Trump’s deregulation push will take more than the stroke of a pen

President-elect Donald Trump’s announcement of Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy’s “Department of Government Efficiency” has put a sharp focus on plans to unwind Biden administration regulations on the environment, the economy and more. Every interest group in Washington has prepared a wish list of regulations they hope to see repealed or spared. But repealing and replacing regulations is not as simple as signing a few executive orders.

Deregulation can be just as cumbersome as regulation, especially if the new administration wants those efforts to survive inevitable legal challenges under the Administrative Procedure Act. For those closely following Trump’s deregulatory agenda, there are several key issues to watch.

As soon as Trump takes office, he will quickly freeze the regulatory process until his appointees get situated. This usually entails a memo from the incoming chief of staff directing federal agencies not to submit new rules for publication in the Federal Register until they are reviewed and approved by a Trump appointee. This “freeze” memo also directs agencies to withdraw submitted but yet-unpublished rules and to postpone by 60 days the effective date of rules not yet in effect.

This traditional move enforces the norm that there is only one president at a time, ensuring that President Biden’s regulatory control ends with his term. But it does not allow Trump to reach back and unwind duly promulgated regulations. For that, he will rely on a different set of tools: the Congressional Review Act, the regulatory process itself and litigation under the Administrative Procedure Act.

Before Trump first took office, the Congressional Review Act of 1996 was on the books but was rarely used. Now it is in its heyday. In simple terms, the CRA allows Congress to disapprove federal regulations by passing a resolution that is not subject to the Senate filibuster but still subject to the president’s veto. It is thus most powerful when the same party controls the White House and Congress, as Republicans did in 2017 and will again this year. Once Congress disapproves a regulation, the CRA dictates that it “may not be reissued in substantially the same form.”

There are limits, however, on using the CRA to unwind regulations. With narrow exceptions, Congress can reach back only to disapprove regulations promulgated in the last several months of the previous administration. Congress will also have a limited window in early 2025 to introduce disapproval resolutions and move them through the process, which burns precious floor time. Congress will use it only for high-priority targets.

But Trump will want to unwind more regulations than the CRA can reach. In most cases, he will use the same rulemaking process to repeal regulations as Biden used to implement them. In 2009, the Supreme Court held in FCC v. Fox Television that federal agencies are generally free to repeal or replace old rules, so long as they acknowledge the change and provide a reasoned justification for the new approach. But interested parties also maintain the same right to sue and challenge a deregulatory action under the Administrative Procedure Act.

To survive judicial scrutiny, the deregulatory action and the agency’s justification cannot be unconstitutional, contrary to statute or arbitrary and capricious. As a prime example, in DHS v. Regents in 2020, the Supreme Court invalidated the Trump administration’s repeal of Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals — not because it disagreed with the attorney general’s conclusion that it was unlawful, but because the acting DHS secretary did not adequately explain the rescission, making it “arbitrary and capricious.”

This time around, the Trump administration will still act to repeal regulations it considers unlawful, but it is less likely to rely solely on that rationale. Expect deregulatory actions to address additional considerations, even when the primary justification for repeal is that a regulation exceeded the agency’s statutory authority. The incentive to do so is even stronger after the Supreme Court’s recent decision in Loper Bright v. Raimondo, since federal courts will no longer afford so-called Chevron deference to a federal agency’s legal interpretation of its own statutory authority.

The final tool is the Administrative Procedure Act itself in cases where private parties have already sued (or will soon sue) to challenge Biden-era regulations. In some instances, the law will authorize agencies to delay the effective date of regulations pending judicial review. But there are unsettled legal questions, such as whether the law allows agencies to delay already-effective rules and what level of justification agencies need to give for the delay.

In many cases, we can expect the Trump administration to switch positions and agree with the challengers that the prior rule was invalid for one reason or another. The first Trump administration switched positions before the Supreme Court on class action waivers and other regulatory issues in 2017, and the Biden administration made similar moves in 2021.

A switch in position is generally not enough on its own for a court to vacate the rule. But particularly in cases where the court has already ruled against a regulation and the Biden administration has a pending appeal, the Trump administration may be able to effectively end the regulation by dropping the appeal.And many courts will pause their cases over Biden-era rules to give the Trump administration time to reconsider them.

Trump has the tools necessary to pursue his deregulatory agenda. It will take a thoughtful and sustained effort to see it through.

John Moran is a partner in the Washington, D.C., office of McGuireWoods LLP. He served on the first Trump presidential transition, as associate White House counsel and as a senior official at the Department of Justice.

Topics

Smaller crypto may gain more than bitcoin after Trump takes office – should you invest?

Altcoins may have more room to rally than bitcoin after the pro-crypto president elect Donald Trump returns to the Oval Office, with his inauguration scheduled on Monday, industry participants said.
MarketWatch - 1d
Trump Media shares jump more than 21% week before presidential inauguration

Tech companies and executives have donated to the Trump inaugural fund, including Google, Meta and Amazon, as well as OpenAI CEO Sam Altman.
CNBC - 5d
The TikTok Ban Is More Likely Than Ever

While Supreme Court justices pressed both sides in Friday’s oral arguments, experts say it’s hard to see how TikTok gets enough votes to survive.
Wired - Jan. 10
As Bitcoin Booms, More and More Companies Are Taking a Stake

Businesses that have nothing to do with crypto still see BTC as a hedge against inflation or a way to entice investors.
Inc. - Jan. 8
Blinken says Trump's push for US to take control of Greenland is 'not going to happen'

Outgoing U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken is advising the world not to waste a lot of time on what President-elect Donald Trump has been saying about Greenland
ABC News - Jan. 8
Trump Has Reeled in More Than $200 Million Since Election Day

The president-elect has boasted about the donations for his inauguration, library and political activities from those seeking favor or perhaps in some cases, atonement.
The New York Times - Jan. 4
U.S. dollar index hits more than two-year high as markets brace for Trump return

Optimism around the U.S. economy was in focus as markets reopened following disrupted trade over Christmas and the New Year's holiday.
CNBC - Jan. 2
Russian forces suffered more than 420,000 casualties taking 1,600 square miles of territory in 2024: ISW

Yahoo News - Jan. 2
The attack was the deadliest in the U.S. in more than a year.

Less than a month ago, New York State authorities charged Luigi Mangione with an act of terrorism in the killing of a health care executive in a shooting in Midtown Manhattan.
The New York Times - Jan. 1

More from The Hill

Donald Trump and the unmooring of patriotism and democracy

Among the reckonings necessary in the wake of Trump’s reelection is jettisoning the notion that patriotism and democracy are synergistic.
The Hill - 40m
Trump expected to quickly revive 'global gag rule' on abortion

President-elect Trump is expected to reinstate a controversial policy soon after taking office that would bar foreign nongovernmental organizations that perform, counsel on or provide information ...
The Hill - 40m
TikTok restoring service to US users

TikTok said Sunday it is "in the process" of restoring service to the U.S., just more than 12 hours after cutting off access to the popular video-sharing platform in anticipation of a ban. “In ...
The Hill - 1h
Live updates: TikTok restoring service to US, Gaza ceasefire begins, Trump to take office

TikTok said on Sunday that it is "in the process" of restoring service in the United States hours after the popular video-sharing platform went dark. President-elect Trump will officially return to ...
The Hill - 1h
A journey through the US reveals a divided nation with much in common

With so much talk about what divides us, people have forgotten what unites this unique assortment of states.
The Hill - 1h

More in Politics

Trump expected to quickly revive 'global gag rule' on abortion

President-elect Trump is expected to reinstate a controversial policy soon after taking office that would bar foreign nongovernmental organizations that perform, counsel on or provide information ...
The Hill - 40m
Donald Trump and the unmooring of patriotism and democracy

Among the reckonings necessary in the wake of Trump’s reelection is jettisoning the notion that patriotism and democracy are synergistic.
The Hill - 40m
Johnson says ‘we will enforce the law’ on TikTok ban, 2 GOP senators break with Trump on extension

Speaker Mike Johnson on Sunday dispelled the notion that President-elect Donald Trump would bring TikTok back early in his second term without the company's willingness to sell to a U.S.-based owner.
NBC News - 48m
TikTok restoring service to US users

TikTok said Sunday it is "in the process" of restoring service to the U.S., just more than 12 hours after cutting off access to the popular video-sharing platform in anticipation of a ban. “In ...
The Hill - 1h
Live updates: TikTok restoring service to US, Gaza ceasefire begins, Trump to take office

TikTok said on Sunday that it is "in the process" of restoring service in the United States hours after the popular video-sharing platform went dark. President-elect Trump will officially return to ...
The Hill - 1h