddied with injuries, he spent most of 2021 and 2022 sidelined, appearing in 10 total games over those two seasons. However, he played every single game in 2023 and 2024, so those injuries are obviously healed and not causing any immediate problems.
Last season with the New York Jets, Kinlaw had his best season to date. He recorded 40 tackles (27 solo), 4.5 sacks, two forced fumbles, one fumble recovery, and eight stuffs.
At 6-foot-5 and 319 pounds, Kinlaw is a force to be reckoned with on the field. His athleticism shined with the Jets last season and the Commanders hope he can do it again. They desperately needed help along the line, and Kinlaw can provide that.
Did they overpay? Maybe. But it's probably going to be worth it.
This article originally appeared on Commanders Wire: Commanders' Javon Kinlaw signing continues to be criticized
-
New Commanders DL Javon Kinlaw is already a fan favorite
New Washington Commanders DL Javon Kinlaw endears himself to fans in opening press conference.Yahoo Sports - 4d -
Commanders continue to add depth in the trenches
The Washington Commanders re-signed two offensive linemen and one defensive lineman on Thursday.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
NFL analyst: Tennessee Titans signing of Dan Moore is a head scratcher
The Tennessee Titans signed offensive lineman Dan Moore to a big contract during free agency, prompting an analyst to call it a gamble.Yahoo Sports - 4h -
Commanders restructure Andrew Wylie's contract next season
The Washington Commanders restructured Andrew Wylie's contract next season, proving he was a big part of their plans for 2025.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
New Commanders offensive tackle has some upside
The Washington Commanders signed an offensive tackle and he could provide more than just depth.Yahoo Sports - 8h -
Some good news for Commanders quarterback Jayden Daniels
Washington Commanders quarterback Jayden Daniels is having a good offseason already.Yahoo Sports - 5h -
Commanders bring back special teams ace on multi-year deal
The Washington Commanders were one of the NFL's best on special teams in 2024. Nick Bellore was a big reason why. He's back.Yahoo Sports - 5d -
Ertz to run it back with Commanders, source says
Three-time Pro Bowl tight end Zach Ertz is re-signing with the Washington Commanders on a one-year deal worth $6.25 million, a source told ESPN's Adam Schefter.ESPN - Mar. 9 -
Commanders agree to one-year deal with OL Nate Herbig
The Commanders are adding some depth to their offensive line.Yahoo Sports - 4d
More from Yahoo Sports
-
Fantasy Baseball: Top pitcher fades for 2025
Fantasy baseball analyst Dalton Del Don sheds light on some key pitchers who are being drafted too early in 2025.Yahoo Sports - 21m -
Emma Raducanu vs Sayaka Ishii LIVE: Miami Open latest score and updates
Britain’s No 2 is first in action on the Hard Rock Stadium courtYahoo Sports - 24m -
Emma Raducanu vs Sayaka Ishii LIVE: Miami Open latest score and updates
Britain’s No 2 is first in action on the Hard Rock Stadium courtYahoo Sports - 24m -
Hello again! Players return to March Madness, this time playing for new teams
One year after Terrence Edwards and Chucky Hepburn played against each other in the NCAA Tournament, they are experiencing March Madness again as teammates at an entirely different school. This is ...Yahoo Sports - 24m -
Hello again! Players return to March Madness, this time playing for new teams
One year after Terrence Edwards and Chucky Hepburn played against each other in the NCAA Tournament, they are experiencing March Madness again as teammates at an entirely different school. This is ...Yahoo Sports - 24m
More in Sports
-
Why Rory McIlroy's early form legitimizes belief that Masters win, career grand slam will finally come in 2025
McIlroy has two wins entering April for the first time in his career; more complete and confident, is Rory finally ready to win at Augusta National?CBS Sports - 16m -
Why Rory McIlroy's early form legitimizes belief that Masters win, career grand slam will finally come in 2025
McIlroy has two wins entering April for the first time in his career; more complete and confident, is Rory finally ready to win at Augusta National?CBS Sports - 16m -
Nine big 2025 NBA Draft questions the NCAA Tournament may help answer—including Johni Broome's pro outlook
From Cooper Flagg to Johni Broome and even small-school stars, here's what to know for the NCAA TournamentCBS Sports - 16m -
Nine big 2025 NBA Draft questions the NCAA Tournament may help answer—including Johni Broome's pro outlook
From Cooper Flagg to Johni Broome and even small-school stars, here's what to know for the NCAA TournamentCBS Sports - 16m -
NCAA Basketball Tournament 2025: Surprising bracket upset picks, March Madness advice, strategy, predictions
SportsLine's model has revealed its last-minute bracket advice for 2025 NCAA bracket contestsCBS Sports - 17m