Supreme Court appears swayed by Texas death row inmate’s request for DNA testing
The Supreme Court appeared swayed by a Texas death row inmate’s argument he has the legal right to sue over the state’s laws governing DNA testing, as he seeks to obtain testing on evidence he claims would prevent his execution.
Ruben Gutierrez was convicted of capital murder and other charges tied to the 1998 robbery and killing of 85-year-old Escolastica Harrison. Prosecutors said Gutierrez and two others plotted to lure Harrison out of her mobile home to steal cash, but instead, two men entered the home and killed her.
For more than a decade, the death row inmate has sought DNA testing to prove that he is ineligible for capital punishment because he wasn’t a major participant in the crime, asserting that he was not one of the two men to enter the home though he did participate in the robbery.
Gutierrez contends that Texas’ DNA testing statute violates due process by only allowing testing where favorable results would bolster a defendants’ innocence, instead of their ineligibility for the death penalty. He sued a Texas prosecutor and local police chief, given their custody of the evidence.
But a federal appeals court found that he does not have standing to challenge the laws’ constitutionality because he failed to prove a prosecutor would likely grant access to the DNA evidence if a court ruled in his favor. Gutierrez’s lawyers claim the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit created its “own novel test” that runs afoul of Supreme Court precedent.
Anne Elizabeth Fisher, a lawyer for Gutierrez, argued before the justices Monday that Gutierrez’s challenge is like that of Texas death row inmate Rodney Reed, who similarly sought leave to challenge Texas’ postconviction DNA testing statute. The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 in Reed’s favor in 2023, with conservative Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett joining the liberal justices.
In that case, the prosecutor whom Reed sued argued that a declaratory judgment would not make it more likely that the state would turn over the DNA evidence — an argument the high court rejected, Fisher said.
"When you apply Reed as it's written, we fit exactly under that category,” Fisher said.
Justice Brett Kavanaugh seemed sympathetic to Gutierrez’s position, suggesting that the lower court’s ruling can’t be left uncorrected just because prosecutors might decline to turn over evidence.
“You know, if President Nixon said, ‘I'm not going to turn over the tapes, no matter what,’ you wouldn't say, ‘Oh, I guess we don't have standing to hear the executive privilege case,’” Kavanaugh said.
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson also seemed to suggest that the lower court overreached.
“You don't have to prove that nothing can come up that will defeat your ability to win the claim. And that's what they seem to be saying,” Jackson said.
“That's exactly what they're saying, and that's what we're fighting against,” Fisher said.
William Francis Cole, a lawyer for Luis Saenz, the district attorney in Cameron County, Texas, argued that the case is not about Saenz’s discretion, but instead whether he can be “compelled to hand over the evidence.”
The state initially did not oppose Gutierrez’s request for DNA testing, but later, changed its position. Justice Sonia Sotomayor scrutinized the flip-flop, suggesting that it was “odd” the state would not want to confirm if another defendant was more culpable than once thought.
“At one point you decided that you wouldn't object to doing it, but now you're fighting a tooth and nail,” Sotomayor said.
“If you are sure of your conviction in your theory, why not do the testing?” she added.
Jackson also expressed concern that, while the case seems “very small and narrow,” a decision in the prosecutor’s favor could have “major implications” for how to determine standing.
“In a discretionary world, if that's your concept of injury, you would never have discretion,” she said. “You'd never have redressability because the prosecutor could always say... ‘Well, I wouldn't give it to you anyway,’ no matter what,” she said.
Cole emphasized that, if Saenz were ordered to turn over the evidence, he would.
A decision is expected by this summer.
-
Kim Kardashian called him a Texas death row inmate on Instagram. He wasn't, and he's suing
Kim Kardashian confused a Texas death row inmate with a New York resident who is not a double murderer. He's now suing for defamation.Los Angeles Times - 3d -
Kim Kardashian sued after mistakenly IDing New York man as Texas death row inmate on Instagram
Kim Kardashian is being sued for slander and libel after she posted an Instagram photo that inaccurately labeled a New York man as a Texas death row inmate.NBC News - 4h -
South Carolina Death Row Inmate Chooses to Be Executed by a Firing Squad
The state has never used that method to execute a prisoner. The last time an inmate was killed by a firing squad was in 2010 in Utah.The New York Times - 3d -
Louisiana's oldest death row inmate dies month before execution date
Christopher Sepulvado was charged with the 1992 killing of his 6-year-old stepson.CBS News - 9h -
Texas AG asks court to require NCAA to begin gender testing
The Republican attorney general in Texas wants the NCAA to take its transgender policy a step further and require gender testing for athletes who compete in women’s sportsABC News - 3d -
Luigi Mangione appears in court for first time since arraignment in UnitedHealthcare CEO death
Luigi Mangione, the 26-year-old man accused of gunning down UnitedHealthCare CEO Brian Thompson in front of a New York City hotel, appeared in court Friday for the first time since he was arraigned ...NBC News - 2d -
Luigi Mangione to appear in NYC court
Luigi Mangione, the man accused of murdering UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson, will be in a New York City courtroom Friday. Attorney and CBS News reporter Katrina Kaufman has more.CBS News - 3d -
Luigi Mangione makes first court appearance of 2025
Hundreds of supporters of suspected killer Luigi Mangione rallied outside of a New York City courthouse Friday. It marked the first court appearance of the year for Mangione, who has pleaded not ...CBS News - 2d -
Texas AG adds gender screening request to NCAA lawsuit
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton asked a judge on Thursday to require the NCAA to start gender testing for athletes who compete in women’s sports. The request for a temporary injunction adds a ...The Hill - 3d
More from The Hill
-
These 17 countries voted with US against Ukraine UN resolution
Seventeen countries in the United Nations General Assembly joined the U.S. on Monday in voting against a nonbinding resolution condemning Russia as the aggressor in the ongoing war in Ukraine – ...The Hill - 37m -
Delta flight declares emergency due to ‘smoky odor’ on flight deck
A Delta Air Lines flight declared an emergency on board after there was a “smoky odor” detected on the flight deck. It was the second incident Monday for the airline. Flight 1882 was headed from ...The Hill - 46m -
Live updates: Trump, Macron talk Russia-Ukraine war; Musk's email deadline looms
President Trump appeared alongside French President Emmanuel Macron for a press conference Monday afternoon at the White House, after meeting on the third anniversary of the Russian invasion of ...The Hill - 51m -
No, the DOJ didn’t cut a ‘good’ quid pro quo with Eric Adams
Almost everyone wants Adams to have a jury trial — at least everyone except Trump’s Justice Department and Alan Dershowitz, professor emeritus at Harvard Law School.The Hill - 1h -
SEC ends investigation into Robinhood's crypto arm
The Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has closed its investigation into the cryptocurrency arm of Robinhood without taking action against the online brokerage, the company announced Monday. ...The Hill - 1h
More in Politics
-
Texas Gov. Abbott wages immigration operation in community targeted by conservatives
Gov. Gregg Abbott stated he'd been planning the immigration operation in Colony Ridge for months to target criminals and immigrants. Observers said some people who were stopped were on to their way ...NBC News - 8m -
Trump and Macron discuss way forward for Ukraine and Russia at press conference
President Trump and French President Macron held a joint press conference at the White House that largely centered around the ongoing negotiations to end the war in Ukraine after Russia's invasion ...NBC News - 18m -
These 17 countries voted with US against Ukraine UN resolution
Seventeen countries in the United Nations General Assembly joined the U.S. on Monday in voting against a nonbinding resolution condemning Russia as the aggressor in the ongoing war in Ukraine – ...The Hill - 37m -
Delta flight declares emergency due to ‘smoky odor’ on flight deck
A Delta Air Lines flight declared an emergency on board after there was a “smoky odor” detected on the flight deck. It was the second incident Monday for the airline. Flight 1882 was headed from ...The Hill - 46m -
Live updates: Trump, Macron talk Russia-Ukraine war; Musk's email deadline looms
President Trump appeared alongside French President Emmanuel Macron for a press conference Monday afternoon at the White House, after meeting on the third anniversary of the Russian invasion of ...The Hill - 51m