Massachusetts judge rules Meta must face state's social media lawsuit
A Massachusetts Superior Court judge has ruled Meta must face a state lawsuit, alleging the company knowingly designed and deployed features harmful to young online users.
Suffolk County Superior Court Judge Peter Krupp issued the ruling Thursday in response to Meta's request to have the case tossed.
The social media giant argued the suit created a nuisance and violated Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, which can protect tech companies from being held liable for information uploaded by their users.
In his ruling, made public Friday, Krupp wrote Section 230 does not apply to the suit's claims due to Meta's own statements about its platforms' safety and publishing conduct.
Massachusetts was among dozens of states to file suit against Meta last year over accusations the company knowingly designed and implemented features that were detrimental to the mental health of young users.
In doing so, the tech company allegedly misrepresented the safety of its users to the public, the suits argue.
These allegations are not immune under Section 230 as they were "principally seeking to hold Meta liable for its own business conduct," rather than the content posted by third-party users, Krupp wrote.
The judge further rejected Meta's claim that the suit violates the First Amendment.
Calling the argument "unavailing," Krupp ruled the state's claims regard Meta's conduct and product design, not its expressive content.
"Meta has failed to establish that the claims are entirely based on protected speech or expression and that therefore dismissal is appropriate," he wrote.
A spokesperson for Meta said the company "disagrees" with the decision.
"We’ve developed numerous tools to support parents and teens, and we recently announced that we’re significantly changing the Instagram experience for tens of millions of teens with new Teen Accounts, a protected experience for teens that automatically limits who can contact them and the content they see," the spokesperson wrote in a statement to The Hill. "We believe the evidence will demonstrate our commitment to supporting young people.”
Krupp's ruling came two days after a federal judge in California similarly rejected Meta's bid to dismiss lawsuits by more than 30 states over the same allegations, Reuters reported.
Massachusetts was one of a few states to file claims in their own states rather than on a federal level.
Court documents part of Massachusetts's case offered insight last year into Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg's alleged role in making decisions about features for teens on the platform.
According to the unredacted lawsuit filed by Massachusetts Attorney General Andrea Campbell (D), Zuckerberg allegedly halted proposals aimed at improving Facebook and Instagram’s impact on teen mental health.
The CEO is accused of vetoing plans to ban filters that simulate plastic surgery on Meta-owned platforms and ignored requests from top executives to boost investments in teens' well-being.
A Meta spokesperson pushed back on these allegations at the time.
The suits come as Meta platforms, including Instagram and Facebook, along with other social media companies face increasing scrutiny from lawmakers and parents over social media’s impact on youth safety and mental health.
Updated at 7:02 p.m. EDT
Date: |
Topics
-
Business - Inc.
Meta Will Face State Lawsuits Alleging Teen Social Media Addiction
Despite efforts to have two cases dismissed, the parent company of Instagram and Facebook will have a legal reckoning over allegations its platforms harm younger users.2 days ago -
Business - Inc.
Social Media Layoffs Hit Meta
The tech giant confirmed an unspecified number of job cuts at WhatsApp and Instagram.Yesterday - Meta -
Top stories - BBC News
Social media faces big changes under new Ofcom rules
Ofcom warns social media companies could face fines if they don’t comply with the new Online Safety BillYesterday -
Politics - The Hill
Georgia judge rules county election officials must certify election results
A Georgia judge ruled Tuesday that county election officials may not delay or decline to certify election results based on suspicions of fraud. Fulton County Superior Judge Robert McBurney wrote in ...3 days ago -
Top stories - NBC News
Local election officials in Georgia must certify results, judge rules
County election boards in Georgia are not allowed to refuse to certify election results, a state judge ruled on Tuesday.3 days ago -
Health - ABC News
Judge dismisses lawsuit over old abortion rights ruling in Mississippi
A Mississippi judge has dismissed a lawsuit that challenged a potential conflict between a 2022 state law that bans most abortions and a 1998 state Supreme Court ruling that said abortion is ...2 days ago - Abortion -
Business - Financial Times
Social media must do more to tackle payment fraud, says UK regulator
Ministers urged to consider levy on tech groups to compensate victims of online scams4 days ago - United Kingdom -
Top stories - CBS News
Georgia judge invalidates controversial new state election rules
The seven rules thrown out by a Georgia judge include one that required the number of ballots be hand-counted after the close of polls.2 days ago -
Top stories - NBC News
Royal Caribbean facing lawsuit after ex-crew member put hidden cameras in state rooms
Royal Caribbean is facing legal trouble after passengers filed a lawsuit over hidden cameras placed in state rooms by a former employee.16 hours ago
More from The Hill
-
Politics - The Hill
Watch live: Harris rallies suburban voters outside Detroit
Vice President Harris is rallying voters outside of Detroit on Friday evening, concluding this week's swing through the "blue wall" battleground states. With just 18 days left until Election Day, ...1 hour ago - Kamala Harris -
Politics - The Hill
Defense contractor Raytheon to pay almost $1B for defrauding DOD
Raytheon Co., part of parent defense contractor RTX, will pay more than $950 million to resolve Justice Department allegations that it defrauded the Defense Department (DOD) and paid bribes to a ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
Boeing supplier Spirit Aero to furlough employees amid strike
Spirit AeroSystems announced plans to furlough 700 workers for 21 days Friday due to the ongoing Boeing employee strike. The company’s hourly direct, support functions and management employees in ...1 hour ago -
Politics - The Hill
Chris Wallace: Questions about Trump's fitness 'working for Harris'
CNN host Chris Wallace said that questions about former President Trump’s physical state, well-being and age are working in favor of Vice President Harris. “This question of mental and physical ...2 hours ago - Donald Trump -
Politics - The Hill
Biden gives geothermal a boost
{beacon} Energy & Environment Energy & Environment The Big Story Biden administration gives geothermal energy a boost The administration proposed this week to speed up approvals for geothermal ...2 hours ago - Joe Biden