When it comes to educating immigrant children, the benefits outweigh the costs
![When it comes to educating immigrant children, the benefits outweigh the costs](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2019/11/istock-children-classroom-diverse-2019.jpg?w=900)
They are the “newcomers” — newly arrived immigrant students, many starting schools this month. And with immigration, crime and border issues at the top of the ballot, they are a big deal this election season.
The costs to educate these newcomers, and our responsibility to do so, has resurfaced as a political concern. In the past we argued over how a child should be educated: at-home schooling, public charters, private schools, etc. But there was a common understanding that every child should have access to a "classroom," regardless of their immigration status.
Now that is up for debate.
The basic right of young people to access education, regardless of immigration status, was codified by the Supreme Court in 1982, in Plyler v. Doe. In a 5-4 vote, the decision held “that any resources which might be saved from excluding undocumented children from public school would be far outweighed by the societal harms from denying a young person an education.”
But today, some conservative local, state and policy leaders are pointing to rising levels of immigration — some legal, some not. It’s creating new tensions, given that the share of students in public schools from immigrant households has grown almost fourfold, from 7 percent in 1980 to 23 percent in 2021.
One conservative think tank, the Heritage Foundation, is leading the charge to upend the system, because of what they argue are unfair costs to the more than 130,000 K-12 public schools in the U.S. — many still facing post-COVID economic challenges.
According to the World Population Review, “in the United States, K-12 schools spend about $612.7 billion annually. This is about $12,612 per pupil” (although the numbers change depending on the source of school funding). “Federal, state, and local governments spend about $720.9 billion annually or $14,840 per pupil.”
Trying to extrapolate from public school data and put an exact price tag on each newcomer — especially those without authorization — is difficult, as children arrive at different times of the year and with different needs, such as English learning specialists (ESLs) or emotional counselors.
As one expert, Julie Sugarman of the Migration Policy Institute’s National Center on Immigrant Integration Policy, told Congress recently, “If you already have a lot of teachers who are well-trained to serve these kids, then you might need just a minimal number of paraprofessionals or ESL (English as a Second Language) teachers to serve newcomers. ... [Schools] can absorb two or three kids with a minimal amount of additional actual cost if they don’t have to actually hire a new teacher.”
But extra teachers equal extra dollars — and those can quickly add up.
In testimony before Congress, one expert used data from FAIR — a highly partisan group — and said the costs are high for unauthorized kids because English is not their first language, and they need Limited English Proficiency (LEP) assistance.
Tennessee says its taxpayers spent $571 million on the education of illegal immigrants last year. Texas says it cost $7 billion a year to educate “illegal aliens.”
Many state and local leaders want to consider charging tuition for newcomers or find ways to keep them out of school, coming up with their plans of action.
Texas Gov. Gregg Abbott, among others, wants the 1982 Supreme Court ruling reversed because of the high costs of educating immigrant children. His state has repeatedly bused immigrants to Chicago, where “about 5,600 newcomers were staying at Chicago’s 17 shelters” last week, according to the Washington Post.
Florida is also debating a crackdown on the presence of illegal immigrants in schools. And in Oklahoma, lawmakers are requiring that school districts report the number of undocumented students in their schools — meaning that teachers and school administrators must check the legal status of students.
Many teachers say they do not want to become border patrol agents, and that having to report immigrant kids to authorities fuels absenteeism.
Rarely considered in this debate, however, is the lived experience of immigrant children, who must live with the daily fear of deportation.
Newcomers face discrimination due to myths about their negative school behavior, even though studies show immigrant students to be highly motivated and well behaved when teachers are prepared and trained to receive them. And there are numerous success stories of immigrant children enriching classrooms and bringing cultural awareness that benefits everyone.
Immigrant children also become part of a cycle that benefits both the host country and the sending nation. According to a recent report by the Wilson Center, “migrants who gain skills, savings, and experience working abroad, often return home to start companies and employ people in their homeland, thus relieving the pressure for future migration.”
So, where do we go next?
First, we need to update antiquated systems for collecting school data and give monetary grants to incentive public schools to provide accurate information on immigrant students. Addressing the precise needs of a newcomer is made more challenging by the lack of data from schools; in Chicago, for example, the number of migrant children enrolled in public schools can range from 9,000 to 17,000, depending on the definitions and metrics used.
Second, we must provide more federal resources for schools to hire counselors to help newly arriving families with school registration, legal assistance and language skills, including Haitian and Creole. In states like Massachusetts, three out of four recent migrants are from Haiti.
Third, it’s important that we tell the story of how immigrant kids contribute to keeping America diverse and economically strong. America is a global power and needs ideas from all over the world. As of 2021, about half of recent immigrant children are Latino, but today many come to America from Asia and Africa as well.
Young immigrant students grow up to contribute to America’s economic growth in two ways: by working and by spending. Their presence in unexpectedly high numbers “explains some of the surprising strength in consumer spending and overall economic growth since 2022,” according to the New Yorker. “Without positive net migration, the U.S. population is projected to begin shrinking by about 2040.”
Immigration will bolster the American economy by approximately $7 trillion over the next decade, according to the Congressional Budget Office’s 2024 report.
At the end of the day, you can add up cost numbers and try to argue against educating newcomers. But that is just math — math that misses history and undercuts the future.
We are a nation of immigrants. We made a promise to educate every child. Let's keep it.
Tara D. Sonenshine is former U.S. undersecretary of state for public diplomacy and a nonresident senior fellow at the Fletcher School of Law and Diplomacy at Tufts University.
Date: |
-
NBC News - Politics
Most SNAP ‘skimming’ victims will no longer get stolen benefits back if Congress doesn’t take action by Sept. 30
Low-income families who are robbed of their grocery funds may no longer get reimbursed if Congress doesn’t act by Sept. 30.1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
When will you need a REAL ID? It may be complicated
A program that is intended to enhance U.S. travel requirements, which has been delayed multiple times, is scheduled to take effect in May 2025. Hiccups during the initial rollout may, however, ...1 hour ago -
Inc. - Business
Trump Tariff Plan Would Hike Shipping Costs, Much Like 2018
A return to and expansion of the GOP candidate's tariff regime would boost inflation and increase prices for consumers, experts say.1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Caitlin Clark on 'liking' Taylor Swift's Harris endorsement: 'Educate yourself'
Indiana Fever star Caitlin Clark set the record straight after her Instagram "like" on Taylor Swift's endorsement of Vice President Harris stoked speculation about her political beliefs. Clark was ...3 hours ago -
CBS News - Top stories
States ramp up efforts to enact stricter immigration laws, group finds
Efforts by state lawmakers to pass stricter immigration laws have increased significantly over the past four years, a national civil rights group found in a new report.3 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Pelosi: Trump reminds me of balloon 'when you stick a pin in it'
Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) said in a Wednesday interview that former President Trump reminds her of a balloon that rapidly loses air “when you stick a pin in it.” Pelosi, who was the top House ...3 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Yahoo News - World
'I thought I would die with my six children' - dam collapse survivor
4 hours ago -
CBS News - Top stories
Will homebuyer competition rise when mortgage interest rates are cut?
As mortgage rates drop, buyers may need to come to terms with how it could impact the competition they face.4 hours ago - Mortgage -
GameSpot - Tech
Xbox Friend Requests Are Finally Coming Back
For the first time since the Xbox 360 days, Xbox users will be able to send and receive friend requests. The announcement was made via a blog post on the official Xbox website, which provided more ...5 hours ago -
BBC News - Top stories
'Tubes dislodged' when Letby was at other hospital - inquiry
Lucy Letby worked two placements at Liverpool Women's Hospital in 2012 and 2015.6 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Trump fails (again) to hit Biden-Harris on national security
The former commander in chief’s failure to take advantage of the abject incompetence of President Biden and his national security team is yet another missed opportunity that is turning a race Trump ...29 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Judge sides with Illinois attorney general in lawsuit over Chicago Trump Tower's water use
A Chicago court ruled this week that the Windy City’s Trump Tower violated the Illinois environmental protection law with its use of water from the Chicago River. In his ruling, Cook County Circuit ...30 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Georgia school shooting suspect's dad seeks protection in jail, citing 'incalculable number of threats'
Colin Gray, the father of accused 14-year-old Georgia school shooter Colt Gray, is asking to be separated from the other inmates in jail, where he is being held on charges of second-degree murder, ...36 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Senators to pursue contempt charges against Steward Health CEO
A bipartisan group of senators will pursue contempt of Congress charges against Steward Health Care CEO Ralph de la Torre after he defied a subpoena and failed to attend a Senate hearing Thursday. ...41 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Bridging America's divide: Understanding moral misconceptions
Research suggests that the perceived moral differences between Democrats and Republicans are a major factor in America's political divide, and addressing this misconception could help bridge the gap.59 minutes ago