Roberson execution temporarily blocked in shaken baby syndrome case
The Supreme Court declined to block Texas from executing Robert Roberson, who insists his conviction for murdering his 2-year-old daughter rests upon a debunked version of shaken baby syndrome, but his execution is temporarily on hold under a state court ruling handed down moments beforehand.
Roberson, 57, was scheduled to be executed by lethal injection Thursday evening, which would make him the first person in the U.S. to be put to death over such a conviction.
In an order issued less than two hours earlier, the Supreme Court denied Roberson’s emergency appeal to halt it. Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote a solo statement explaining that the court was “powerless to act without a colorable federal claim” but stressed that Texas Gov. Greg Abbott (R) still had authority to issue a 30-day delay.
“That could prevent a miscarriage of justice from occurring: executing a man who has raised credible evidence of actual innocence,” Sotomayor wrote.
Moments before the Supreme Court’s order, however, Roberson’s execution was put on hold when a Texas House committee emerged successful in an unusual last-ditch effort to delay it — for now.
On Wednesday, the committee subpoenaed Roberson to testify. They went to court on Thursday, when a judge granted their motion for a temporary order blocking the state from executing him. The state’s criminal justice department said it is appealing.
A jury in 2003 found Roberson guilty of murdering his 2-year-old daughter, Nikki Curtis, who died after doctors observed subdural bleeding, brain swelling and retinal hemorrhages. At the time, those combined symptoms were viewed as proof of shaken baby syndrome caused by child abuse.
Roberson maintains his innocence, and his lawyers point to experts who have since discredited the medical theory. His attorneys argue Roberson’s daughter instead died from pneumonia that progressed to sepsis, which caused her to fall from her bed and suffer head trauma. They also say Roberson's autism was used against him.
“Robert did not harm Nikki in any way,” Roberson’s attorneys wrote to the Supreme Court. “There was no crime — only the tragic natural death of a little girl.”
Roberson’s Supreme Court bid to block his execution rested on a Texas law passed over a decade ago that allows challenges to convictions based on changed science.
The Texas Court of Criminal Appeals declined to block Roberson’s execution on procedural grounds. In his emergency appeal to the Supreme Court, Roberson’s attorneys claimed his due process rights were violated because the state panel tossed his case in a “boilerplate” order that contained no analysis of his arguments.
“We have reached an ominous moment in terms of the sanctity of law when vast swathes of the public can be more aware of the facts of this case and moved by the injustice it represents than the state judiciary that was charged with adjudicating it,” his attorneys wrote in court filings.
But Texas contended Roberson “falls short” of proving his innocence and at most showed a “battle of the experts” about the evidence.
“He clearly advocates for a new rule — that a state court must provide an explanation for the application of a state procedural rule when a capital state habeas applicant raises a claim of actual innocence based on new scientific and medical evidence. That was not the rule at the time of Roberson’s conviction, and it’s not the rule today,” the Texas attorney general’s office wrote in court filings.
The Supreme Court rarely intervenes to block executions. Last term, the justices received roughly 30 requests to do so but only halted one, according to The Hill’s analysis of the court’s docket.
The Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles on Wednesday voted to not recommend Roberson’s sentence be commuted to life in prison or delay his execution. Such a recommendation was required for Abbott, Texas’s Republican governor, to grant clemency, though he retains authority to provide a 30-day reprieve.
Updated at 7:30 p.m. EDT
Date: |
-
Top stories - CBS News
Texas board denies clemency for Robert Roberson, set to be executed in shaken baby syndrome case
Robertson's lawyers have asked the U.S. Supreme Court to stay his execution.Yesterday -
Top stories - ABC News
'Shaken baby syndrome' execution temporarily halted despite SCOTUS ruling
Robert Roberson, who was sentenced to death based on the largely discredited "shaken baby syndrome" hypothesis, was denied a stay of execution by the Supreme Court.1 hour ago -
Health - ABC News
Texas man facing execution in shaken baby syndrome case awaits clemency ruling
The Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles has denied a request for clemency for a man who this week could be the first person in the U.S. executed for a murder conviction tied to the diagnosis of ...22 hours ago -
Top stories - CBS News
What to know about the Texas inmate set to be executed in shaken baby syndrome case
Thursday night, a Texas man is scheduled to become the first person executed for the death of a toddler blamed on "shaken baby syndrome." CBS News national correspondent Nikki Battiste has more on ...9 hours ago -
Top stories - NBC News
Judge upholds execution warrant in 'shaken baby' case
A judge in Texas denied a motion by lawyers for Robert Roberson to throw out the execution warrant against him. Roberson is scheduled to be executed Thursday and would be the first person put to ...2 days ago -
Top stories - The New York Times
Court Orders Delay of Execution in Texas Shaken Baby Case
Robert Roberson was set to be executed on Thursday evening for the death of his 2-year-old child. But state legislators obtained a last-minute court order postponing it.1 hour ago -
Top stories - NBC News
Texas execution tied to 'shaken baby syndrome' death is in limbo amid legal fight
Texas is preparing to put Roberson to death Thursday in what would be the nation's first execution involving a case of "shaken baby syndrome."1 hour ago -
Top stories - CBS News
A look into the shaken baby syndrome case that landed a Texas man on death row
The Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles denied requests to halt the upcoming execution of 57-year-old Robert Robertson, who was convicted in a controversial 2002 shaken baby syndrome case. He is ...Yesterday
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Who could replace Yahya Sinwar as Hamas's leader?
Yahya Sinwar's death has raised many questions about the future of the war in Gaza, perhaps none more pressing than who will replace him as Hamas's leader. The Israeli Defense Forces (IDF) said on ...42 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: Jacky Rosen, Sam Brown go head-to-head in Nevada Senate debate
Incumbent Sen. Jacky Rosen (D-Nev.) will face off with GOP challenger Sam Brown Thursday night in the Nevada Senate debate. The forum will be the only chance for Rosen, a first-term senator, and ...46 minutes ago -
Politics - The Hill
Harris: Trump 'has no idea' about women's health care
Vice President Harris on Thursday night made an appeal to female voters at a rally in Wisconsin, arguing former President Trump doesn’t know what he’s talking about when it comes to women’s health ...49 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: Trump gives remarks at Al Smith dinner in New York
Former President Trump is attending the annual Al Smith dinner in New York City on Thursday evening — a major fundraising event hosted by Catholic Charities of New York. The dinner, which ...1 hour ago - New York -
Politics - The Hill
Trump assassination suspect demands Judge Cannon recuse from case
Ryan Routh, the man charged with attempting to assassinate former President Trump at his Florida golf course last month, asked U.S. District Judge Aileen Cannon on Thursday to recuse herself from ...2 hours ago - Donald Trump