Will a Chinese doping scandal ruin the Olympics?
![Will a Chinese doping scandal ruin the Olympics?](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/07/GettyImages-1234166962-e1719933898729.jpg?w=900)
With the Paris Olympics weeks away, China’s swimmers have been caught up in the latest state-sponsored doping scandal.
The schemes may change, from the East German steroids of 50 years ago to the recent Russian mass urine-test falsifications, but the corrosive, demoralizing effect on clean athletes never changes. After years of training and intrusive testing, clean American swimmers find themselves competing against Chinese athletes who used performance-enhancing drugs.
“We have to pull our shorts below our knees and our shirts up to our chests,” Allison Schmitt, a ten-time Olympic swimming medalist, said as she described the testing to the House committee investigating the Chinese doping, “while someone bends over and watches the pee come out.” Michael Phelps, a 23-time swimming gold medalist, testified that he had as many as 150 such intrusive drug tests in a year, more than entire national teams, and often had to provide four to six vials of blood.
A New York Times investigation recently revealed that, just before the 2021 Tokyo Games, 23 Chinese swimmers tested positive during a domestic meet for a heart medication called trimetazidine, or TMZ, which is banned from competition as a performance-enhancing drug.
After waiting two months, the Chinese anti-doping agency disclosed the tests to the World Anti-Doping Agency but claimed that the athletes had unknowingly ingested TMZ while eating dinner at a Chinese hotel. The Chinese agency did not explain how a prescription-only drug in pill form appeared in meals eaten by a staggering number of elite swimmers.
Both the World Anti-Doping Agency and the Chinese anti-doping agency are supposed to follow a strict liability regime, even in cases of alleged accidental contamination. Athletes are responsible for what medications they use and what they eat. This is why, for example, Allison Schmitt gave up topical creams and oral medications to avoid an unintended positive test.
Further, China's agency was obligated under international rules to immediately publicly disclose the positive tests, identify the swimmers and provisionally suspend them, pending an investigation of whether the athletes had intentionally ingested TMZ. When the Chinese agency failed to follow these procedures, the World Anti-Doping Agency should have intervened and appealed to the Court of Arbitration in Sport, especially since a Chinese whistleblower, now living in Germany, had previously reported that the Chinese government was giving its athletes the banned drug.
The World Anti-Doping Agency's inaction was inexplicable, because it had filed just such an appeal when the Russian anti-doping agency failed to act in the identical case of Kamila Valieva, a Russian Olympic figure skater who tested positive for TMZ. (She claimed that her grandfather’s TMZ pill had gotten into her strawberry dessert.) The Court of Arbitration in Sport stripped Valieva of the gold medal she had won at the 2022 Winter Games.
By not intervening in the case of the 23 Chinese swimmers, the agency allowed many to qualify for and compete in the 2021 Tokyo games, where several won gold medals. Eleven of the 23 swimmers will be competing in the Paris Olympics. There is no evidence that China bribed the World Anti-Doping Agency, but winning Olympic medals is a geopolitical priority in China, and over the last five years China has paid the agency an extra $1.8 million above its required dues.
The agency denied any wrongdoing. It has retained a Swiss attorney to conduct an investigation, but it has not committed to publicly release his findings. Travis Tygart, the head of the United States Anti-Doping Agency, has called the investigation a “whitewash.”
The World Anti-Doping Agency’s failure to do its job could have dire implications for the future of the Olympics. As Michael Phelps warned, without competitive integrity, someday “the Olympic Games might not even be there.”
Gregory J. Wallance was a federal prosecutor in the Carter and Reagan administrations and a member of the ABSCAM prosecution team, which convicted a U.S. senator and six representatives of bribery. He is the author of “Into Siberia: George Kennan’s Epic Journey Through the Brutal, Frozen Heart of Russia.”
Date: |
Filter
-
The New York Times - World
Justice Department Opens Criminal Investigation in Chinese Doping Case
The move escalates a fight with China and world antidoping officials, and will cast a shadow of criminality over the Paris Olympics. -
ABC News - Sports
World swimming federation confirms US federal investigation into Chinese swimmers' doping tests
The international swimming federation says its executive director has been ordered to testify as a witness in a U.S. criminal investigation into the case of 23 Chinese swimmers who tested positive for a banned substance in 2021 yet were allowed to ... -
ABC News - Sports
World swimming federation confirms US has launched federal investigation into Chinese swimmers' doping tests
World swimming federation confirms US has launched federal investigation into Chinese swimmers' doping tests -
ESPN - Sports
Porter to face federal charge in betting scandal
Court papers indicate former Raptors player Jontay Porter will be charged with a federal felony connected to the betting scandal that spurred the NBA to ban him. -
CBS News - Top stories
3 signs credit cards are ruining your finances (and how to fix it)
High credit card payments could wreck your finances, so it's important to proactively identify (and fix) the issue. -
The Hill - Politics
The Chinese electric vehicle tariff conundrum
Good trade policy is not easy.EV -
ABC News - World
Ruins of ancient garden likely owned by Emperor Caligula uncovered near Vatican during excavations
Italy's culture ministry says archaeological excavations near the Vatican have uncovered the remains of an ancient garden overlooking the right bank of the Tiber River that was likely owned by Roman Emperor Caligula -
BBC News - Top stories
EU hits Chinese electric cars with new tariffs
The move poses a challenge to Beijing, which hopes EVs will help revive the country's flagging economy.European Union -
The Wall Street Journal - World
EU Confirms Tariffs on Chinese-Made EVs
The European Union confirmed plans to impose additional tariffs on electric cars made in China, dashing hopes of a solution sought by several carmakers whose executives fear reprisal from an escalating trade war.European Union -
NBC News - Top stories
Chinese migrants deported on first large flight from U.S. since 2018
A group of migrants were deported to China over the weekend on the first large charter flight there since 2018, the Department of Homeland Security said.
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Third House Democrat says Biden should bow out of presidential race
Rep. Seth Moulton (Mass.) on Thursday became the third House Democrat to publicly call on President Biden to step out of the presidential race after a weak debate performance last week that left his allies shaken. “President Biden has done ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
Biden says he was seen by doctor after debate and is fine
President Biden told Democratic governors that he saw a doctor after his shaky debate performance last week and was given a clean bill of health. The comments, first reported by Politico, apparently contradict White House press secretary Karine ...Joe Biden -
The Hill - Politics
I’m Gen Z. Here’s how I’m escaping my phone this summer.
Gen Z is experiencing a barrage of notifications and ads on social media, but museums offer a slower, more thoughtful approach to sharing information, providing a respite from the fast-paced online world. -
The Hill - Politics
Students at fake university created by ICE can sue US, court rules
Students who enrolled in a fake university set up by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) as part of a sting operation can sue the U.S., an appeals court ruled last week. The ruling by a three-judge panel of the Federal Circuit Court of ... -
The Hill - Politics
Dozens of US beaches closed or hit with swimming advisories on July Fourth
Dozens of beaches in the U.S. are closed or under swimming advisories on the Fourth of July, as a result of high levels of bacteria in the water. Local and state governments have issued warnings about shores in their own areas but there is no ...