The solicitor general’s misguided endorsement of state-driven climate lawsuits
In her final weeks as U.S. solicitor general, Elizabeth Prelogar filed amicus briefs urging the Supreme Court to allow climate lawsuits, particularly one brought by Honolulu, to proceed under state tort law. This stance is ill-advised and inconsistent with the positions taken by past attorneys general, Democrat and Republican alike.
Climate change issues, by Supreme Court precedent, are fundamentally regulated by federal law under the Clean Air and Clean Water acts. Further, leaving a patchwork of state laws to address this issue will only jeopardize energy security. It is imperative for the Supreme Court to grant certiorari in the Honolulu case to ensure this baseless campaign of climate tort litigation does not undermine U.S. energy policy.
Not long ago, there was broad consensus that climate change litigation was a matter of federal law. As recently as 2011, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg, rarely considered a friend of the fossil fuel industry, rejected global warming tort claims made by several states in her opinion for a unanimous Supreme Court in AEP v. Connecticut decision. President Barack Obama’s solicitor general, Neil Katyal, took a similar approach in a 2010 brief: “In the context of climate change, a regulatory solution will be far better suited to addressing the scope of the problem and to fashioning an appropriately tailored set of remedies than a potentially open-ended series of common-law suits in far-flung district courts.”
Likewise, former President Donald Trump’s solicitor general, Jeffrey Wall, argued in a 2020 brief that climate change was a matter where federal law should apply. DOJ lawyers later explained that climate change was “inherently federal” because the alleged harms are “caused by emissions from all over the world, and those emissions just can't be subjected to potentially conflicting regulations by every state and city affected by global warming.”
The top Justice department lawyers from the Obama and Trump administrations were standing on solid precedent. For over a century, the Supreme Court has held that interstate pollution must be governed by federal — not state — laws. The states have a role to play, to be sure, in setting environmental policies within their boundaries.
There are state laws across the country that protect air, water, biodiversity and critical habitats from environmental harm. But the plaintiffs suing U.S. energy companies under state laws are seeking damages for injuries they allege are caused by the cumulative impact of emissions emanating from every state in the U.S. and every country in the world. This far-reaching assertion is itself an admission that the claim is an interstate one, so federal law should reign.
Beyond that, energy security is intrinsically linked to national security. As I've written elsewhere, the U.S. will lose its status as global leader in advanced technologies without dependable energy sources. Europe’s reliance on Russian energy is a stark warning to those who downplay the importance of national energy independence.
If U.S. energy policy is set by piecemeal litigation under state laws, we can expect to rely on more energy imports from foreign sources as domestic energy producers flee hostile jurisdictions. This means both fewer jobs and higher costs to consumers and businesses, something which the attorneys organizing these suits openly admit is one of their goals.
The energy companies are not exaggerating when they write in their Supreme Court brief that there are few cases of “such extraordinary importance to one of the nation’s most vital industries.” The solicitor general’s endorsement of these lawsuits to proceed under state tort law has far-reaching implications. The previous two administrations got it right: Climate change is a federal issue necessitating a coordinated response. The Supreme Court should grant certiorari to settle, once and for all, that when it comes to climate change, federal law applies.
Michael Toth is a founding partner of PNT Law, based in Austin, Texas.
-
‘Ironic’: climate-driven sea level rise will overwhelm major oil ports, study shows
Ports including in Saudi Arabia and the US projected to be seriously damaged by a metre of sea level rise. Rising sea levels driven by the climate crisis will overwhelm many of the world’s biggest ...The Guardian - 18h -
TikTok knew its livestreaming feature allowed child exploitation, state lawsuit alleges
Company’s own inquiry found money laundering and children performing sexualized acts for digital currency. TikTok has long been aware that its video livestream feature has been misused to harm ...The Guardian - 9h -
Will Trump's endorsement be enough for Mike Johnson to remain House speaker?
Mike Johnson may face Republican resistance in his quest to retain the House speakership. This comes after President-elect Donald Trump endorsed Johnson's bid. CBS News' Taurean Small and Ed ...CBS News - 1d -
Transcript: Climate change is coming for your Bordeaux
Sonja Hutson talks to Will Schmitt and Susannah SavageFinancial Times - 1d -
Morgan Stanley to exit global climate coalition
Morgan Stanley on Thursday announced its departure from a coalition of banks that aims to target net-zero emissions through lending and investment, the fifth group to do so in recent weeks. “Morgan ...The Hill - 2d -
Trump endorses Mike Johnson to remain as House Speaker
President-elect Trump rang in the new year at his Mar-a-Lago home, less than three weeks before Inauguration Day, telling reporters that he would attend President Carter’s funeral and reiterated ...NBC News - 3d -
Showdown over House Speaker after Trump endorses Johnson
Even though President-elect Trump has endorsed him, House Speaker Mike Johnson faces a showdown over whether he will continue in the role. A vote is scheduled in the House on Friday. NBC News' Gabe ...NBC News - 4d -
Trump endorses Johnson for speaker
Politico - 5d
More from The Hill
-
Kinzinger on 'changed' GOP: 'I'm probably closer to a Democrat now'
Former Rep. Adam Kinzinger (R-Ill.) reflected on the “changed” Republican Party, saying he finds himself being “probably closer to a Democrat now” politically, arguing the Democratic Party is ...The Hill - 25m -
Trump flexes power over House GOP in whirlwind Speaker race
President-elect Trump reasserted his power over the House GOP conference during Friday’s whirlwind Speaker vote, proving that, despite some recent doubts, he still has significant sway over ...The Hill - 1h -
German chancellor on Musk: ‘Don’t feed the troll’
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz shared his approach to dealing with tech mogul Elon Musk who lately has traded barbs with German politicians, saying it is wise to not “feed the troll.” “There are a ...The Hill - 2h -
Democrats look for places to work with Trump 2.0
Democrats say one thing is certain: 2025 won't be 2017, when it comes to the start of the Trump administration. Two months after their grueling and disappointing White House loss to ...The Hill - 2h -
Ex-FDA chief says Biden 'mishandling' bird flu, urges swift action from Trump
Former commissioner of the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) Scott Gottlieb and Luciana Borio, a former director for medical and biodefense preparedness policy at the National Security Council, ...The Hill - 3h
More in Politics
-
Biden to deliver two major speeches in his final days in office
President Joe Biden plans to deliver two major speeches before leaving office as part of an effort to outline what he sees as key parts of his legacy from more than 50 years in public service, ...NBC News - 3m -
Kinzinger on 'changed' GOP: 'I'm probably closer to a Democrat now'
Former Rep. Adam Kinzinger (R-Ill.) reflected on the “changed” Republican Party, saying he finds himself being “probably closer to a Democrat now” politically, arguing the Democratic Party is ...The Hill - 25m -
Biden honors 19 politicians, philanthropists, cultural icons with Presidential Medal of Freedom
President Biden awarded the nation’s highest civilian honor to more than a dozen politicians, philanthropists and cultural icons during a ceremony at the White House Saturday. Nineteen people ...NBC News - 38m -
Trump flexes power over House GOP in whirlwind Speaker race
President-elect Trump reasserted his power over the House GOP conference during Friday’s whirlwind Speaker vote, proving that, despite some recent doubts, he still has significant sway over ...The Hill - 1h -
German chancellor on Musk: ‘Don’t feed the troll’
German Chancellor Olaf Scholz shared his approach to dealing with tech mogul Elon Musk who lately has traded barbs with German politicians, saying it is wise to not “feed the troll.” “There are a ...The Hill - 2h