New York's high court rules voting early by mail is constitutional
![New York's high court rules voting early by mail is constitutional](https://thehill.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/2/2024/04/stefanikelise_041724ar02_w.jpg?w=900)
New York’s top court affirmed Tuesday that a measure expanding access to absentee voting in the state is constitutional, rejecting a lawsuit led by House GOP Chair Elise Stefanik (N.Y.).
The New York Court of Appeals ruled 6-1 that New York’s Early Mail Voter Act, which allows registered voters to submit ballots early by mail in any election where they are eligible to vote, can stand. The measure was signed into law by Gov. Kathy Hochul (D) last year.
“Our task is to rigorously analyze the constitutional text and history to determine if New York’s Early Mail Voter Act is unconstitutional,” Chief Judge Rowan Wilson wrote for the majority. “We now hold that it is not.”
Wilson acknowledged the “difficult” question raised by the Republican-led lawsuit, noting that though the New York Constitution does not contain language explicitly requiring in-person voting, the state’s legislative and executive branches “have often proceeded as if our Constitution requires as such.”
The chief judge also recognized that a 2021 proposed amendment to codify absentee voting failed at the ballot box. Some 55 percent of voters turned down the measure at the time.
“We take seriously both the legislature’s position in 2021 and the voters’ rejection of the proposed constitutional amendment,” Wilson wrote. “At the same time, we may not simply defer to the legislature’s assumptions about what the Constitution requires.”
Stefanik and a slew of Republican groups challenged the measure shortly after it was signed into law last year in September.
In a statement, Stefanik said the state’s high court “disgracefully claims to know the constitutional framers’ intent more than they did,” disregarding interpretation norms.
“New York's court system is so corrupt and disgraceful that today's ruling has essentially declared that for over 150 years, New York’s elected officials, voters, and judges misunderstood their own state’s Constitution, and that in-person voting was never required outside the current legal absentee process,” Stefanik said, adding that the “only path forward to Save New York” is to vote the state’s Democrats out of office.
The Republican National Committee, National Republican Congressional Committee, Conservative Party of New York State and New York Republican State Committee challenged the law alongside Stefanik.
New York Attorney General Letitia James (D), whose office defended the measure, called voting a “beautiful celebration of patriotism and civic responsibility” and suggested that the government should make it easier to vote, not harder.
"While some want to put up roadblocks and stifle New Yorkers’ ability to exercise their Constitutional right to vote, I will always stand up and protect this basic, yet essential, freedom,” James said.
Aria Branch, an Elias Law Group lawyer who represented the Democratic Congressional Campaign Committee and several Democratic lawmakers, said in a statement that the decision is a win for New York voters who can now cast ballots by mail "without having to provide an excuse.” Branch called the court’s ruling a “pro-democracy decision.”
—Updated at 4:02 p.m.
Date: | |
Tag: | New York |
-
The Hill - Politics
Black enrollment drops in Harvard’s freshman class after Supreme Court ruling
Harvard University released racial and ethnic data that showed a decrease in how many Black students the school admitted in its newly enrolled freshman class, the first to be affected by the ...20 hours ago -
ABC News - World
Serbian appeals court overturns ruling to extradite to Belarus a critic of its authoritarian regime
An appeals court in Serbia has overturned an earlier ruling that a prominent critic of the authoritarian government in Belarus should be extradited to that country and said that the case must be ...20 hours ago -
The New York Times - Lifestyle
Off-White Comes to New York: NYFW Review
Off-White celebrates the allure of the melting pot.3 days ago - New York
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Koch-affiliated Libre Initiative makes endorsements in Michigan, Connecticut
The Libre Initiative Action is rolling out endorsements for three tight congressional races on Thursday, hoping to win elections to the House and Senate for Republicans in Michigan and Connecticut. ...38 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Most in new survey wary of AI-powered election information
Most Americans say they don’t trust AI-powered chatbots to produce accurate information about the 2024 election, according to a new survey from The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs ...40 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
When America welcomes refugees to its shores, we all win
The United States has long been a beacon for those fleeing war, persecution and violence. We must keep this legacy alive.40 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Black voters in key battleground states highly motivated to vote in November: poll
Black voters in key battleground states are highly motivated to cast their ballots in this year’s election, according to new polling, following Vice President Harris’s ascension to the top of the ...46 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
A cease-fire and hostage deal in Gaza will require a change of framework
The negotiated deal’s framework allows Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who does not want the war to end, to sabotage it every step of the way.1 hour ago