Are The Maple Leafs Mistaking Mitch Marner's Decision To Decline a Trade As A Sign Of Loyalty?

Mitch Marner (Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images)

The Toronto Maple Leafs and Mitch Marner appear to be on the same page...for now. As GM Brad Treliving says, the two sides are aligned following a dramatic trade deadline that included asking Marner to waive his no-trade clause for a deal with Carolina. Everyone is now moving in the same direction.

How long will that last?

Marner declined to waive his no-movement clause, which was well within his right. While some view this as a signal that he wants to remain in Toronto long-term, others see it as a strategic move to maximize his value in free agency.

According to Pierre LeBrun of TSN, the Leafs’ willingness to discuss trading Marner could push him in one of two directions. He might feel disrespected and prepared to leave, or he could realize that the organization is open to moving on and reconsidering his future. Either way, the request to waive his no-trade clause is likely weighing on Marner as he looks ahead to the offseason.

Maple Leafs Should Not Be Fooled Into Believing Marner Is Solely Loyal

There are several reasons Marner might have said no. Staying with the Leafs could be the highest among them, but not going to Carolina could also have been a factor. Whether that be because it was Carolina specifically or because the spotlight isn’t as bright, thus limiting the eyeballs on how fantastic a season he’s having, the ripple effect of being moved out of the center of the hockey universe in Canada shouldn’t be discounted.

The expectation remains that Marner will enter free agency this summer. His refusal to waive his no-trade clause and his refusal to sign an extension suggest he is looking to leverage his position. Marner is reportedly seeking a contract worth approximately $104 million over eight years—an average annual value of $13 million.

LeBrun wonders if Marner is thinking twice after the Leafs so heavily pursued Mikko Rantanen, but if Marner doesn’t sign fairly quickly, it should indicate that this is all about money.

Mitch Marner reportedly declined to waive his no-movement clause for a potential Mikko Rantanen trade per @reporterchris pic.twitter.com/v5g1y9oafu
— TSN (@TSN_Sports) March 8, 2025

The team’s willingness to go another direction should be a wake-up call, and time will tell if that’s accurate.

By staying put for now, Marner ensures that multiple teams will be lining up to offer him a massive contract in free agency, potentially forcing the Leafs to meet his demands or risk losing him for nothing. This is about leverage. His agent wants him to have it and Marner seems happy to play the game.

Toronto’s front office has been eager to extend Marner, but recent events show they are also willing to move him if necessary. Both sides must decide whether they can find common ground or if Marner’s future lies elsewhere. How all of the drama unfolded at the deadline is not a sign he’s definitely staying put. It’s simply a sign he wanted to keep a measure of control in his negotiations – which he did.

Get the latest news and trending stories by following The Hockey News on Google News and by subscribing to The Hockey News newsletter here. And share your thoughts by commenting below the article on THN.com.

Topics

Where Could Maple Leafs' Mitch Marner Sign In The Summer? Five Potential Fits

Following last week’s NHL trade deadline, a major storyline has been the future of Toronto Maple Leafs star right winger Mitch Marner.
Yahoo Sports - 3d
‘I Love It Here, I’ve Said I Want To Stay’: John Tavares Reaffirms Commitment To Maple Leafs Amid Contract Uncertainty Following Loss To Avalanche

After rumors surfaced following the NHL’s trade deadline that the Toronto Maple Leafs had considered trading Mitch Marner to the Carolina Hurricanes in exchange for Mikko Rantanen, John Tavares was ...
Yahoo Sports - 6d
The Maple Leafs Did Very Maple Leaf Things At The NHL Trade Deadline

Brock Nelson was out there. Mikko Rantanen was out there. Brad Marchand was out there.
Yahoo Sports - Mar. 8
Bennett's power-play goals lift short-handed Panthers over Maple Leafs 3-2

Sam Bennett scored power-play goals late in each of the first two periods, Sergei Bobrovsky made 23 saves and the short-handed Florida Panthers beat the Toronto Maple Leafs 3-2 on Thursday night ...
Yahoo Sports - 1d
"I came here to win. I'm not here to retire." Erik Johnson and Charlie Coyle Speak to Colorado Media for the First Time

Trade deadline acquisitions Erik Johnson and Charlie Coyle spoke to Colorado media members prior to tonight's game against the Toronto Maple Leafs.
Yahoo Sports - 6d
'We'll See What Happens With That': Marlies Coach John Gruden Hasn't Spoken To Ryan Reaves Following Maple Leafs' Assignment To AHL

Reaves hasn't been in the Maple Leafs' lineup since Mar. 2 against the Penguins.
Yahoo Sports - 40m
'It Was A Bit Stressful': Former Maple Leafs Prospect Fraser Minten Reacts To Boston Trade, Taking On Former Team In Bruins Debut

Minten made his Providence debut against the Marlies on Wednesday night in Toronto.
Yahoo Sports - 2d
'There's Not A Lot Of Room': How The Panthers Made Life Difficult For Maple Leafs In Playoff-Like Matchup

The Panthers scored two of their three goals on the power play, which was the difference in this game.
Yahoo Sports - 1d
Here's Why Star Winger Zach Hyman Chose Edmonton Oilers To Pursue Stanley Cup Dream

Oilers star winger Zach Hyman has been a great success in Edmonton. Leaving the Toronto Maple Leafs was a tough decision for Hyman, but in this feature story from THN's Nov. 26, 2021 edition, ...
Yahoo Sports - 1d

Are The Maple Leafs Mistaking Mitch Marner's Decision To Decline a Trade As A Sign Of Loyalty?

Maple Leafs Should Not Be Fooled Into Believing Marner Is Solely Loyal

Topics

Related

Where Could Maple Leafs' Mitch Marner Sign In The Summer? Five Potential Fits

‘I Love It Here, I’ve Said I Want To Stay’: John Tavares Reaffirms Commitment To Maple Leafs Amid Contract Uncertainty Following Loss To Avalanche

The Maple Leafs Did Very Maple Leaf Things At The NHL Trade Deadline

Bennett's power-play goals lift short-handed Panthers over Maple Leafs 3-2

"I came here to win. I'm not here to retire." Erik Johnson and Charlie Coyle Speak to Colorado Media for the First Time

'We'll See What Happens With That': Marlies Coach John Gruden Hasn't Spoken To Ryan Reaves Following Maple Leafs' Assignment To AHL

'It Was A Bit Stressful': Former Maple Leafs Prospect Fraser Minten Reacts To Boston Trade, Taking On Former Team In Bruins Debut

'There's Not A Lot Of Room': How The Panthers Made Life Difficult For Maple Leafs In Playoff-Like Matchup

Here's Why Star Winger Zach Hyman Chose Edmonton Oilers To Pursue Stanley Cup Dream

More from Yahoo Sports

Nets' Jordi Fernandez gives details on Cam Thomas' hamstring injury

Oregon State Spring Football Nuggets Day 6: Defense Wins First Scrimmage

Hilary Knight has a goal and 2 assists to help the Fleet beat the Charge, 5-2

New-look OLB room for Arizona Cardinals has solid sack potential

Orlando Pride waste no time bringing the match to Chicago Stars, 6 to 0

More in Sports

Nets' Jordi Fernandez gives details on Cam Thomas' hamstring injury

Oregon State Spring Football Nuggets Day 6: Defense Wins First Scrimmage

Hilary Knight has a goal and 2 assists to help the Fleet beat the Charge, 5-2

New-look OLB room for Arizona Cardinals has solid sack potential

Real Madrid won't play without 72 hours' rest