What the performative patriotism of Donald Trump reveals about his character
When I was preparing for deployment for Iraq in 2007, we were required to do grenade training. Before we started, our master sergeant asked who would jump on a grenade to save the lives of others. More than half of the Marines (mostly guys who hadn’t deployed yet) raised their hands. When we finished training, he asked the same question. After seeing what grenades actually do, no one raised their hands.
Our master sergeant then told us that is what separated Cpl. Jason Dunham from the rest of us Marines, and why Dunham earned the Medal of Honor. We all sacrificed in the military, but Jason’s sacrifice is on a level even Marines might struggle to understand.
Earlier this week, Donald Trump, looking to jump start his struggling campaign decided to make a campaign stop at Arlington National Cemetery. This hallowed ground had been avoided by Trump for the last three years, but now was a perfect opportunity to engage in what he has mastered better than most politicians; performative patriotism.
However, there was something that would inhibit his goals and that was the actual rules of Arlington National Cemetery which prohibit political campaigning and photography for political purposes. Of course, that wouldn’t stop Trump and his team from getting what they wanted. An altercation ensued, and we were presented with a picture of Trump smiling over the graves of the fallen with a thumbs up.
This pursuit of the photo op, despite rules, decorum, decency and tact is the latest illustration of Trump appearing to view fallen military and their families as props and not people. And it plays into the feelings that Americans have about a word that Trump knows how to manipulate. Sacrifice.
This isn’t the first time that Trump has run afoul of his view of military members. We all remember what he said about late Sen. John McCain (R-Ariz.), his words to his chief of staff and Gold Star father Gen. John Kelly about “suckers and losers.” And in his latest insult, he asserted that the nation's highest military award, the Congressional Medal of honor, is no better than the Presidential Medal of Freedom.
But there was one incident back in 2016 that I want to touch on, because it speaks volumes about how Trump views sacrifice.
After Khizr and Ghazala Khan shared the story of their son, Humayun Khan, who had died in Iraq in 2004, Trump decided to discuss the loss of their son in the context of his own personal sacrifices. Speaking to ABC’s George Stephanopoulos, Trump said “I think I’ve made a lot of sacrifices. I work very, very hard.”
Trump went on to talk about the buildings and jobs he created, putting his business career on the same level as an officer who had died preventing a suicide bomber from killing his men.
Of course, Trump (his writers) put out a carefully worded condolence later. But since then, we have been treated to a slew of insults to people who served and their families. We have also been doused with the performative routine that Trump uses to rally some of his followers. From hugging flags to altering the Bible, Trump has made millions from his followers.
Now this performative patriot routine will always appeal to certain people. Slap a flag on a beer can, truck, t-shirt sleeve, bag of coffee, or underwear and people will pay for it, regardless of its quality. And you really can't blame them for this and Trump being the businessman that he is, taking advantage of that.
But on a deeper level, we also need to understand this. Trump seems to truly believe that the sacrifices that Americans have made in battle are on the same level as the ones he has made in his business and political career. And that is something that no true patriot should accept.
Sure, we all sacrifice in some sense. Parents sacrifice for their kids, immigrants sacrifice their old lives to start a new one here, people give up time with their families to start a new business, and teenagers sacrifice fun times with friends to work toward college acceptance and success. But most of us have the cognizance to realize that what we give up pales in comparison to the sacrifices that service members endure.
It is easy to hug a flag, sell an “American” Bible or stage a photo op at Arlington. But Trump has never been able to truly answer are whether he truly knows what it is like to sacrifice for his country. Does he understand that whatever he did pales in comparison to those who had died for us? And is he humble enough to admit it?
Jos Joseph is a master’s candidate at the Harvard Extension School at Harvard University. He is a Marine veteran who served in Iraq and lives in Anaheim, Calif.
Date: | |
Tag: | Donald Trump |
Topics
-
NBC News - Politics
What Trump, Harris teams say about their debate performances
"Meet the Press" moderator Kristen Welker joins Sunday TODAY’s Willie Geist to discuss what both Kamala Harris and Donald Trump’s campaigns are saying about the final stretch to election day after ...2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
NBC News - Politics
Steve Kornacki: What the road to 270 looks like for Kamala Harris and Donald Trump
NBC News National Political Correspondent Steve Kornacki joins Meet the Press to break down the state of the presidential race.1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
NBC News - Politics
‘His staff’s embarrassed by it’: Aides express concerns about Trump's ties to Laura Loomer
Donald Trump allies are worried that the former president’s ties to right-wing activist Laura Loomer could cost him votes in key battleground states. Hallie Jackson, Jonathan Martin, Marc Short and ...56 minutes ago -
ABC News - Top stories
What the 911 calls in Georgia high school shooting reveal
The emergency dispatch center that received active shooter reports from a Georgia high school was overwhelmed with 911 calls as the situation unfolded.14 hours ago -
BBC News - Top stories
Astronauts reveal what life is like on ISS – and how they deal with 'space smell'
As Suni Williams and Butch Wilmore spend months longer than planned on ISS, three astronauts tell us what life is like in orbit.1 hour ago -
Yahoo Sports - Sports
Chase believes Bengals misled him about his extension this offseason
Ja'Marr Chase reportedly has no plans to negotiate new deal this season with Cincinnati.12 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
What’s so funny about getting an AI app to give you a roasting?
Roasting can be really brutal, but at least if we inflict it on ourselves, we can get ahead of the joke. A friend recently shared a comment someone had made about her online. Sophie was a ...7 hours ago -
The New York Times - Top stories
What to Know About Springfield, Where Thousands of Haitian Migrants Have Settled
Businesses needed workers, and Haitians, many already authorized to work, heard living costs were low. But the newcomers have strained resources, and that has fueled tension.15 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
Who Could Ever Love you by Mary Trump review – family burn book dishes on Donald
Ex-president’s niece’s latest memoir recounts her brutal home life yet she won’t abandon the Trump legacy. Once again, Mary Trump strafes her family, with her third book in four years. Who Could ...4 hours ago - Donald Trump -
NBC News - Top stories
Trump allies worry his ties to far-right activist Laura Loomer could cost him Georgia and North Carolina
Donald Trump allies are worried that the former president’s ties to right-wing activist Laura Loomer could cost him votes in key battleground states.5 hours ago - Donald Trump
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
How a Trump-Musk government efficiency commission might affect NASA
Such a commission would be the perfect vehicle for looking at NASA, an agency with a storied history beset with a slew of problems.58 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Vance says ‘of course' Trump has a plan 'to fix American health care'
Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio), the Republican nominee for vice president, said "of course" former President Trump has a plan to "fix American health care" in a Sunday interview and also outlined several ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Why do most school buses not have seat belts?
School buses frequently lack a safety feature that, if you were caught not wearing one, would result in a ticket — but why?1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
Vance won’t say whether Trump would veto federal abortion ban: ‘I’ve learned my lesson’
Sen. JD Vance (R-Ohio), the GOP vice-presidential nominee, declined to say on Sunday whether former President Trump, if elected, would veto a federal abortion ban, saying, “I’ve learned my lesson” ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Punish the administrators, not the researchers, for campus antisemitism
Congressional appropriations committees can use federal funding cuts to punish campus antisemitism without damaging the essential need for support of basic research.1 hour ago