Supreme Court turns away self-proclaimed Republican’s defense in claiming party’s support
The Supreme Court turned away a failed Minnesota state Senate candidate’s challenge to rulings that he falsely implied to have the Republican Party’s support during his 2022 write-in campaign.
The Republican Party of Minnesota and the state’s Democratic attorney general insisted Nathan Miller’s First Amendment appeal was riddled with errors and the issue was too narrow to merit the high court’s attention.
Miller ran as a write-in candidate for the Minnesota Senate’s 9th District in 2022 after unsuccessfully seeking the state GOP’s endorsement.
In the lead-up to Election Day, the party filed a complaint against Miller for reposting on his campaign website a flyer that advertised his appearance at an October political rally hosted by a group called “Caravan of Patriots.”
“SD 9 – Republican Party” appeared under Miller’s name, and courts agreed that it violated Minnesota’s law prohibiting knowingly false claims that a candidate has a political party’s support.
Miller — a self-proclaimed Republican who claims the statement was truthful — petitioned the Supreme Court to take up his First Amendment challenge after Minnesota’s high court refused to hear the case.
“During campaigns, candidates seek to reach the electorate and educate the public as to their political beliefs that may align with political philosophies of other national parties,” Miller’s attorney wrote in the petition.
“But many of these candidates do not have endorsements of state parties,” they continued. “Candidates cannot be faced with, nor should they fear, the threat of prosecution—civil or criminal—because of their truthful speech to the electorate, even if state parties do not like it.”
Both the Republican Party of Minnesota and Keith Ellison, the state’s Democratic attorney general and former deputy chair of the Democratic National Committee, told the Supreme Court to stay out of the case.
“In addition to altering his legal theories, he appears to want to litigate an entirely different case on appeal,” the state wrote in court filings.
The party noted the statute narrowly covers false claims of having a party’s support — but not other false campaign speech — and that Miller had only identified four cases brought under the law.
“The Petition is dominated by the enormous chasm between Petitioners’ characterizations of this case and the reality of the factual record and the relevant case law,” the party wrote in court filings.
Date: |
-
Politics - The Hill
Supreme Court turns down Michael Avenatti’s appeal of Stormy Daniels identity theft conviction
The Supreme Court on Tuesday declined to hear disgraced lawyer Michael Avenatti’s appeal of his aggravated identity theft conviction for stealing book proceeds from porn actor Stormy Daniels. A ...1 hour ago -
Top stories - The New York Times
America Is on the Brink of a Great Political Realignment. It’s Already Visible in Arizona.
He and his acolytes purged the G.O.P. to make it smaller and more strident.18 hours ago -
Politics - The Hill
The Supreme Court’s blockbuster gun case is a shot at redemption
In last Tuesday’s ghost gun oral argument, several justices gave the impression that they are inclined to follow the law’s clear text, even where that text leads to gun regulation.2 hours ago -
Top stories - NBC News
Trump turns political event into surreal listening party
Donald Trump turned a town hall event in Pennsylvania into an impromptu listening party Monday, playing a unlikely selection of tunes for more than 30 minutes after the event was paused for a ...4 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Harris campaign touts Republican Mesa mayor's support in new Arizona ad
Vice President Harris’s campaign launched a $370 million ad blitz on Monday, debuting a 30-second spot highlighting an Arizona Republican mayor’s support for the Democratic nominee. In the new ad, ...23 hours ago -
World - The New York Times
Supreme Court Ruling Means Italy’s ‘Bunga Bunga’ Saga Is Not Over
The ruling sets the stage for yet another trial related to the scandal involving Silvio Berlusconi, the former prime minister of Italy who died last year.Yesterday -
Politics - CBS News
Supreme Court tosses decision that shielded officers who arrested citizen journalist
A Texas citizen journalist was arrested after she published two news stories to her Facebook page that included information she sought from a police source.2 hours ago -
Tech - GameSpot
Super Mario Party Jamboree Review - This Party Is Too Crowded
After a significant post-GameCube slump, the Mario Party franchise showed signs of new life in its first two titles on the Switch. While both Super Mario Party and Mario Party Superstars were ...3 hours ago -
Tech - GameSpot
Super Mario Party Jamboree Video Review | This Party Is Too Crowded
As the Switch approaches the end of its lifecycle, Super Mario Party Jamboree attempts to find the sweet spot between its two predecessors and stumbles into an issue of quantity over quality in the ...3 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Democrats slam GOP for 'attempts to disenfranchise' military voters
Democrats this week slammed Republicans for attempting to obstruct voting for military servicemembers after some GOP lawmakers filed lawsuits targeting overseas voters. Rep. Pat Ryan (D-N.Y.), an ...14 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: Walz campaigns in battleground Pennsylvania
Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, the Democratic vice presidential nominee, is holding campaign events in the critical swing state of Pennsylvania Tuesday, with just three weeks left until the election. His ...23 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
The internet’s worst ‘zero day’ could drain all of our bank accounts
Without protective legislation, strong rules, cybercops, better security and tech-literate users, it seems inevitable that we wake one day to zero balances.23 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Nathan Wade appears for House deposition; Willis blasts GOP
Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis (D) blasted House Republicans for “politically motivated tactics” as a former top prosecutor on the Jan 6 case appeared for a deposition with the House ...28 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Geraldo Rivera unsure how Latino voters with 'any self-respect' could back Trump
Television personality Geraldo Rivera questioned how any Latino voter with "self-respect" or "self-esteem" could vote for former President Trump in November, citing what Rivera labeled as ...41 minutes ago - Donald Trump