Trump's Greenland annexation threat is both weird and misplaced
Greenland is in the headlines as President-elect Trump threatens to buy or simply take the territory — perhaps along with Canada and Panama.
Some media outlets have suggested this is no mere empty threat. For countries neighboring the U.S., this may sound like a renewed Manifest Destiny. For many, this is just ridiculous posturing by a leader craving the spotlight.
This surreal moment does, however, provide an opportunity to better understand Greenland’s unique status, if only to put to rest Trump’s misplaced ambitions.
Often described as the world’s largest island, Greenland is immediately to the east of the Canadian territory of Nunavut, with whom it shares cultural and historical links. Colonized by the Kingdom of Denmark in the 18th century, it retains an Indigenous majority. Inuit peoples constitute about 90 percent of the territory’s 56,000 residents, with the others mostly being Danes concentrated in the capital city of Nuuk.
Although part of Denmark, Greenland is also partially independent from it. In 1979, Greenland was granted autonomous status. In 2008, 75 percent of Greenlanders voted to expand self-government powers. Today, Greenland (Kalaallit Nunaat) has its own parliament, flag, language policy, control over education, resource management and even membership in international organizations.
In a highly fragmented political party system, Greenland’s parliament (Inatsisartut) has long been ruled by Siumut, a left-wing social democratic party. In 2021, the left-leaning separatist party Inuit Ataqatigiit won a plurality of seats, allowing its leader, Múte Bourup Egede, to become prime minister. This means that Greenland is currently led by a separatist, although in coalition with other parties. The ruling party focuses a great deal on Greenlandic sovereignty, including rejecting rare earth mining projects that favor foreign companies and endanger the local environment.
The barriers to Greenland becoming independent are considerable. Its fragmented legislature has no single dominant party, which undermines any sense of the island having a single voice. The territory has important regional divisions, as one might expect in a sparsely populated region, especially as the countryside resists centralization from Nuuk. Greenland has rich natural resources, namely fisheries and mining, but it remains dependent on economic transfers from Denmark.
Perhaps the primary factor limiting the likelihood of independence is that the territory enjoys real autonomy, with the potential for more. While hardly impossible, the world has yet to see a special region gain considerable autonomy, and use this as a stepping-stone to independence. This is because meaningful self-government is often considered superior to independence or incorporation.
It also makes the host country seem less threatening, since minorities are recognized by national leaders and are ruled by their own group. Separatists who are forced to govern must also make compromises and sometimes see their policies fall short. All told, regions such as Greenland with real self-government are not likely to gain independence.
This brings us back to Trump’s threat to annex Greenland. To “purchase” the island makes no sense, as it is not Denmark’s to sell. Nor would Inuit peoples sell their homeland. It is true that Greenland wants the U.S. to be an ally and a trading partner, but joining the U.S. would run counter to its quest for self-rule. As Greenland’s leaders have made clear, there is no logic in trading one Western colonial power for another.
Greenland is open for business, but it is not for sale. Inuit peoples in Greenland also understand the limited nature of self-rule for Puerto Rico and Native Americans. The U.S. has a poor track record in sharing power with minority nations, and it would be no different for Greenland under President Trump. And as for the threat of invasion, this would involve one NATO member attacking another, theoretically triggering a war between the U.S. and its allies.
An American Greenland is little more than bluster. Greenland is enjoying a growing sense of self-government in association with Denmark. It seeks to diversify its foreign relations and trading partners, seeking better terms with mining companies, as well as with Canada, including deepening ties with Inuit in Nunavut.
Threats of annexation run contrary to the potential partnerships that would best serve the interests of the people in Greenland and the U.S.
Shane Barter is a professor of comparative politics at Soka University of America in Aliso Viejo, Calif.
-
Donald Trump Jr. Visited Greenland. Then Things Got Weird.
In a quiet corner of the island, locals suddenly find themselves at the center of a geopolitical power play.The Wall Street Journal - 1d -
Trump threats prompt talk of boosting Greenland security
President-elect Trump’s talk of taking over or acquiring Greenland is highlighting bipartisan talks about the need to increase security around the Arctic island and boost defenses in the region. ...The Hill - 1d -
Danes struggle with response to Trump Greenland threat
Copenhagen's grey winter skies match the mood among politicians and business leaders in the face of a crisis.BBC News - Jan. 9 -
Trump’s Threat to Take Over Greenland Bewilders the Island’s Population
After Donald Trump suggested he might take over Greenland by force, the consensus among the island’s population appears to be bewilderment and anxiety.The New York Times - Jan. 8 -
Germany warns Trump after Greenland takeover threat
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz sent a warning to President-elect Trump over border rules as the incoming president continues his threat of taking over Greenland. Scholz said Wednesday that he spoke ...The Hill - Jan. 8 -
Ros Atkins: Why is Trump talking about annexing Greenland?
The BBC's analysis editor Ros Atkins takes a look at why President-elect Donald Trump is talking about annexing Greenland.BBC News - Jan. 8 -
Why is Donald Trump talking about annexing Greenland?
The US president-elect has refused to rule out military force to take control. This is why it is important – and what Greenlanders think. Hours after his son Donald Trump Jr touched down in the ...The Guardian - Jan. 8 -
Trump ramps up threats to gain control of Greenland and Panama Canal
The president-elect said he would not rule out the use of military force to seize control of the Panama Canal and Greenland.BBC News - Jan. 8 -
‘A snowball’s chance in hell’: Trudeau rejects Trump threat to annex Canada
President-elect threatened to use ‘economic force’ to make northern neighbor part of US. Justin Trudeau has rejected threats from Donald Trump that the US could use “economic force” to annex its ...The Guardian - Jan. 7
More from The Hill
-
Trump's inauguration inching closer: Here's how to watch
President-elect Trump will be inaugurated inside the Capitol Rotunda on Jan. 20 among a of lawmakers, world leaders and allies. The decision to move the event inside the walls of Congress comes as ...The Hill - 49m -
Bans on cell phones in schools grow, but debate thrives on how they are handled
Cell phone bans in school are ramping up as more states consider policies that have been cheered by many educators but still face trepidation from parents. New York and New Jersey are the latest ...The Hill - 59m -
It’s almost Inauguration Day. Will there be any checks on Trump’s power?
The U.S. government's system of checks and balances can withstand attempts at presidential overreach, and the Senate, courts, and civil society must do their part to ensure that the Constitution is ...The Hill - 59m -
Maher slams Los Angeles wildfires response and ‘wokeness’
Comedian Bill Maher slammed the government’s response to the Los Angeles fires and, in part, blamed “wokeness,” for the natural disaster in the region, saying the government’s role is to protect ...The Hill - 1h -
Mexico’s corn policy risks North America’s economic ties
President Sheinbaum’s handling of this issue will define her legacy and Mexico’s role in the region.The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
Trump's inauguration inching closer: Here's how to watch
President-elect Trump will be inaugurated inside the Capitol Rotunda on Jan. 20 among a of lawmakers, world leaders and allies. The decision to move the event inside the walls of Congress comes as ...The Hill - 49m -
It’s almost Inauguration Day. Will there be any checks on Trump’s power?
The U.S. government's system of checks and balances can withstand attempts at presidential overreach, and the Senate, courts, and civil society must do their part to ensure that the Constitution is ...The Hill - 59m -
Bans on cell phones in schools grow, but debate thrives on how they are handled
Cell phone bans in school are ramping up as more states consider policies that have been cheered by many educators but still face trepidation from parents. New York and New Jersey are the latest ...The Hill - 59m -
Maher slams Los Angeles wildfires response and ‘wokeness’
Comedian Bill Maher slammed the government’s response to the Los Angeles fires and, in part, blamed “wokeness,” for the natural disaster in the region, saying the government’s role is to protect ...The Hill - 1h -
Marijuana rescheduling runs into roadblock
A Drug Enforcement Administration (DEA) judge canceled an upcoming hearing on the Biden administration’s marijuana rescheduling proposal pending appeals, effectively kicking the process to the ...The Hill - 1h