White House locks horns with judiciary over deportations

The Trump administration is on a collision course with the courts after a week spent taunting a federal judge and escalating a battle over whether his orders have been defied.

Administration officials on March 15 rebuffed an oral order from U.S. District Court Judge James Boasberg to turn around or halt flights of Venezuelan migrants headed to a Salvadoran prison.

In the week since, they have lashed out at the judge inside and outside of court, diminishing Boasberg's authority over the matter and repeatedly refusing to provide requested information in court. President Trump and allies in Congress have even floated impeaching Boasberg — sparking some rare public pushback from Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts.

While the week began with broad attacks on Boasberg’s ruling over the flights, it concluded with Trump decrying the entire concept of nationwide injunctions to halt his agenda and calling for the Supreme Court to intervene.

Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) said in an interview with NBC’s “Meet the Press” that he agreed with those who said the U.S. was in a constitutional crisis.

“Look, Donald Trump is a lawless, angry man. He thinks he should be king,” Schumer said. “He thinks he should do whatever he wants, regardless of the law, and he thinks judges should just listen to him.”

“Defying court orders is why our democracy is at risk, and we'll have to do everything to fight back in that regard,” he added.

Numerous Trump officials have suggested the federal bench can't interfere with Trump’s foreign policy, despite judges routinely reviewing immigration policy and other major national security matters.

Attorney General Pam Bondi said Boasberg had “no right” to ask questions seeking more information about the flights that deported alleged Venezuelan gang members.

Stephen Miller, the deputy chief of staff to the president who has been central to the administration’s sweeping push to crackdown on immigration and ramp up deportations, sparred with television anchors over the case and argued Trump telegraphed his plans on the campaign trail.

“The American people voted for this specific action to occur. It has occurred, and it is occurring, and it will continue to occur,” Miller said. And the idea that a single district court judge has the authority to direct as though they were the president, the movement of airplanes around the globe, again it is the most outrageous thing I have seen from a district court judge in my lifetime, but frankly going back multiple lifetimes.”

Trump and some of his aides have not shied away from trolling their critics, dating back to the 2024 campaign. They have leaned into that in recent days, as the administration has seemingly embraced the controversy surrounding the case and Boasberg’s order.

“The president will always follow the law, but this judge was too slow. We played a little game of ‘catch me if you can,’ and guess what, the judge wasn’t able to catch us on this one,” deputy press secretary Harrison Fields said Tuesday on NewsNation’s “Morning in America.”

In another media appearance during the week, Fields suggested Boasberg’s ruling was pushing the nation closer to a constitutional crisis, turning around a line of attack that has become common among alarmed watchdogs and Democrats.

The White House posted a video to its social media account this week that featured footage of migrants in handcuffs being patted down by Border Patrol and put on a plane. The video was set to the song “Closing Time” by Semisonic, which drew a rebuke from the band.

“I think it sums up our immigration policy pretty well. 'You don't have to go home, but you can't stay here,'” press secretary Karoline Leavitt said, quoting a line from the song.

Border czar Tom Homan said the administration would not stop its deportation efforts, telling Fox News, “I don’t care what the judges think.”

Trump has at multiple points said he would not openly defy a court order and that his administration would appeal rulings it disagreed with.

But the administration’s combative approach has drawn rebukes from legal groups and Democrats who view Trump and his aides as attempting to consolidate power and undermine the judiciary.

“For more than 200 years, our legal system has afforded individuals the right to disagree with judicial decisions and to appeal them if they are the aggrieved party,” the American Bar Association said in a statement this week.

“Targeting judges personally or threatening to remove them because they rule a certain way has never been acceptable. Such efforts are intended to intimidate judges and our courts and weaken public trust and confidence in our judicial system.”

Roberts himself made the same argument.

“For more than two centuries, it has been established that impeachment is not an appropriate response to disagreement concerning a judicial decision. The normal appellate review process exists for that purpose,” he said in a rare public statement shortly after Trump’s calls for impeachment.

Boasberg on Friday made clear he intends to push back against the Trump administration, including on whether officials flouted his order to turn around flights of Venezuelans headed to El Salvador.

“The government’s not being terribly cooperative at this point, but I will get to the bottom of whether they violated my order, who ordered this and what the consequences will be,” Boasberg said during a Friday hearing.

The Justice Department (DOJ) this week repeatedly refused to share details about flights carrying more than 230 Venezuelans to El Savlador — flight plans that would help Boasberg sort out whether the government complied with an oral order he gave at around 6:45 p.m. March 15, as well as a written order that was posted to the docket at 7:27 p.m. that same day.

At a Monday hearing a DOJ attorney repeatedly told Boasberg he was “not authorized” to disclose more information about the flights.

Then when asked to explain the legal rationale behind their refusal to do so, DOJ again demurred, writing in a filing that “there is no justification to order the provision of additional information, and that doing so would be inappropriate.”

DOJ was then directed to provide the flight information to Boasberg under seal, but Boasberg indicated it again did not do so, instead submitting a sworn statement from a midlevel immigration official saying the Cabinet was discussing whether to invoke the state secrets privilege. That would limit sharing with Boasberg, who has handled highly sensitive classified information previously through his role as a Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) Court judge.

Boasberg said the response was “woefully insufficient” and “evaded” obligations to show the administration complied with an earlier court ruling.

Though both oral and written orders are binding, the White House has repeatedly asserted it complied with Boasberg’s written directive, while failing to mention his verbal instruction.

“We are 100 percent confident that we've complied,” Leavitt told reporters Thursday.

“And as I've said from the podium and will continue to say, all of the flights that were subject to the written order of the judge took off before the written order was pushed in the courtroom.”

Topics

White House, courts battle over deportations

The White House is igniting a power struggle between the executive and judicial branches of government.
The Hill - 5d
The Memo: Roberts rebukes Trump in latest twist of White House battle with judiciary

Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts issued a clear, if implicit, rebuke of President Trump on Tuesday, intensifying a clash between the White House and the judiciary. The Trump administration, ...
The Hill - 4d
White House denies defying judge's order over deportations to El Salvador

An order to halt the removal of 261 people came too late and had "no legal basis" anyway, the White House says.
BBC News - 5d
White House Denies Violating Judge’s Order in Deporting Venezuelans

Karoline Leavitt, the White House press secretary, also asserted that the federal courts “have no jurisdiction” over President Trump’s conduct of foreign affairs or his power to expel foreign enemies.
The New York Times - 6d
Fight to impeach judge will be up to Johnson: White House

White House deputy chief of staff James Blair said it will be up to Speaker Mike Johnson (R-La.) whether the federal judge who sought to block Trump administration deportation flights over the ...
The Hill - 2d
Morning Report — White House escalates fight over deportations

In today’s issue: President Trump and his advisers are ratcheting up their fight over his immigration policy, seeking to muscle past court orders aimed at pumping the brakes. They expect the ...
The Hill - 4d
White House denies violating judge’s order with Venezuela deportations

Trump administration used Alien Enemies Act to deport about 250 alleged gang members to El Salvador. US politics live – latest updates The White House has denied allegations that it engaged in ...
The Guardian - 5d
Semisonic blasts use of 'Closing Time' in White House deportation video

Semisonic said it did not authorize and does not condone the White House's using its hit "Closing Time" in a video that appears to depict deportation, the band said in a statement Monday.
NBC News - 5d
White House calls judge challenging Trump deportation order a ‘Democrat activist’

Press secretary says judge who weighed legality of Trump deportation order ‘does not have that authority’. The White House on Wednesday labeled the federal judge challenging the Trump ...
The Guardian - 3d
White House defends decision to deport alleged gang members amid legal fight

Over the weekend, the Trump administration cited a rarely-used 18th-century law to justify the deportations of suspected gang members. As Ed O'Keefe reports, the president's moves sparked a legal ...
CBS News - 5d
AP reporter spars with White House over tariffs

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt on Tuesday clashed with a reporter with The Associated Press over President Trump’s use of tariffs after granting the outlet a rare question during a ...
The Hill - Mar. 11
White House questions authority of judge's verbal order on Venezuelan deportation flights

The White House on Monday cast doubt on the authority of a verbal order from a judge directing the administration to turn around planes carrying Venezuelan migrants out of the country. White House ...
The Hill - 5d
Watch live: Leavitt briefs White House press corps after deportations to El Salvador

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt will brief the press and take questions Monday, coming quick on the heels of a weekend effort to deport dozens of Venezuelans. Secretary of State Marco ...
The Hill - 5d
Eagles accept White House invite to celebrate title

The Philadelphia Eagles will be visiting the White House on April 28 to celebrate their Super Bowl LIX victory over the Kansas City Chiefs.
ESPN - Mar. 11
White House denies ignoring court order blocking some deportations

A federal judge in Washington, D.C., held a hearing late Monday on the Trump administration's use of the 18th-century Alien Enemies Act. Despite being blocked by the courts, the White House used ...
CBS News - 5d
White House escalates attacks on judge in deportation case: 'Egregious abuse of the bench'

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt on Wednesday stepped up attacks on a federal judge that ordered flights carrying alleged Venezuelan gang members to be turned around, decrying him as a ...
The Hill - 3d
White House rips Dems, condemns attacks on Teslas

The White House on Wednesday condemned Democrats for not speaking out about attacks on Tesla dealerships and cars, doubling down on the Trump administration’s criticism over the recent targeting of ...
The Hill - 3d
Trump insists he has final say on deportation cases amid judiciary battle

President Donald Trump claims he has the final say in all deportation matters as he continues to battle the courts over his use of the Alien Enemies Act. NBC News Correspondents Yamiche Alcindor ...
NBC News - 1d
Judge orders Trump White House to disclose deportation flight details

The Trump administration went to court Monday defending its decision to invoke the Alien Enemies Act of 1798 and deport hundreds of alleged gang members to El Salvador. On Saturday night, a judge ...
CBS News - 5d
'SNL' taps into cynicism over Elon Musk's White House influence

Questions about tech investor Elon Musk's extraordinary influence in President Donald Trump's White House found answers that doubled as punchlines on "Saturday Night Live."
NBC News - Mar. 9
White House criticizes 'activist judges' interfering with Trump's actions

White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt criticized the judge who blocked President Trump's use of the Alien Enemies Act for deportations and called on the Supreme Court to "reign in activist ...
NBC News - 3d
GOP lawmakers conflicted over Trump’s clash with judiciary

Republican lawmakers are conflicted over how to respond to President Trump’s confrontational standoff with the federal judiciary, which drew a rare public rebuke Tuesday from Chief Justice John ...
The Hill - 3d
Details on upcoming Trump call with Putin, White House's court-defying deportation of Venezuelans

President Trump has expressed optimism ahead of Tuesday's call with Russia's Vladimir Putin about the war in Ukraine. CBS News senior White House correspondent Weijia Jiang reports on that and the ...
CBS News - 5d
Trump admin live updates: White House asks court to stay deportation flights TRO

Despite a federal judge ordering deportation flights of Venezuelans to cease, video shows more deportees arriving in El Salvador.
ABC News - 6d
White House touts deportations under Alien Enemies Act after judge block efforts

The Trump administration announced deportations of hundreds of immigrants it alleges are members of a Venezuelan gang to El Salvador under the Alien Enemies Act.
NBC News - 6d
Watch live: White House holds briefing as fears over economy, trade war mount

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt will hold a press briefing Tuesday afternoon as President Trump's tariffs and dips in the stock market have raised concerns over the economy. Trump on ...
The Hill - Mar. 11
Watch live: Trump, Hegseth speak at White House amid concerns over NATO moves

President Trump and Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth will give remarks from the White House Friday morning amid questions over whether the U.S. will continue its 75-year leadership of NATO and at ...
The Hill - 1d
The White House war on federal statistics

Economists and scientists worry over disappearing data and advisory groups
Financial Times - 4d
Eagles will visit White House to celebrate Super Bowl win after 2018 absence

News confirmed by White House on Tuesday Team were disinvited by Donald Trump in 2018 Comment: why athletes should boycott Trump The Philadelphia Eagles have confirmed they will visit the ...
The Guardian - Mar. 11
White House’s defense for not recalling deportations ‘one heck of a stretch’, says judge

Administration claims it didn’t stop flights despite judge’s instructions because he did not write it in the formal order. The Trump administration claimed to a federal judge on Monday that it ...
The Guardian - 5d
Judge demands answers from White House on deportation flights to El Salvador

Jeb Boasberg instructs Trump administration to explain how refusal to return flights did not violate court order. A federal judge instructed the Trump administration on Thursday to explain why its ...
The Guardian - 2d
White House says Canada would 'benefit greatly' from becoming 51st state

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters that Canada would "benefit greatly" from becoming the 51st state as tensions continue over tariffs.
NBC News - Mar. 11
A Trump critic just won Greenland's election, but the White House may still benefit

A party that has criticized President Trump's threat to take over Greenland won an election there, but may have to govern with a pro-White House opponent.
NBC News - Mar. 12
David Sacks sold $200 million in crypto-related holdings before taking White House job, ethics memo says

The White House memo revealed that AI and Crypto Czar David Sacks divested over $200 million in digital asset-related investments.
CNBC - Mar. 14
Semisonic objects to White House using song 'Closing Time': 'You missed the point'

The band Semisonic is pushing back at the White House for using their hit song “Closing Time” over a social media post that shows a shackled deportee
ABC News - 5d
WATCH: Van Horn, players postgame - Arkansas 16, Oral Roberts 0

Arkansas coach Dave Van Horn and players postgame press conferences after the win over Oral Roberts.
Yahoo Sports - 3d
WATCH: Van Horn, players postgame - Arkansas 12, South Carolina 3

Arkansas coach Dave Van Horn and players postgame press conferences after the win over South Carolina.
Yahoo Sports - 7h
Watch live: White House holds briefing amid Trump battle with courts, Ukraine talks

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt is holding a press briefing Wednesday afternoon following an intense back-and-forth between President Trump and a federal judge over Venezuelan migrant ...
The Hill - 3d
White House withdraws CDC director nominee

Dave Weldon had faced growing scrutiny over his anti-vaccine views.
Politico - Mar. 13