Red states ask court to reject Google privacy settlement
A group of Republican-led states have asked a U.S. appeals court to reject a $62 million consumer privacy settlement with Google, citing large amounts of money awards going to class members' lawyers and advocacy groups.
Iowa Attorney General Brenna Bird (R) led the group of 20 state attorneys general in arguing to the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals that the settlement "replaces money that could go toward making class members whole with awards to controversial political organizations."
The effort comes after a federal court judge in California approved the $62 million settlement in May. The settlement was reached as part of a data privacy class action stemming from Google's tracking and storing of location data for 247.7 million U.S. mobile users who disabled their "location history" on their phones.
Following the May decision, a group of class members appealed the settlement approval to the 9th Circuit over its lack of effort to distribute funds to the class.
The bulk of the settlement funds are expected to go toward third-party groups, which the attorneys general argued do not have a "substantial" tie to the class members.
"Instead, their efforts focus on environmental justice, abortion, and controversial positions on sex and sexuality," the AGs' friend-of-the-court brief stated. "Not only are those causes wholly unrelated to the class's data privacy claim, but many class members actively oppose them."
Bird, in a press release about the Wednesday filing, took specific aim at the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), one of the 21 recipient organizations slated to be paid in the settlement. Other recipients include the Free Press and The Information Society Project at Yale.
"Of the $62 million, $42.6 million will be sent to left-wing activist groups that have nothing to do with Google, including the ACLU," Bird wrote. "The ACLU has already made it clear that it will use its resources to fund advocacy and lawsuits relating to abortion and LGBTQ issues. The remaining money goes to the attorneys. Zero dollars from the settlement will go to the Americans who have been harmed."
The Hill has reached out to the ACLU for comment.
A spokesperson for Google, in a comment shared with The Hill, maintained that sending funding to nonpartisan organizations is typical when direct payments to the individuals are "not feasible."
"The organizations were selected by the parties because they have a strong commitment to promoting online privacy. The Attorneys General were told and given the chance to object at the time and none of them did," Google spokesperson José Castañeda wrote.
Other states behind this week's filing are Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Louisiana, Montana, Nebraska, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Utah, Virginia and West Virginia.
Date: | |
Tag: |
-
NBC News - Top stories
Supreme Court rejects Green Party bid to appear on Nevada presidential ballot
The Supreme Court rejected Green Party presidential nominee Jill Stein’s last-ditch request to be included on the ballot in Nevada, a key swing state.6 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
Texas judge rejects Paxton attempt to block State Fair gun ban
An Texas judge has slapped down an attempt by state Attorney General Ken Paxton (R) to force the state fair to allow guns. Paxton’s office sued in August to block a change in state fair policy to ...5 hours ago -
ESPN - Sports
Flick: Early red changed game 'totally' for Barca
Barcelona coach Hansi Flick felt Eric García's early red card was the turning point in Thursday's 2-1 defeat to Monaco and insisted his side are strong enough to progress in the new-look Champions ...6 hours ago -
The Wall Street Journal - Business
Social-Media Firms Lack Adequate Privacy Controls, FTC Report Says
The agency said the companies engaged in vast consumer surveillance while failing to provide adequate privacy controls or safeguards for children.Yesterday -
The New York Times - Tech
What the U.S. Has Argued in the Google Ad Tech Antitrust Trial
As the government wraps up its case, it has built a picture of how Google has become dominant among companies that buy and sell ads online.6 minutes ago - Google -
Financial Times - World
Three big investment questions I’m asking now — and so should you
As the fourth quarter looms, portfolio risk, US equities and China are all that matters16 hours ago -
Yahoo News - World
India rejects report on transfer of ammunitions to Ukraine as 'speculative'
12 hours ago - Ukraine -
Yahoo Sports - Sports
Report: Red Wings May Not Be Able to Manage Eight-Year Deal for Seider
Per TSN's Chris Johnston, Detroit may have to limit the star German defenseman's contract term to find an agreeable annual salary2 days ago -
Inc. - Business
SpaceX 'Forcefully Rejects' FAA Conclusion it Violated Launch Requirements
CEO Elon Musk rails at $633,000 in fines, which he called politically motivated, threatening to sue to contest them.3 hours ago - SpaceX
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
North Carolina judge rejects GOP request to bar students from using digital IDs to vote
A North Carolina judge has rejected Republicans' request to bar students and school employees from using digital identification cards to vote. Wake Superior Court Judge Keith Gregory denied on ...37 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Co-chair of Haley’s Iowa campaign endorses Harris
Dawn Roberts, the co-chair of former GOP presidential candidate Nikki Haley’s campaign in Iowa, said Friday is endorsing Vice President Harris for president. In a column in the Des Moines Register, ...48 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Wisconsin Supreme Court to rule on whether RFK Jr. will stay on ballot
The Supreme Court of Wisconsin has agreed to rule on whether Robert F. Kennedy Jr. will stay on the ballot after the independent candidate-turned-Trump backed filed a Sept. 3 lawsuit seeking to ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
Ocasio-Cortez says office 'tagged with blood-splattered signs' after pager attack remarks
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (D-N.Y.) said her House office was "tagged with blood-splattered signs accusing [her] of supporting terrorism" after she condemned Israel for a series of ...1 hour ago -
The Hill - Politics
Navy’s highest-ranking officer successfully treated for breast cancer
Chief of Naval Operations Adm. Lisa Franchetti was treated successfully for early-stage breast cancer this summer, the service revealed Friday. Franchetti, the Navy’s highest-ranking military ...1 hour ago