Trump resistance media 2.0: Like the original, but even more obtuse

There will be no reckoning in U.S. media for having once again greatly underestimated President Trump’s chances of electoral victory. And there will be no widespread effort by legacy media to understand better the electorate that moved to the right in November.

CBS News’s programming last weekend already suggested as much.

In an address in Munich on Jan. 14, Vice President JD Vance told European leaders that they’ve grown dangerously illiberal, citing as an example Scotland’s “buffer zone” law barring pro-life activists from demonstrating or praying within 600-plus feet of abortion clinics.

“[L]ast October,” he said, “the Scottish government began distributing letters to citizens whose houses lay within so-called ‘safe access zones,’ warning them that even private prayer within their own homes may amount to breaking the law.”

“In Britain and across Europe, free speech, I fear, is in retreat,” he said.

Love him or hate him, the man has a point, although many American journalists will tell you otherwise. The way they see it, the vice president is guilty of spreading “disinformation” regarding the Scottish law. Also, for some reason, these beneficiaries of our First Amendment believe that free speech should not be as free as Vance suggests.

This is our Fourth Estate, ladies and gentlemen.

First of all, the Scottish government did send letters in 2024 before enacting the “buffer zone” law, warning residents within designated zones that they could be prosecuted for engaging in pro-life activities within their own homes.

"In general, the offenses apply in public places within the Safe Access Zones,” the letter read. “However, activities in a private place (such as a house) within the area between the protected premises and the boundary of a Zone could be an offense if they can be seen or heard within the Zone and done intentionally or recklessly."

So, Vance was correct — these letters were sent. If you stand at your window and pray within one of these zones, it seems to say, you might get a visit from the police. And Rachael Clarke of the British Pregnancy Advisory Service seemed to confirm as much with her non-denial denial of this.

"Absolutely none of us [wanted the law to include] having a private conversation in your own house,” she said. "However” — a mighty big however — “you can use a private dwelling or another private building in order to have exactly the same effect as if those people [stood] on a public highway.”

Scotland’s “buffer zone” laws are truly outrageous and would never be allowed in the U.S. But as bad as the American media's knee-jerk defense of these laws was, it paled in comparison to CBS’s exaltation of Germany’s draconian censorship laws.

This began when CBS anchor Margaret Brennan asserted, falsely, that freedom of speech had paved the way to the Holocaust.

Vance, she said, “was standing in a country where free speech was weaponized to conduct a genocide."

Germany's Nazi Party was known for many things — book burning and street violence against Jews, for example — but advocacy for free and open political speech was never one of them. What Brennan ignorantly suggested is colloquially referred to as the "Weimar Fallacy." It’s not an obscure theory; it’s quite well known.

Later that same weekend, CBS highlighted Germany’s anti-speech laws, reporting approvingly on a “pre-dawn wakeup call” wherein law enforcement officials stormed a private residence over the posting of a supposedly offensive cartoon. Without a hint of reservation or concern, CBS noted approvingly that more than 50 such raids were occurring that moment all over Germany. Of 16 units tasked with policing online speech, one was investigating at least 3,500 cases, CBS reported.

Throughout the segment,"60 Minutes" correspondent Sharyn Alfonsi is seen mugging and laughing with German authorities as they detail their surveillance and censorship efforts, including the hotlines they created so that citizens could denounce their neighbors.

The segment even included comments from Josephine Ballon, CEO of a German nonprofit called HateAid, which purports to promote “human rights in the digital space and fight against digital violence." Ballon notes that Germans have grown fearful of expressing political opinions online. But laughably she attributes this fear to online trolls rather than the threat of prosecution or pre-dawn police raids against those expressing disapproved opinions.

Nowhere in the CBS segment is it suggested that Germany has gone too far or that its efforts are extreme. Censorship is presented as a net positive. Meanwhile, the American vice president was portrayed elsewhere on the network as a villain for pointing out that Europe’s commitment to freedom of speech has been somewhat lacking.

This is just one more sign of what the media will look like in Trump 2.0. Major outlets won't make much effort to understand or convey the perspective of the majority that voted to put Trump back into the White House. There will be no reckoning or retrospective by anchors, journalists or editors to understand how they missed Trump’s victory not once but twice.

Instead, we will see another four years of full-on anti-Trump resistance. If you thought the descent into political advocacy was terrible following Trump’s defeat of Hillary Clinton, you ain't seen nothin' yet.

Becket Adams is a writer in Washington and program director for the National Journalism Center.

Topics

2/20: CBS Evening News

Woman uproots life to take job as federal worker, then fired in mass layoffs weeks later; Supporters gather to pray for Pope Francis outside hospital
CBS News - 3d
In foreign policy, Trump needs to be more like Reagan, less like Biden

The Biden administration's reluctance to take action against Russia in Ukraine has been criticized, while Trump's new Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has made similar rookie mistakes, potentially ...
The Hill - 1d
Avowed Was Originally Pitched With Multiplayer Like Destiny Mixed With Skyrim

Avowed was originally going to have multiplayer components, similar to that of Destiny where players could walk around in a massive world.. In an interview with Bloomberg , director Carrie Patel ...
GameSpot - 2d
Denise Cheung, the US prosecutor resisting Trump

A lifetime public servant, the by-the-book lawyer is the latest to defend the integrity of an increasingly imperilled justice system
Financial Times - 2d
JD Vance thinks AI will uplift Americans — It’s more likely to erase them

AI is rapidly replacing human labor. It is surpassing humans at an exponential rate, with implications that are staggering, and the implications of this are far from utopian, with AI coming for ...
The Hill - 2d
Trump says he's weighing giving 20% of DOGE savings to Americans

President Donald Trump revealed Wednesday that he's considering sending 20% of the money saved by the Department of Government Efficiency to Americans.
CNBC - 4d
Many Americans don't trust the media to cover Trump: Survey

Most Americans in a new survey said they have little confidence that the news media can cover President Trump with fairness and accuracy. The YouGov poll, published Friday, found that 67 percent of ...
The Hill - 1d
Leavitt says media has been 'blinded' by 'anti-Trump bias'

White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt on Saturday said journalists at mainstream media outlets bring "preconceived narrative and bias” against President Trump to the briefing room. In an ...
The Hill - 23h
Tennis participation grows to more than 25M players in the US even as pickleball's popularity surges

The U.S. Tennis Association says participation in the sport around the United States rose to 25.7 million players in 2024
ABC News - 5d
Trump Marks Black History Month, Even as He Disparages Value of Diversity

President Trump arrived at a packed White House celebration alongside Tiger Woods to a roaring crowd. The event came as he has eviscerated federal programs aimed at combating inequality in America.
The New York Times - 3d
Even ‘Real Housewives’ Star Erin Lichy Is Preparing for Trump’s Tariffs

The serial entrepreneur talks the growth of her mezcal brand Mezcalum and why she’s never bootstrapping a business again.
Inc. - 2d
Neuroscience Says 2 Minutes a Day Can Make You Less Stressed, More Focused, and Even Increase the Size of Your Brain

Too busy for self care? This type of (in)activity provides clear cognitive benefits.
Inc. - 4d
Celsius wants to sell more energy drinks to women. Wall Street likes the move.

Celsius shares are up more than 30% after its quarterly results topped estimates and it announced plans to buy drink maker Alani Nu.
MarketWatch - 2d
The ‘Gulf of America’ feud is about something bigger: Trump wants to control the media | Margaret Sullivan

The president punished the AP for choosing its own language, but that’s just the tip of the iceberg. The press must show unity. It might seem like a small matter, just a disagreement over whether a ...
The Guardian - 3d
‘We have nothing now’: Myanmar’s exiled media face existential crisis after Trump severs aid

Organisations that take extreme risks to document atrocities, corruption and war crimes fear for their future after USAid cuts. Each month Su Myat secretly crosses the border from Thailand into ...
The Guardian - 17h
‘Like a cruel auction’: what Ukrainians think of Trump’s peace talks with Putin

Ukrainians inside the country and abroad express their hopelessness, anger and defiance at negotiations between Washington and Moscow. Europe live – latest updates “I don’t think that this ...
The Guardian - 3d
Trump suggests Musk needs to be 'more aggressive'

President Trump suggested in a new post that tech billionaire Elon Musk, one of his closest allies, needs to be “more aggressive" — presumably referring to his efforts to slash spending, downsize ...
The Hill - 1d
Trump Administration Moves More Migrants to Guantánamo Bay

The base had been cleared of migrants since Thursday, after the government sent 177 to Venezuela and one back to the United States.
The New York Times - 14h
Whole Hog Politics: Democrats learn the limits of resistance

On the menu: COVID-19 at root of Gen Z move to the right; Vivek readies battle for Ohio; Kemp brushes back Greene; A very big fish story It may be fitting that President Trump has been in a ...
The Hill - 3d
Trump backs Rep. Byron Donalds in his likely run for Florida governor in 2026

President Donald Trump on Thursday publicly supported Republican Rep. Byron Donalds' likely bid for Florida governor in 2026.
NBC News - 3d
Boosted by Musk and Trump, German far-right party looks likely to make historic gains

It is a pivotal moment for Germany's far-right AfD ahead of national elections Sunday. The party is polling at 21% — likely enough for second place.
NBC News - 3d
Roy Wood Jr. on Trump, unity, personal connection and more

Comedian Roy Wood Jr., host of "Have I Got News For You," joined CBS News to discuss President Trump, his latest comedy special, the state of the world and more.
CBS News - 3d
Under Trump, D.C. Faces More Federal Control, Fewer Federal Workers

The Washington region is bracing for a shock to the local economy from President Trump and Elon Musk’s sweeping cuts to the government work force.
The New York Times - 2d
Viktor Orbán's political director on Trump, Bannon's CPAC salute and more

Many well-known figures in conservative politics are delivering remarks at this year's CPAC, and not all are from the U.S. Balázs Orbán, political director and adviser to Hungarian Prime Minister ...
CBS News - 2d
Frustrated Democrats Urge Leaders to Show More Fight Against Trump

Voters, activists and even some governors, like Josh Shapiro of Pennsylvania, are growing exasperated with congressional Democrats’ restrained approach.
The New York Times - 2d
Reese posts Unrivaled's first 20-20 game in win

Angel Reese recorded the first 20-20 game in Unrivaled history as the Rose handed the Owls their first loss of the season.
ESPN - 1d
2/19: CBS Evening News

Global implications of Trump's public criticism of Zelenskyy; Historic SS United States makes final voyage before being turned into reef
CBS News - 4d
2/21: CBS Evening News

IRS employee among those fired by Trump during tax season speaks out; Couple takes in Senegalese high school basketball player left homeless by private school closure
CBS News - 2d
TurboTax Discount Codes: 20% Off | February 2025

Tax season doesn’t have to be stressful. Save up to $50 with TurboTax coupons right here on WIRED.
Wired - 4d
The 20 Best Barefoot Shoes for Running or Walking (2025)

Our favorite zero-drop, minimalist footwear will let you feel the ground beneath your feet.
Wired - 22h
Trump to sign more executive orders today, despite legal pushback on several of his directives

Trump is slated to sign more executive orders this afternoon. Several of his directives have already faced pushback during his first month in office.
NBC News - 3d
Trump touts DOGE cuts at CPAC as he tells Elon Musk to 'get more aggressive'

Trump is scheduled to deliver remarks today at the Conservative Political Action Conference. He's spoken at the conference every year since 2016.
NBC News - 2d
What it's like to live in Greenland

Yahoo News - 1d
Evening Report — Hegseth moves to shake up Pentagon

{beacon} Evening Report TRUMP FIRST 100 DAYS © Virginia Mayo, Associated Press Hegseth moves to shake up the Pentagon DEFENSE SECRETARY PETE HEGSETH is moving to overhaul the Pentagon through ...
The Hill - 2d
2/21: CBS Evening News Plus

Why Republicans are at odds about how to fund the government; Yankees finally permits players to sport full beards
CBS News - 2d
'Conclave' wins big at SAG Awards; Jane Fonda’s speech offers a moment of political resistance

The papal thriller “Conclave” won best ensemble and Timothée Chalamet took best actor at the 31st Screen Actors Guild Awards on Sunday, a pair of twists that added a few final wrinkles to an ...
NBC News - 10h
Oscars flashback: Documentaries about children prevailed 20 years ago

'Born Into Brothels' and a short about children marching during the civil rights era won Oscar gold in 2005.
Los Angeles Times - 5d
Right-Wing Media Praises U.S.-Russia Talks as ‘Breath of Fresh Air’

Many of President Trump’s media allies were quick to celebrate this week’s negotiations, a contrast to the deep unease expressed by the foreign policy establishment.
The New York Times - 4d
ChatGPT-generated op-eds appeared in mainstream Latin American media outlets

Chinese propagandists used ChatGPT to write and translate op-eds that they successfully planted in Spanish-language news outlets last fall, researchers said Friday.
NBC News - 3d