When America welcomes refugees to its shores, we all win
As a refugee medical examiner for Los Angeles County, I have had the privilege of being the first doctor many new arrivals see in the U.S. In these moments of vulnerability, refugees share not just their medical history but their personal stories — tales of resilience, hope and the arduous journeys that brought them here.
I have screened engineers who supported our forces in Afghanistan, Ukrainians whose homes were reduced to rubble, religious minorities discriminated against in Nigeria, Iran and Turkey, and a Guatemalan prosecutor who joked that he's traded dodging bullets for battling Los Angeles traffic.
Through our services to protect their health as well as the health of our public from any imported infections, I have seen the transformative power of America's promise — the relief in a mother's eyes when her child receives long-delayed medical care; the determination of a former translator to build a new life, practicing English phrases during our check-up; the joy of an elderly couple finally safe from fear; and the tuberculosis patients' laughter, echoing, as they share plans for their grandchildren's future. These moments reflect the very best of our nation.
In last night's presidential debate, the issue of immigration took center stage, as expected. Vice President Kamala Harris, in particular, stood at a crossroads.
The current administration has taken important steps to restore America's commitment to refugees, raising the annual admissions cap from a historic low of 18,000 under the previous administration to 125,000. Although this is progress, it still falls short of historical highs (the peak was 231,700 in 1980); ongoing crises on our border and across the globe call for an even bolder approach. As the nation watched, Harris had an opportunity to reaffirm, not apologize for, this commitment, by making it clear that America will continue to lead the world.
Founded by refugees, the U.S. has long been a beacon for those fleeing war, persecution and violence. From the Puritans and Quakers who sought religious freedom to the more recent waves of refugees from places like Vietnam and Bosnia, America's legacy of welcoming the world's vulnerable is woven into the fabric of who we are.
It is crucial to understand the difference between refugees and asylum seekers. Refugees apply from their home countries and travel to the U.S. after being approved. They receive support through a thoughtful resettlement process that is a model of public-private partnership and comprehensive support. From humanitarian groups like the International Rescue Committee to faith-based organizations like Global Refuge to government agencies like mine, there's an entire network dedicated to welcoming refugees, offering English classes, job preparation, apartment hunting, school enrollment and more.
In Minnesota, for instance, the Minnesota Council of Churches has resettled Karen refugees from Myanmar, many of whom have revitalized their congregations. In Texas, refugee-run businesses in Houston have boosted the local economy, with the city proud to be among the most welcoming for refugees in the nation. In Vermont, communities provide not just material support but also friendship and cultural exchange.
In contrast, asylum seekers request their status after arriving in the U.S. The system for asylum requests, particularly at the southern border, is under immense strain. We're seeing record-high numbers, with over 4 million encounters and 1 million asylum requests in 2022 and 2023 alone.
Unlike refugees, asylum seekers don't receive any resettlement support while their cases are being determined. Having left everything behind to survive, those without U.S. contacts often find themselves — and their host cities — under significant strain. Given the concerns with border security, we should focus on the refugee process.
Raising the cap, expanding the eligibility for pathways such as the Priority 3 Family Reunification Program and expediting applications are possible starting points. More refugees will mean a more controlled, supportive process where the benefits go both ways. When given the chance, refugees repay that opportunity by becoming self-sufficient, integrated and successful Americans.
Contrary to some perceptions, refugees improve the safety of their surroundings. A prime example is the city of Lewiston, Maine, which experienced an influx of Somali refugees in the early 2000s. Despite false allegations by Donald Trump, the city experienced a steady decline in crime, with the acting police chief defending its Somali residents.
Similarly, the Rust Belt city of Buffalo saw its crime rates drop by 40 percent between 2010 and 2017, as its refugee population grew. Local officials attributed part of this success to the revitalization of neighborhoods by hard-working refugee families.
Refugee employment rates mirror or even exceed that of the general population, and refugee-owned businesses generate significant revenue. In Idaho, for example, refugees have played a crucial role in the state's dairy industry, helping it become one of the largest in the nation. And in Georgia, Clarkston, often referred to as the "Ellis Island of the South," has seen its economy grow due to its large refugee population.
The New American Economy Fund found high rates of refugee entrepreneurship, creating opportunities for American workers and contributing more than $20 billion in federal, state and local taxes when this was studied back in 2015. In California alone, they found refugees made substantial contributions to the state's economy, with $17.2 billion in spending power.
Recent polling found that about 72 percent of Americans believe that taking in civilian refugees from countries experiencing violence and war should be an important goal for U.S. immigration policy. This broad public support is mirrored in Congress, where bipartisan groups of lawmakers have championed refugee resettlement. From the Refugee Act of 1980, which standardized resettlement services for all refugees admitted to the U.S., to the Lautenberg Amendment, which aided Soviet Jews and Evangelical Christians, to more recent efforts assisting Afghan and Ukrainian refugees, support for refugees has transcended party lines.
Unfortunately, we are living in fractured times. As we reflect on this week’s debate and consider our nation's future, let's consider which candidate used the opportunity to paint a more confident, joyful and generous vision of America — one that challenges us to see refugees as I’ve seen them, not as burdens but as future neighbors, colleagues and friends who enrich our lives.
Naman Shah, MD, Ph.D., is director of medical and dental affairs at the Los Angeles County Department of Public Health, a Paul and Daisy Soros Fellow, and a Public Voices Fellow of the OpEd Project. The views expressed in this commentary are his own.
Date: |
Topics
-
ABC News - World
A Hezbollah official says "several hundred" people in Lebanon, including its members, were wounded when pagers exploded
A Hezbollah official says "several hundred" people in Lebanon, including its members, were wounded when pagers exploded6 hours ago -
ABC News - World
Hezbollah officials say at least two of its members and a girl were killed when the group's new brand of pagers exploded
Hezbollah officials say at least two of its members and a girl were killed when the group's new brand of pagers exploded5 hours ago -
The Guardian - World
After the Huw Edwards scandal – and all the others – we must have a BBC fit for the modern age | Jane Martinson
The former presenter’s crimes are his responsibility, but the corporation must change so its stars can never again abuse their power. Disgraced, convicted and now sentenced , a chapter has closed: ...10 hours ago -
Inc. - Business
Corporate America Cares Less and Less About Inflation
Fewer S&P 500 companies are mentioning inflation during earnings calls ahead of the Fed's first rate cut.7 hours ago -
CBS News - Top stories
When and how to see September's Harvest Moon
The September Harvest Moon will see a partial lunar eclipse, peaking the night of Tuesday, Sept. 17.10 hours ago -
ABC News - Top stories
WATCH: Dog stands on hind legs to give a gentle welcome sniff to new puppy
Cooper the dachshund stood tall to give his new son Dorito a gentle first sniff.2 hours ago -
GameSpot - Tech
All The Upcoming Star Wars Movies
Blast off The Star Wars movie series hasn't seen a new release since 2019's The Rise of Skywalker . While the venerated sci-fi series created by George Lucas is resting, it's far from over. ...2 hours ago -
The Hill - Politics
America’s story is bigger than Trump’s hateful conspiracy theories
The presidential debate is over, but the people of Springfield, Ohio, are only beginning to face its fallout.8 hours ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
It’s official: America’s real wages are up under Biden-Harris
The average working-class American can now answer yes to the question: Are you better off now than you were under Donald Trump?5 hours ago - Joe Biden -
The New York Times - Top stories
America’s Role in the World Is Hard. It Just Got Much Harder.
The explosion of wireless devices across Lebanon casts in sharp relief the challenges of U.S. foreign policy facing Kamala Harris or Donald Trump.46 minutes ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Klobuchar, Warner press tech leaders to take action against election-related disinformation
Democratic Sens. Amy Klobuchar (Minn.) and Mark Warner (Va.) sent a letter to major tech leaders on Tuesday, urging them to take "decisive action" against disinformation related to the 2024 general ...22 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Tensions rise after apparent Trump assassination attempt
Welcome to The Hill's Campaign newsletter {beacon} Campaign Report Campaign Report The Big Story Tensions rise after apparent Trump assassination attempt Another major event has shaken up the ...24 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Evening Report — Trump returns to campaigning after assassination attempt
Presented by the National Council on Aging — 📝 Speaker Johnson pushes ahead in funding bill fight {beacon} Evening Report © UPI photo Trump returns to campaign trail amid outrage over second ...24 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Democrats block Cruz attempt to pass GOP IVF bill
Democrats on Tuesday blocked an attempt by Republican Sens. Ted Cruz (Texas) and Katie Britt (Ala.) to pass a GOP IVF access bill through unanimous consent, repeating a similar showdown that ...30 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
GOP won't force a vote to overturn nursing home staffing rule
Republicans are not planning to force a vote on a resolution to overturn the Biden administration’s plan mandating minimum staffing levels in nursing homes, Sen. James Lankford (R-Okla.) said. A ...31 minutes ago