Trump, Roberts on collision course as lawsuits creep toward Supreme Court

Chief Justice John Roberts is on a collision course with Donald Trump as the president increasingly tests the limits of the judiciary’s role as the most prominent backstop to his administration’s sweeping agenda.

The president stepped up his attacks this week by calling for a judge’s impeachment, earning a rare public rebuke from the chief justice.

Though it marked the most direct spat yet between the duo since Trump retook the White House, the trail ahead appears rougher as the ever-intensifying barrage of litigation against the Trump administration creeps closer to the Supreme Court.

“If Justice Roberts and the United States Supreme Court do not fix this toxic and unprecedented situation IMMEDIATELY, our Country is in very serious trouble!" Trump wrote on Truth Social Thursday.

As the president expresses agitation toward district judges who block his policies nationwide, Trump so far has maintained more cordiality with Roberts, refusing to attack him personally.

“The president respects Chief Justice Roberts overall, he just expressed that to me in the Oval Office,” White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt told reporters Wednesday.

The restraint was notable, given that Trump has no trepidation for lambasting judges who rule against him. Yet he refused to personally chastise Roberts, who had just rebuked the president for calling for the impeachment of U.S. District Judge James Boasberg for ordering the administration to turn around deportation flights last weekend.

The chief justice’s pushback was terse, two sentences in all.

“For more than two centuries, it has been established that impeachment is not an appropriate response to disagreement concerning a judicial decision. The normal appellate review process exists for that purpose,” Roberts wrote.

Retired Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer, who served alongside Roberts for nearly 17 years, said on CNN this week that “every judge is aware of the climate of the era.”

“He's trying to explain to the people of this country how the legal system works and how it doesn't work,” Breyer said of the chief justice’s rebuke. “It doesn't work by impeaching a judge because you don't like his decision. And, by the way, you may be right. The other side may be wrong. There are two sides, usually.”

When asked if the country is nearing a constitutional crisis, Breyer said “no one really knows.”

“People have different views on that. And the best thing, I think, for the judges is you follow the law. You simply follow the law. And that is what they try to do,” he said.

Trump, for his part, has brushed off Roberts’ rebuke by noting the statement didn’t explicitly name him. Trump stood firmly on his calls to impeach the lower judge but declined to go after Roberts.

“He didn’t mention my name in the statement. I just saw it quickly. He didn’t mention my name,” Trump replied in an interview with Fox News’s Laura Ingraham.

Others in Trump’s orbit were also calling for the judge’s impeachment. That Roberts felt the need to speak out at all – whether Trump was named or not – is rare.

Roberts rebuked Trump once before, during his first White House term, when Trump in 2018 assailed a judge as an “Obama judge” for temporarily blocking the administration from refusing to consider asylum applications.

“We do not have Obama judges or Trump judges, Bush judges or Clinton judges. What we have is an extraordinary group of dedicated judges doing their level best to do equal right to those appearing before them. The independent judiciary is something we should all be thankful for,” the chief justice said at the time.

In recent years, Roberts has only spoken out against another prominent politician one other time, when he critiqued Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer’s (D-N.Y.) remarks at a 2020 rally outside the Supreme Court. Schumer told Trump-appointed Justices Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh they “will pay the price” and “won’t know what hit” them as they were inside hearing oral arguments in an abortion case.

During Trump’s first White House term, Roberts often sided with the president, but not always. In 2019, for example, Roberts joined the court’s liberals in refusing to clear the way for the administration to add a citizenship question to the 2020 census.

As Trump makes sweeping moves on the federal bureaucracy, immigration, federal spending and more in his second administration, Roberts may now face his greatest test of all.

The chief justice has long looked to keep the court above the political fray and once famously compared his role to an umpire who calls balls and strikes. Trump, meanwhile, has long accosted judges whenever they have ruled against him as a defendant and as president, often accusing them of being politically biased and part of the “radical left.” Trump has also, at times, invoked some of their family members.

The two men’s starkly different views on judges’ proper role became apparent at Trump’s joint address to Congress earlier this month, when Trump passed Roberts in the front row of the House chamber.

“You did such a great job, thank you…and they’re still talking about it,” Trump told Roberts as he approached the rostrum.

On the way out, Trump similarly told him, “Thank you again, thank you again, won’t forget it,” patting Roberts’ arm.

The chief justice did not appear to say anything in response.

The now-highly scrutinized exchanges prompted speculation among Trump critics that the president was referencing the Supreme Court’s landmark decision carving out broad criminal immunity for former presidents.

In a Truth Social post, the president later insisted he was referring to how the chief justice swore him in at the inauguration and went on to attack “sleazebag 'journalists’” for trying to “create a divide between me and our great U.S. Supreme Court.”

No matter how Roberts perceived it, at the time, he was preparing to rule against Trump.

Days earlier, the administration filed an emergency application with the court seeking to freeze nearly $2 billion in foreign aid payments. The court issued its decision denying the request the morning after Trump’s speech.

Though Roberts joined the court’s liberal justices to side against the administration, he largely was spared from the spotlight. Instead, the online right directed their barrage of criticism toward Justice Amy Coney Barrett, Trump’s third nominee to the court who joined Roberts to form the slim 5-4 majority on the ruling.

But Roberts may not be able to do the same as many of the more than 100 legal challenges filed against major Trump administration directives approach the Supreme Court. Some of the appeals appear designed to prompt Roberts and his conservative colleagues to overturn some of the court’s precedents.

Already, the Justice Department has asked the Supreme Court for an emergency intervention to narrow several judges’ nationwide injunctions blocking Trump’s efforts to restrict birthright citizenship. The court is set to rule after briefings concludes early next month.

And other cases are inching closer to the justices. The Trump administration has signaled a desire to bring a lawsuit filed by Democratic attorneys general over frozen teacher preparation grants to the Supreme Court, and challenges to Trump’s independent agency firings could soon arrive too once an appeals court issues its ruling.

“It’s incumbent upon the Supreme Court to reign in these activist judges. These partisan activists are undermining the judicial branch by doing so,” Leavitt, the White House press secretary, said this week.

Topics

Trump legal battles on high court collision course

Presented by National Council on Aging — Plus: Fallout over Trump team group chat {beacon} Trump legal battles on SCOTUS collision course TWO OF PRESIDENT TRUMP's highest-profile legal battles ...
The Hill - 8h
Trump says Supreme Court justices 'get weak' in lambasting unfavorable coverage

President Trump on Friday lamented that Supreme Court Justices “can’t really fight back” and “get weak” in the face of unfavorable media coverage as he railed against what he framed as "horrible" ...
The Hill - Mar. 14
Princeton professor says he does 'not expect' Trump 'to defy a direct order of the Supreme Court'

Princeton professor Robert P. George said Sunday he does “not expect” President Trump “to defy a direct order of the Supreme Court.” “I do not expect, as some people expect, President Trump, to ...
The Hill - 1d
Breyer defends Roberts, federal judges in Trump feud

Retired Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer defended Chief Justice John Roberts and the federal judiciary, stating that judges should not be influenced by public opinion and that impeachment is ...
The Hill - 5d
Trump on collision course with GOP defense hawks over NATO

President Trump is on a collision course with Republican defense hawks over the question of whether the United States should continue its 75-year military leadership of NATO and at what level of ...
The Hill - 3d
John Roberts made Trump’s authoritarianism possible. He could still save his own legacy | Steven Greenhouse

The supreme court judge has emboldened and enabled Trump, but the president’s second term must surely have him worried. John Roberts , chief justice of the US supreme court, should be very worried ...
The Guardian - 6d
The Memo: Roberts rebukes Trump in latest twist of White House battle with judiciary

Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts issued a clear, if implicit, rebuke of President Trump on Tuesday, intensifying a clash between the White House and the judiciary. The Trump administration, ...
The Hill - 6d
Top US Supreme Court justice rebukes Trump's call to impeach judge

Chief Justice John Roberts issued a rare statement after Trump called for a judge that halted his deportations to be impeached.
BBC News - 6d
Roberts rebukes Trump, allies over attacks against federal judge

Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts has issued a rare statement rebuking a push to impeach judges, hours after President Trump echoed such calls amid a clash with a federal judge over migrant ...
The Hill - 6d
Trump brings birthright citizenship argument to Supreme Court

The Trump administration asked the Supreme Court for an emergency intervention Thursday limiting lower court rulings that are blocking President Trump's plans to restrict birthright citizenship. ...
The Hill - Mar. 13
Supreme Court Will Not Hear Appeal in ‘Juliana’ Climate Case

The Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal in the long-running case, known as Juliana, which helped spawn legal strategies widely adapted to other lawsuits over climate.
The New York Times - 4h
Supreme Court Will Not Hear Appeal in ‘Juliana’ Climate Case

The Supreme Court declined to hear an appeal in the long-running case, known as Juliana, which helped spawn legal strategies widely adapted to other lawsuits over climate.
The New York Times - 4h
Supreme Court turns away bid to block state climate change lawsuits

A group of Republican-led states sought to block lawsuits brought by a group of Democratic-led states that seek to hold energy companies accountable for climate change.
CBS News - Mar. 10
Live updates: Musk's USAID actions ruled 'likely' unlawful; Roberts pushes back on Trump's call for judge's impeachment

Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts issued a rare rebuke of President Trump on Tuesday amid an escalating battle between the executive and judicial branches of government over the president's ...
The Hill - 6d
Trump asks Supreme Court to intervene on blocks to his birthright citizenship order

The Trump administration is asking the Supreme Court to significantly narrow nationwide injunctions blocking his order redefining birthright citizenship in the U.S.
ABC News - Mar. 14
Trump asks Supreme Court to block reinstatement of fired probationary employees

The Trump administration has asked the Supreme Court for an emergency stay of a judge's order that 16,000 terminated federal probationary employees be reinstated.
ABC News - 12h
Trump asks Supreme Court to intervene in birthright citizenship cases

The Trump administration asked the Supreme Court to limit three lower court orders that blocked enforcement of his birthright citizenship executive order nationwide.
CBS News - Mar. 13
Trump asks Supreme Court to pause reinstatement of some workers

The Trump administration asked the Supreme Court to pause a lower court decision requiring six agencies to reinstate more than 16,000 federal probationary workers.
CBS News - 12h
Trump asks Supreme Court to pause reinstatement of some workers

The Trump administration asked the Supreme Court to pause a lower court decision requiring six agencies to reinstate more than 16,000 federal probationary workers.
CBS News - 12h
Trump asks Supreme Court to pause reinstatement of some workers

The Trump administration asked the Supreme Court to pause a lower court decision requiring six agencies to reinstate more than 16,000 federal probationary workers.
CBS News - 12h
Supreme Court declines Steve Wynn’s bid to loosen libel standard

The Supreme Court on Monday turned away casino mogul Steve Wynn’s bid for the court to consider overturning its 61-year-old precedent that has protected journalists from libel lawsuits. Wynn urged ...
The Hill - 16h
Trump asks Supreme Court to take up birthright citizenship plan

The Trump administration wants the Supreme Court to limit the scope of lower court rulings against his executive order that would end automatic birthright citizenship. NBC News' Lawrence Hurley ...
NBC News - Mar. 13
Trump takes his plan to end birthright citizenship to the Supreme Court

WASHINGTON — The Trump administration asked the Supreme Court on Thursday to narrow nationwide injunctions that have blocked the president’s plan to end automatic birthright citizenship.
NBC News - Mar. 13
Trump endorses Schimel in high-stakes Wisconsin Supreme Court race

President Trump became the highest profile politician to weigh in on the Wisconsin Supreme Court race late Friday, urging his supporters to back conservative candidate Brad Schimel. Trump in a late ...
The Hill - 2d
Trump administration asks Supreme Court to intervene in rehiring of federal workers

The Trump administration Monday asked the Supreme Court to block an order forcing the government to rehire thousands of workers fired as part of President Trump’s effort to drastically reduce the ...
The Hill - 13h
Trump’s Birthright Citizenship Order Reaches the Supreme Court

Trump administration lawyers asked the justices to limit the sweep of decisions by three lower courts that issued nationwide pauses on the policy.
The New York Times - Mar. 13
Wisconsin Supreme Court candidates to debate about Trump, Musk and key issues

A closely watched Wisconsin Supreme Court election takes center stage as Republican-backed Brad Schimel and Democratic-backed Susan Crawford are set to debate.
ABC News - Mar. 12
Brad Schimel, a Trump Loyalist, Aims to Flip Wisconsin’s Supreme Court

Brad Schimel, a judge who is so supportive of the president that he dressed up as him for Halloween, is hoping to flip the Wisconsin Supreme Court for conservatives.
The New York Times - Mar. 13
Supreme Court won't take up challenge to landmark defamation case

The Supreme Court on Monday declined to take up a case brought by casino mogul and Trump donor Steve Wynn that would have challenged a landmark decision.
CBS News - 13h
With mass rehirings ordered and a plea to the Supreme Court, Trump's court fights scale new heights

Judges this week ordered the government to reinstate thousands of workers, while the administration turned to the Supreme Court for help rolling back judicial powers.
NBC News - Mar. 14
White House locks horns with judiciary over deportations

The Trump administration is on a collision course with the courts after a week spent taunting a federal judge and escalating a battle over whether his orders have been defied. ...
The Hill - 2d
The Roberts court is America's last safeguard against Trump’s tyranny

How will history judge the nation's highest court?
The Hill - Mar. 10
Trump responds to chief justice's rebuke over call to impeach judge

As several of President Donald Trump’s efforts to shrink and reshape the federal government are being blocked in the courts, Chief Justice of the Supreme Court John Roberts released a rare ...
NBC News - 5d
Wisconsin Supreme Court candidates spar on abortion law, Musk, Trump during debate

Wisconsin Supreme Court candidates Brad Schimel and Susan Crawford sparred over abortion law, as well as Elon Musk, during a debate.
ABC News - Mar. 13
Sanders: Roberts knows ‘the danger of a president' who doesn't 'respect the Constitution'

Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-Vt.) said Tuesday that he believes Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts knows “the danger of a president” who doesn’t “respect the Constitution” after pushback from ...
The Hill - 6d
‘Nothing like this in American history’: the crisis of Trump’s assault on the rule of law

Even if the supreme court were to resist the president’s onslaught, it has little means to enforce its decisions. When the chief justice of the US supreme court , John Roberts, delivered his ...
The Guardian - Mar. 9
Judge denies Pulitzer board’s request to pause Trump lawsuit during presidency

A Florida judge Monday denied the Pulitzer Prize Board’s request to pause President Trump’s defamation lawsuit while he is in the White House, an argument Trump’s lawyers themselves have made in ...
The Hill - Mar. 11
Supreme Court turns down Trump donor Steve Wynn's bid to overturn libel precedent

The Supreme Court turned away a bid by top Republican donor and former casino magnate Steve Wynn to undermine legal protections for news companies facing defamation suits.
NBC News - 14h
Supreme Court turns down Trump donor Steve Wynn's bid to overturn libel precedent

The Supreme Court turned away a bid by top Republican donor and former casino magnate Steve Wynn to undermine legal protections for news companies facing defamation suits.
NBC News - 14h