Supreme Court won't hear arguments in Texas emergency abortion case
The Supreme Court decided not to hear arguments in a case involving Texas that could have provided an answer about whether a state abortion ban conflicts with a federal emergency care law.
The decision is a significant victory for Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton (R) and comes just three months after the court dismissed a similar case involving Idaho, a move that was criticized as a preelection punt that offered no clarity on the issue.
Dismissing the Idaho case did not resolve the underlying legal questions, so the decision not to hear arguments in the Texas case was unexpected.
The dismissal came under fire not just from abortion-rights activists and physicians but also Justices Samuel Alito and Ketanji Brown Jackson.
Both argued, for different reasons, that the court should have ruled on the merits.
The Texas case centers on the Emergency Medical Treatment and Labor Act (EMTALA), which requires federally funded hospitals to provide stabilizing care to emergency room patients no matter their ability to pay.
The Biden administration invoked EMTALA in the wake of the Supreme Court decision that overturned Roe v. Wade. The administration said state laws or mandates that employ a more restrictive definition of an emergency medical condition are preempted by the federal statute.
Texas sued the administration shortly after the guidance was issued, arguing the law was improperly applied, and the administration did not follow the appropriate rulemaking process.
A lower court ruled in favor of Texas, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit agreed.
The court said the administration’s guidance was improperly issued. The panel held that EMTALA does not require any particular care and never requires pregnancy termination. The court, considered the most conservative in the country, ruled EMTALA does not govern the practice of medicine.
Further, the court said there is no direct conflict between EMTALA and the Texas abortion law. Texas bans abortions in almost all circumstances, but there are exceptions for when there is a life-threatening condition that places the mother at risk of death or “substantial impairment of a major bodily function.”
In asking the Supreme Court not to hear arguments, Texas insisted the case was merely about how the administration issued the EMTALA guidance, rather than the substance of the law itself.
In the earlier case, the Biden administration sued Idaho over its abortion ban, arguing it conflicted with EMTALA. But in this case, Texas sued the Department of Health and Human Services.
“This is not the case the federal government says it is,” the state said in its brief. “The United States has erased two years of litigation history and transformed this case from one about whether the executive branch complied with administrative-law requirements to one about whether the State of Texas has complied with constitutional demands.”
Date: | |
Tag: | Abortion |
-
Top stories - CBS News
Supreme Court won't decide Texas dispute over emergency abortions
In turning away the case, the Supreme Court leaves in place a lower court order that blocked emergency abortion care if it violates Texas' near-total ban.1 hour ago - Abortion -
Health - ABC News
Supreme Court declines Biden administration appeal in Texas emergency abortion case
Court let stand decision barring emergency abortions that violate law in Texas.36 minutes ago - Joe Biden -
Top stories - ABC News
Supreme Court won't hear appeal from Elon Musk’s X platform over warrant in Trump case
Prosecutors got search warrant in the election-interference case against Trump.1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - CBS News
Supreme Court won't hear dispute involving Jack Smith and Trump's X data
Special counsel Jack Smith obtained in January 2023 a court-authorized warrant for information associated with former President Donald Trump's X account as part of its election interference probe.2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Top stories - CBS News
Supreme Court convenes for new term, here's a look at some of the cases they're hearing
The U.S. Supreme Court is reconvening for its new session Monday. The court's docket includes cases dealing with the regulation of so-called ghost guns and the controversial concept of medical ...26 minutes ago -
Business - Inc.
Supreme Court Will Tackle Workplace Discrimination Case This Term
The high court’s docket includes cases that could recast the threshold for hiring bias claims, as well as suits addressing guns, transgender rights and online pornography.1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
Supreme Court declines to take up ‘dark money’ case
The Supreme Court on Monday declined to take up a challenge to San Francisco’s "Sunlight on Dark Money" disclosure law, which would have tested the limits of disclosure and free speech in campaign ...2 hours ago -
Entertainment - ABC News
Supreme Court declines to hear appeal from singer R. Kelly, convicted of child sex crimes
The Supreme Court has declined to hear an appeal from the singer R. Kelly, who is now serving 20 years in prison after being convicted of child sex convictions in Chicago2 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Democrats accuse food, beverage companies of ‘profiteering’ through ‘shrinkflation’
Two Democratic lawmakers have sent a letter to some of the country’s biggest food and beverage companies arguing they are “profiteering” through “shrinkflation,” the practice of reducing product ...51 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
The imagined national debt crisis: A long-running distraction
Republicans in the House of Representatives threatened to shut down the government in September 2024 in order to reduce the national debt, but Democrats bailed them out, recognizing that closing ...59 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Trump says son Barron heard about assassination attempt on tennis court
Former President Trump said his youngest son, Barron, was playing tennis when he learned in July that his father had been shot at the Butler, Pa. rally. Trump recounted the experience in a sit-down ...1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Musk-founded PAC says it will give $47 for every swing-state voter referral who signs petition
The America PAC, founded by tech billionaire Elon Musk, is asking the public to sign a petition in favor of the First and Second Amendments and offering supporters $47 for each subsequent ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
US spending on Middle East conflict tops $22B since Oct. 7: Research
The United States government has spent more than $22 billion on fighting the conflict in the Middle East since war erupted a year ago on Oct. 7, 2023, according to new research. The Costs of War ...1 hour ago