Musk and Trump are blatantly violating the Constitution
Since President Trump took office just under a month ago, Elon Musk and his team of privateers have rampaged through government, demolishing agencies, rifling through private data, firing thousands of career federal employees and even changing signage on federal buildings and historic sites.
The White House has justified Musk’s authority under the label “special government employee.” The media has taken the bait to an alarming degree, covering Musk and his Department of Government Efficiency as if they are legitimate agents of the federal government.
This is legal window-dressing, as two lawsuits allege — one filed in federal court in Washington, D.C. and one in Maryland. Both cases claim that Musk is operating unconstitutionally and seek injunctions stripping Musk of his powers and endeavoring to undo some of the damage he has already done to the nation. Of all the lawsuits filed since Jan. 20, these two are perhaps the most important.
Although it is normally Congress’s job to create agencies and give them their power by statute, Trump created DOGE by executive order. He renamed an existing agency, the U.S. Digital Service, which President Barack Obama created as a sub-entity within the Executive Office of the President. That office was created in 1939 by President Franklin D. Roosevelt to give the president support to govern effectively, including assisting with messaging to the American people and promoting our interests abroad. The Digital Service’s role was to improve the government’s digital interfaces, including the HealthCare.gov website that launched Obamacare.
As the 26 current and former government employee plaintiffs in the Maryland suit allege, Musk’s authority far surpasses that of a presidential advisor within the reasonable scope of the Executive Office of the President or U.S. Digital Service. “His power includes, at least, the authority to cease the payment of congressionally approved funds, access sensitive and confidential data across government agencies, cut off systems access to federal employees and contractors at will, and take over and dismantle entire independent federal agencies,” their complaint states. Such a delegation of power requires an act of Congress.
The D.C. case was filed by a group of 19 state attorneys general, who write, “President Trump has delegated virtually unchecked authority to Mr. Musk without proper legal authorization from Congress and without meaningful supervision of his activities.”
Special government employees are supposed to be temporary — employed no more than 130 days within a 365-day period. They are also subject to conflict-of-interest laws. In a letter sent to White House Chief of Staff Susie Wiles on Monday, Sen. Adam Schiff (D-Calif.) wrote, “Musk’s compliance with federal conflicts of interest and other related obligations remains unknown to Congress and the public.”
The conflict-of-interest laws have criminal implications. And Musk’s conflicts are glaring, as his companies are under federal scrutiny by several agencies over which he has immense power. The Guardian reported, for example, that FDA staff reviewing Musk’s brain implant company Neuralink had been fired over the weekend.
Even if Musk is a compliant special government employee, Trump has no authority to give him power that the executive does not have — including the power to dismantle entire federal agencies. Again, that requires an act of Congress.
In a post-hearing filing in the case before Judge Tanya Chutkan, Joshua Fisher, the director of the White House Office of Administration, declared that Musk “has no actual or formal authority to make government decisions himself,” including personnel decisions at individual agencies; that Musk is an employee of the White House Office (not the U.S. Digital Service or the U.S. DOGE Service Temporary Organization); and that Musk only has the ability to advise the president, or communicate the president’s directives, like many other senior White House advisors (citing the example of Biden advisor Anita Dunn).
These assertions are plainly false.
On Tuesday, Chutkan denied a temporary restraining order, finding that the plaintiffs "have not adequately linked Defendants’ actions to imminent harm to [the] States in particular" with sufficient specificity to justify such extraordinary relief. But she also wrote that their Appointments Clause claims have “serious implications,” and that “even Defendants concede there is no apparent 'source of legal authority granting [DOGE] the power' to take some of the actions challenged here.” Chutkan added that what Trump gave Musk "appears to be the unchecked authority of an unelected individual and an entity that was not created by Congress and over which it has no oversight.”
The legal heart of both lawsuits is the Constitution’s Article II Appointments Clause, which gives the president the power to “nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate ... appoint ... all other Officers of the United States ... which shall be established by Law: but the Congress may by Law vest the Appointment of such inferior Officers, as they think proper, in the President alone, in the Courts of Law, or in the Heads of Departments.”
Let’s unpack this. First, the Constitution says that “officers” — which the Supreme Court has read to mean “principal officers” who exercise “significant authority,” such as Cabinet-level department heads — must be nominated by the president but are subject to confirmation through the advice and consent of the Senate. Musk appears to have more power right now than any single Cabinet official, because he exercises power over a range of federal agencies and their thousands of employees. But he was neither nominated by the president nor confirmed by the Senate.
Second, the Constitution states that the position of “officer” in question must be established by the Constitution itself or “shall be established by law” — meaning through an act of Congress. Musk’s job is not created by the Constitution and Congress did not even create DOGE, let alone establish by law the role that Musk is now playing.
Third, the Constitution creates a lesser category of “inferior officer.” Even if Trump’s lawyers could manage to legitimately argue that Musk qualifies as "inferior" — a notion that fails the straight-face test — it wouldn’t help them get around the legal problems with Trump anointing Musk with unlimited power. The Constitution states that the appointment of inferior officers without Senate confirmation must be, once again, created by Congress. Congress can give the president the power to appoint them if it wants to, but it has not done that here.
One of the disappointing — if not downright heartbreaking — aspects of the Trump-Musk takeover of government is that Congress is going along with it. Congress could defund the U.S. Digital Service and thus DOGE, although Musk likely will not miss his federal paycheck since he is forgoing it. Congress could also pass legislation specifically banning the Musk special government employee role and rolling back what he and his team have done.
At the very least, Congress could hold oversight hearings — which Democrats have demanded — to find out what the heck is even going on.
Or, as the Framers intended, Congress could begin impeachment proceedings on the rationale that dismantling the government as we know it violates the Constitution.
Every member of Congress takes an oath to “support and defend the Constitution of the United States against all enemies, foreign and domestic.” The failure of Republicans in Congress to do anything about Musk — anything at all — may prove to be the most colossal violation of that sacred oath in American history.
Kimberly Wehle is author of the new book “Pardon Power: How the Pardon System Works — and Why.”
-
Mexico to reform constitution in wake of US terrorism designations
Mexico President Claudia Sheinbaum says she will propose reforms to the country’s constitution to protect Mexico’s sovereignty after U.S. President Donald Trump’s administration designated six ...ABC News - 17h -
Trump 2nd term live updates: Trump touts work of 1st month, praises Musk and DOGE
The chief counsel of the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives was fired and escorted out of her office, sources familiar with the matter told ABC News.ABC News - 5h -
Elon Musk Zeroes In on the I.R.S.
The tech mogul’s cost-cutting initiative is seeking sensitive taxpayer data, drawing concerns about privacy, potential political retribution and more.The New York Times - 2d -
Milwaukee Bucks' Bobby Portis suspended 25 games for violating NBA's anti-drug policy
Portis' agent, Mark Bartelstein, released a statement claiming the violation was essentially a mix-up.Yahoo Sports - 18h -
Milwaukee Bucks Bobby Portis Jr. suspended 25 games over drug policy violation
Milwaukee Bucks forward Bobby Portis, Jr., will miss Thursday's game against the Los Angeles Clippers after the NBA announced he violated the league's anti-drug policy.NBC News - 17h -
Shiri Bibas not among bodies returned from Gaza, Israel says, accusing Hamas of ‘serious violation’
IDF statement comes hours after Benjamin Netanyahu orders further crackdown on occupied West Bank over bus explosions. One of the four bodies returned by Hamas to Israel on Thursday is not that ...The Guardian - 59m -
Capitol agenda: GOP starts to balk at Musk cuts
Politico - 2d -
The Showdown Between Elon Musk and Sam Altman
This week, the Uncanny Valley hosts discuss the lawsuits, bidding wars, and power plays over OpenAI.Wired - 16h -
Elon Musk Is Focused on DOGE. What About Tesla?
Mr. Musk, one of President Trump’s main advisers, has not outlined a plan to reverse falling sales at the electric car company of which he is chief executive.The New York Times - 14h -
5 takeaways from Musk's CPAC talk
Elon Musk served as one of the main attractions at the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) on Thursday evening with a late-scheduled appearance that saw him wield a chainsaw and discuss ...The Hill - 8h
More from The Hill
-
Live updates: Musk takes the stage at CPAC; Senate vote-a-rama stretches into the night
Tech billionaire Elon Musk took the stage at this year's Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) with a late-scheduled appearance that saw him wield a chainsaw and discuss a range of ...The Hill - 5h -
China supports 'recent consensus' between US and Russia on Ukraine war, foreign minister says
China supports “the recent consensus” between the U.S. and Russia on the war in Ukraine, said Wang Yi, the country’s foreign minister, amid ongoing discussions about bringing an end to the nearly ...The Hill - 5h -
Former 'Squad' members launching 'Bowman and Bush' YouTube show
Former Reps. Cori Bush (D-Mo.) and Jamaal Bowman (D-N.Y.) are launching a YouTube show, according to a Thursday post from Bush on her Instagram. “I’m beyond excited to announce the launch of our ...The Hill - 7h -
Trump vows to add Black icons to proposed National Garden of American Heroes
President Trump shared plans to feature more than 10 Black historical figures in his proposed National Garden of American Heroes during a Thursday White House reception for Black History Month. ...The Hill - 8h -
Trump vents frustration with Boeing over Air Force One delays
President Trump is airing grievances with Boeing over delays in delivering new Air Force One jets, telling Republican governors on Thursday he was “getting a little tired” of the hold up. “I bought ...The Hill - 8h
More in Politics
-
Live updates: Musk takes the stage at CPAC; Senate vote-a-rama stretches into the night
Tech billionaire Elon Musk took the stage at this year's Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC) with a late-scheduled appearance that saw him wield a chainsaw and discuss a range of ...The Hill - 5h -
Georgia Republican faces crowd angered by DOGE layoffs
Rep. Rich McCormick faced a crowd at a town hall in Roswell, Georgia, that expressed anger about the layoffs and cuts implemented by Elon Musk's DOGE team.NBC News - 5h -
China supports 'recent consensus' between US and Russia on Ukraine war, foreign minister says
China supports “the recent consensus” between the U.S. and Russia on the war in Ukraine, said Wang Yi, the country’s foreign minister, amid ongoing discussions about bringing an end to the nearly ...The Hill - 5h -
Senate adopts fallback budget in case Trump’s ‘big, beautiful bill’ falters
Now the onus is on House Republicans to build enough support to advance their own party-line plan, or face pressure to back the Senate’s slimmer vision.Politico - 6h -
Fired Army veteran speaks out about federal layoffs
Army Veteran Nelson Feliz, Sr., who spent more than a decade working for the Department of Veterans Affairs, is speaking out about his experience as one of the many federal workers who was let go ...NBC News - 6h