Massachusetts highest court nixes legal rule on which ex gets the engagement ring
The Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court has overturned a 65-year-old rule that required judges to identify and give engagement rings to the wronged party in a break-up.
“More than six decades ago, we recognized that an antenuptial ring generally is understood to be a conditional gift and determined that the donor may recover the ring following a failed engagement, but only if the donor was ‘without fault,’” the court said, according to The Boston Globe. “We now join the modern trend adopted by the majority of jurisdictions that have considered the issue and retire the concept of fault.”
The new ruling states that the engagement ring must go to the party who purchased it “regardless of fault.”
Earlier this year, Bruce Johnson sued his former fiancée Caroline Settino over which of them should keep a $70,000 Tiffany engagement ring. Under this ruling, Settino must return the ring Johnson presented her in 2017, even though a Plymouth Superior Court judge previously found Johnson at fault for the end of the relationship after he wrongfully accused Settino of infidelity.
Most states view an engagement ring as a “conditional gift,” and Massachusetts now joins them in returning that gift to the donor.
Johnson’s attorney, Stephanie Taverna, said the ruling ends a legal standard that forced couples to reveal intimate details about their personal relationships.
“They modernized the law in the right direction by removing fault,” she said. “That’s why it's an important decision, because it helps parties settle issues among themselves without needing to litigate, just like the no-fault divorce statute did when that was enacted in 1975.”
Topics
-
Massachusetts court rules on who keeps engagement ring after breakup
Top stories - CBS News - Yesterday -
Highest court in Massachusetts to hear arguments in Karen Read's bid to dismiss murder charge
Top stories - NBC News - 6 days ago -
South Africa submits its main legal claim to the top UN court which accuses Israel of genocide
World - ABC News - October 28 -
Elon Musk's legal team delays possible ruling on $1M giveaways with federal court filing
Top stories - NBC News - October 31 -
A Massachusetts Couple Called Off Their Wedding. Who Keeps the $70,000 Ring?
Top stories - The New York Times - 3 days ago -
Massachusetts judge rules Meta must face state's social media lawsuit
Politics - The Hill - October 18 -
Trump courts Arab and Muslim support, with Harris criticized for 'not engaging'
Politics - The Hill - November 3
More from The Hill
-
Grover Norquist wins The Hill's 2024 elections prediction contest
Politics - The Hill - 30 minutes ago -
State: Israel not in violation of US law on humanitarian aid to Gaza
Politics - The Hill - 33 minutes ago -
Trump picks Mike Huckabee as US ambassador to Israel
Politics - The Hill - 33 minutes ago -
Personal care product use during pregnancy, lactation may increase exposure to ‘forever chemicals’: Study
Politics - The Hill - 37 minutes ago -
Trump's tariff proposal needs a makeover: A border-adjusted tax
Politics - The Hill - 37 minutes ago
Latest in Politics
-
Elon Musk worries free speech advocates with calls to prosecute researchers and critics
Politics - NBC News - 27 minutes ago -
Grover Norquist wins The Hill's 2024 elections prediction contest
Politics - The Hill - 30 minutes ago -
State: Israel not in violation of US law on humanitarian aid to Gaza
Politics - The Hill - 33 minutes ago -
Trump picks Mike Huckabee as US ambassador to Israel
Politics - The Hill - 33 minutes ago -
Personal care product use during pregnancy, lactation may increase exposure to ‘forever chemicals’: Study
Politics - The Hill - 37 minutes ago