Supreme Court turns away challenge to consumer safety agency’s structure
The Supreme Court announced Monday it won’t take up a case that could have delivered another blow to federal agencies.
Two conservative groups sought to challenge the structure of the Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC), which oversees making sure the country’s consumer products are safe.
At issue were protections preventing the president from firing any of the agency’s five commissioners, except for neglect of duty or malfeasance.
“For the CPSC, with great power comes great unaccountability,” the groups wrote in their high court petition.
The Supreme Court refused to take up the case in a brief order without any noted dissents, as is typical.
The groups’ request was backed by 11 Republican lawmakers — including Sens. Ted Cruz (Texas) and Mike Lee (Utah) — 16 Republican state attorneys general, the Chamber of Commerce and various libertarian think tanks.
But the Biden administration warned the Supreme Court against accepting their arguments, saying it could invalidate similar setups of other federal agencies.
"That is not a tenable reading of this Court’s precedent," U.S. Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar wrote in court filings.
The CPSC, established in 1972, is empowered by Congress to ban hazardous products, issue recalls and seek fines for violations.
Consumers’ Research and By Two, which brand themselves as “educational organizations,” challenged the agency’s setup by suing over records requests the groups made under the Freedom of Information Act.
A district judge agreed that the commissioners’ for-cause removal protections ran afoul of the separation of powers. A divided panel of the 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals reversed the decision, leading the groups to appeal to the Supreme Court.
The Biden administration urged the high court to turn away the case, arguing the groups did not have legal standing to bring their weighty challenge and calling their suit “highly artificial.”
“It would disserve that principle to allow petitioners to leverage a 5¢ increase in photocopying fees into a vehicle for seeking to effectively overrule a 90-year-old precedent and invalidate dozens of federal statutes,” Prelogar wrote.
The case stood to add to several striking blows the Supreme Court has delivered against the federal bureaucracy in recent terms amid a widespread push from conservative and libertarian interests in recent years to dismantle the "administrative state."
The plaintiffs were represented by former Trump White House counsel Don McGahn, a Jones Day attorney who has long-standing ties to the conservative Federalist Society.
“If allowed to stand, the Fifth Circuit’s decision will further entrench an unaccountable Fourth Branch— one that rules Americans without having to answer to them,” McGahn wrote in the petition.
“But the Founders did not fight a revolution so that their descendants could live under the dictates of unelected commissioners and tenured bureaucrats,” he continued. “And this Court’s precedent does not substitute a technocracy for the Founders’ vision.”
Date: |
-
Top stories - CBS News
Supreme Court won't hear challenge to Consumer Product Safety Commission
7 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
Supreme Court turns away self-proclaimed Republican’s defense in claiming party’s support
6 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
Supreme Court to consider which courts can weigh challenges to some EPA actions
4 hours ago -
Tech - The New York Times
Tesla Self-Driving System Will Be Investigated by Safety Agency
3 days ago - Tesla -
Politics - The Hill
Supreme Court turns down Michael Avenatti’s appeal of Stormy Daniels identity theft conviction
6 days ago -
Top stories - CBS News
Supreme Court turns down Michael Cohen's bid to revive suit against Trump
7 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Tech - ABC News
US agency adopts rule to make it easier for consumers to cancel unwanted subscriptions
4 days ago -
Politics - The Hill
The Supreme Court’s blockbuster gun case is a shot at redemption
6 days ago -
Top stories - The New York Times
Abortion Could Decide Control of State Supreme Courts
5 days ago - Abortion
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Trump campaigns in North Carolina with early voting underway
33 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
New York Magazine, Olivia Nuzzi part ways
55 minutes ago - New York -
Politics - The Hill
Florida official says DeSantis's office ordered him to threaten TV stations over abortion ads
1 hour ago - Abortion -
Politics - The Hill
Walz accuses Trump of disrespecting workers by 'cosplaying' at McDonald’s
1 hour ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Texas AG goes after Democratic fundraising as GOP outspent in key races
1 hour ago
Latest in Politics
-
Politics - NBC News
Elon Musk could face ‘legal liability’ for his $1 million giveaway, says election law expert
27 minutes ago - Elon Musk -
Politics - The Hill
Trump campaigns in North Carolina with early voting underway
33 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - NBC News
Trump doubles down on ‘enemy within’ rhetoric in final campaign push
42 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
New York Magazine, Olivia Nuzzi part ways
55 minutes ago - New York -
Politics - The Hill
Florida official says DeSantis's office ordered him to threaten TV stations over abortion ads
1 hour ago - Abortion