New rules for disadvantaged businesses should maintain integrity
A growing and alarming trend threatens to undermine the integrity of vital federal government set-asides for minority, women, veteran-owned and small disadvantaged businesses.
Unscrupulous companies, often backed by larger financial institutions, are exploiting loopholes and weak oversight to falsely claim status with the federal government as "disadvantaged" firms.
Federal contracting is a zero-sum game. When dollars are given to one company on a given contract, it necessarily makes them unavailable to another. Falsely claiming to be a small disadvantaged business takes away opportunities from real, deserving businesses that need these federal contracting opportunities to grow and thrive.
Two recent examples come to mind. First, Florida-based contractors HX5 LLC and HX5 Sierra LLC, together with their owner, agreed to pay more than $7.7 million to settle allegations of falsely claiming disadvantaged business status in June 2023. The companies were accused of misrepresenting the owner’s assets and failing to disclose payments to family members while securing contracts with NASA, the Army and the Air Force.
R&W Builders of Illinois paid $400,000 to resolve claims of fraudulently securing contracts meant for disadvantaged small businesses. The company allegedly collaborated with a qualified disadvantaged business but violated program rules by taking control of the joint venture and completing most of the work themselves.
These beliefs are deeply personal to me. I previously served as the special consultant to the head of the Small Business Association, during which time I drafted the standard operating procedures for the federal government’s 8(a) minority business program.
The 8(a) program is a vital initiative designed to help socially and economically disadvantaged small businesses compete in the federal marketplace. This nine-year initiative provides participants with training, technical assistance and contracting opportunities to strengthen their ability to compete effectively in the American economy.
These policies and programs are lifelines for minority-owned businesses, women-owned businesses, veteran-owned businesses and other disadvantaged enterprises. The opportunities they provide are essential for leveling the playing field, allowing these businesses to compete in a marketplace that has historically favored larger, more established corporations.
It’s imperative that genuine small disadvantaged businesses can count on the access that the 8(a) and other similar programs provide. Small business set-asides provide an incredible opportunity for growth and innovation which federal agencies should encourage.
I have seen firsthand the procedures required for verification, which are extensive and time-consuming, but necessary. The SBA should absolutely lean on partners that can offer a wealth of knowledge and experience to help ensure protections for small minority-owned businesses.
Further, while government oversight remains essential, eligible and qualified small disadvantaged businesses should also have a direct hand in helping to close the loopholes that so clearly exist in the program’s self-certification process.
Protecting the integrity of the small-business set-aside program is not just about fairness; it is about maintaining trust in the federal contracting system. Minority-owned businesses and other disadvantaged enterprises must be able to trust that the opportunities intended for them are not being siphoned off by companies that have no rightful claim to them. When this trust is eroded, the entire purpose of the program is undermined.
One solution to consider is robust oversight on firms that claim small disadvantaged business status. There are strict penalties for misrepresentation, such as fines up to $500,000 or up to 10 years of imprisonment, and/or both, and suspension and debarment from future contracts that should act as a significant deterrent, if enforced.
These steps, combined with leveraging advanced technologies for more effective monitoring, would go a long way toward safeguarding the integrity of the program. If minority and small disadvantaged businesses are to succeed in today’s competitive marketplace, they must abide by the rules without interference by fraudulent companies.
The SBA is currently rethinking the small disadvantaged business program after federal court rulings and has placed a “pause” on new 8(a) applications and new rules and regulations will be coming out this fall.
My organization looks forward to enhanced collaboration with the SBA and other relevant federal agencies to drive immediate and decisive action to address this issue and prevent unqualified businesses from unfairly benefitting from a small disadvantaged business designation.
Preserving small-business set-asides for rightful recipients will ensure that the businesses these programs were designed to help are the ones that truly benefit from them, promoting fairness, equity and economic opportunity for all.
Roger Campos is the chairman and founder of the Minority Business Round Table.
Date: |
Topics
-
The New York Times - Top stories
In Georgia, a New Showdown Is Brewing Over Election Rules
The state election board was recently taken over by a conservative majority. Its latest proposals are dangerously late in the process and most likely illegal, according to the secretary of state.Yesterday -
BBC News - Top stories
We need new homes, where should they go?
BBC Home Editor Mark Easton hosts a debate with three experts asking whether we should build on the green belt.20 hours ago -
CBS News - Top stories
Why first-time homebuyers are at a disadvantage
First-time homebuyers are getting locked out of the market because high interest rates keep people from selling, a spike in all cash offers, and millennials — the largest generation — are competing ...2 days ago -
Financial Times - World
EU’s new competition chief: European companies must scale up for global fight
Incoming Spanish commissioner Teresa Ribera signals new era in how Brussels polices dealmaking17 hours ago -
NBC News - Top stories
How new compensation rules are transforming college gymnastics and attracting Olympic stars
When former gymnast Jordyn Wieber won the all-around world championship ahead of the 2012 London Olympics, she faced a difficult dilemma.10 hours ago - Olympics -
The Hill - Politics
Jeffries: New election rules are 'nonstarter' for Democrats in funding fight
House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries (D-N.Y.) said Thursday that Democrats will oppose any federal funding bill that includes conservative policy riders pushed by former President Trump. “Donald ...2 hours ago -
MarketWatch - Business
Polestar’s stock rises as it maintains Nasdaq listing requirements
Polestar Automotive Holding’s stock was up about 1.7% in premarket trading on Tuesday after the electric-vehicle maker said it has satisfied requirements to remain on the Nasdaq.2 days ago -
ABC News - Sports
Sean Payton bypasses opportunity to go for onside kick under new rules after Colts, Niners try
It seemed like the perfect time for Sean Payton to try an onside kick under the NFL's new kickoff rules that only allow them in the fourth quarter if the team is trailing2 days ago
More from The Hill
-
The Hill - Politics
Sabato's Crystal Ball shifts North Carolina governor's race toward Democrats amid Robinson controversy
The political forecasting site Larry Sabato's Crystal Ball has shifted the North Carolina governor's race toward Democrats amid an unfolding controversy Thursday involving Mark Robinson, the ...22 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Conway: 'Of course' she can see Trump conceding defeat if he loses election
Kellyanne Conway, the former senior adviser to former President Trump, said “of course” she can imagine a world in which Trump graciously concedes defeat to Vice President Harris after losing the ...22 minutes ago - Donald Trump -
The Hill - Politics
Hispanic Caucus backs Democrat to replace late Rep. Pascrell
Congressional Hispanic Democrats are throwing some weight behind New Jersey State Sen. Nellie Pou, a Democrat who’s all but certain to win a vacant House seat to become the state’s first Latina ...33 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Walz meets with families of hostages held by Hamas
Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, the Democratic vice presidential nominee, met Thursday with the families of Americans being held hostage in Gaza by Hamas, the Harris campaign said. Walz listened to the ...40 minutes ago -
The Hill - Politics
Fetterman: Trump’s 'special' place in Pennsylvania 'deepened' after shooting
Sen. John Fetterman (D-Pa.) said he thinks former President Trump has a “special” place among Pennsylvania voters and it only deepened after a gunman opened fire at a Trump rally in the state in ...40 minutes ago - Donald Trump